Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Bookvine.io – Help find age appropriate books for kids aged 6 to 14

bookvine.io

11–20 of 60 posts

Re: Show HN: Bookvine.io – Help find age appropriate books for kids aged 6 to 14

#11

This is a difficult problem to solve for some kids, because there are at least two dimensions to consider: - language difficulty (which is what lexile aims to measure) - how appropriate the topic is My 5.5yo son is decoding words at about 4th grade level (based on an informal 'San Diego Quick Assessment'). But he's limited in his reading by: - his life experience and existing knowledge, which both affect comprehensio…

Totally agree. My boys are reading at an extremely high level. I wish sites like these were a grid of topical and reading level.

Re: Show HN: Bookvine.io – Help find age appropriate books for kids aged 6 to 14

#12
I always found it interesting how different books for teenagers were from movies considered appropriate for the same age group.

For example, the "Cherub" series by Robert Muchamore, which I greatly enjoyed as a kid, included crime, drug and alcohol use (even by kids), sex scenes, mentions of underage prostitution and human trafficking, and even a scene of an attempted rape on a minor. The much more popular "Hunger Games" series was a little bit less violent, but not by much. Nobody seemed to mind. Those books were clearly intended for teenagers, I'd say 12-16 year olds, and there were no disclaimers about what those books contained.

Even with TV, things aren't as obvious as they seem. Over here in Poland, very few parents care about age restrictions. Unlike English, we don't even have a word for "explicit content". Creating online accounts with fake dates of birth is pretty much normal. When I was in middle school, most people I knew watched porn with very few difficulties. Game stores don't have any obligations to restrict what kids can buy, it's not even clear if refusing a game sale based solely on the age of the buyer is legal[1]. When one game store refused to sell GTA5 to a kid, I heard about it on the news. When I compare people of my generation raised in Poland to our American peers, where explicit content is much more of a taboo, I see no noticeable effects of watching such content.

This has some disturbing censorship implications, how many real-life phenomena are filmmakers omitting to get just a little bit more viewers, just because of some well-intended laws that seem to have no actual positive effect on society?

[1] Polish https://bezprawnik.pl/sprzedaz-dziecku-gry-dla-doroslych/

Re: Show HN: Bookvine.io – Help find age appropriate books for kids aged 6 to 14

#13

Well done, this is great. I’ve already sent my wife a link to it. We are mostly through the original magic treehouse series and we need a new book series to read to our 4 year old. Amazon search is a wasteland for this sort of thing. Let’s talk SEO. You need pages like this: books-for-6-year-olds books-for-7-year-olds Etc We have a site crontab.guru and you would not believe the traffic we get on our “every n minutes…

Haha I love crontab.guru! It fits perfectly for me who uses cron schedules only 1-2 times a year, just infrequently enough to forget the format before needing it again.

Re: Show HN: Bookvine.io – Help find age appropriate books for kids aged 6 to 14

#15
post #10

This is a difficult problem to solve for some kids, because there are at least two dimensions to consider: - language difficulty (which is what lexile aims to measure) - how appropriate the topic is My 5.5yo son is decoding words at about 4th grade level (based on an informal 'San Diego Quick Assessment'). But he's limited in his reading by: - his life experience and existing knowledge, which both affect comprehensio…

Totally agree with you on all the points. As with most recommendations - YMMV. This is just to provide a guideline/reference. The way I recommend seeing this list is - say your kid likes "The Penderwicks" then..."hey are few other books that are similar to The Penderwicks"

Yes, definitely. I hope my comment didn't come across as criticism! I love seeing sites like your kid's.

I was more lamenting the general difficulty of the problem. (And possibly just the lack of books that are suitable for kids who are advanced at reading, but have interests similar to other kids their age.)

Re: Show HN: Bookvine.io – Help find age appropriate books for kids aged 6 to 14

#16
Thank you for this.

Suggestion: I'm looking at the 10-14 list. When I click "Next Page", it retains the "book series" section on top and the actual next page I have to scroll halfway down the screen to see. I'm not expecting to have to skip over the book series section again to get to the next page of individual books. Difficult and confusing, at best.

Re: Show HN: Bookvine.io – Help find age appropriate books for kids aged 6 to 14

#17

Quoted post unavailable.

The About page answers this in detail: https://www.bookvine.io/about-page

Overall, this appears to be a learning project for a middle schooler and his dad as well as a way for them to cover costs through affiliate links. While this might be a fun and useful way to discover new books, you should read the reviews and cross-reference your findings with parental or specialty groups like teachclean.com if you are concerned about the subject matter.

Re: Show HN: Bookvine.io – Help find age appropriate books for kids aged 6 to 14

#18

Quoted post unavailable.

The About page answers this in detail: https://www.bookvine.io/about-page Overall, this appears to be a learning project for a middle schooler and his dad as well as a way for them to cover costs through affiliate links. While this might be a fun and useful way to discover new books, you should read the reviews and cross-reference your findings with parental or specialty groups like teachclean.com if you are concerne…

thank you for that answer, I will look..

Re: Show HN: Bookvine.io – Help find age appropriate books for kids aged 6 to 14

#19

Quoted post unavailable.

Out of curiosity, why did you put quotes around the word "marriage"? Am I correctly interpreting your comment as implying that same-sex marriage is not legitimate, and that children should not be aware of its existence (or at least, that its inclusion makes a book inappropriate for children)?

Re: Show HN: Bookvine.io – Help find age appropriate books for kids aged 6 to 14

#20

This is a difficult problem to solve for some kids, because there are at least two dimensions to consider: - language difficulty (which is what lexile aims to measure) - how appropriate the topic is My 5.5yo son is decoding words at about 4th grade level (based on an informal 'San Diego Quick Assessment'). But he's limited in his reading by: - his life experience and existing knowledge, which both affect comprehensio…

A few you might check out:

The Humphrey the hamster series

The Zoey and Sassafras series

The Secret Explorers series

Alice in Wonderland

Some Beverly Cleary books

Many of the DK nonfiction books

Post reply on HN