EDIT: What I mean by uncensored nudity/sexuality is showing actual genitalia or depictions of sexual acts, as in what you'd expect to see in pornography, except I wouldn't call it pornography here - it would have the same "realism" effect as what is currently done on the violence fronts. As far as I know, no mainstream media has made such depictions so far.
Ask HN: Why do we accept gore in movies/games but not nudity/sex in sitcoms?
1–10 of 22 posts
Re: Ask HN: Why do we accept gore in movies/games but not nudity/sex in sitcoms?
#2Re: Ask HN: Why do we accept gore in movies/games but not nudity/sex in sitcoms?
#3Re: Ask HN: Why do we accept gore in movies/games but not nudity/sex in sitcoms?
#4For what it's worth, I think it goes back to latent Puritanism.
Re: Ask HN: Why do we accept gore in movies/games but not nudity/sex in sitcoms?
#5Mainstream Media doesn't want it, enter Showtime and HBO.
I watch movies and play games that I wouldn't want my six year old to be exposed to when he was flipping the channels? Like Leonidas in 300. My kid would have nightmares for days!!!
Re: Ask HN: Why do we accept gore in movies/games but not nudity/sex in sitcoms?
#6Because buying a movie or a game is much more intentional in the sense that it appeals to a specific demographic that has opted in (my grandma would HATE Half Life or any most rated R movies, but is way less offended by a sexual reference in a sitcom). Mainstream Media doesn't want it, enter Showtime and HBO. I watch movies and play games that I wouldn't want my six year old to be exposed to when he was flipping the…
Re: Ask HN: Why do we accept gore in movies/games but not nudity/sex in sitcoms?
#7Because we've somehow as a culture made the decision that violence is to be glorified, but sex and bodies are still shameful — except, apparently, when we use them to sell things, and even then we can only be suggestive , not explicit.
Re: Ask HN: Why do we accept gore in movies/games but not nudity/sex in sitcoms?
#8Re: Ask HN: Why do we accept gore in movies/games but not nudity/sex in sitcoms?
#9One recent "sitcom" that has nudity, including some male nudity, is "Togetherness" which does it well and is also v.funny.
In the UK we have breasts printed in a (well selling) daily newspaper but we're a bit cautious about what gets shown at what times on TV. We have a concept called "the watershed" (9.00PM) Programmes shown before that have to be a bit careful about what they show; programmes shown after that can be more relaxed about what they show. The fines for the Janet Jackson wardrobe malfunction probably wouldn't happen over here.
Re: Ask HN: Why do we accept gore in movies/games but not nudity/sex in sitcoms?
#10The two aren't equivalent. Plenty of movies contain nudity\sex as well as violence and gore. Movies have ratings and are somewhat protected( ticket sales to R rated movies are restricted to 18+ in the US) therefore they have greater latitude in what they are allowed to do. Also the FCC has a number of decency rules that broadcast channels have to follow. That is why most TV shows with any "stronger" content is on a c…