Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Are you using an agent orchestrator to write code?

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 67 posts

Ask HN: Are you using an agent orchestrator to write code?

#1
In a recent interview with The Pragmatic Engineer, Steve Yegge said he feels "sorry for people" who merely "use Cursor, ask it questions sometimes, review its code really carefully, and then check it in."

Instead, he recommends engineers integrate LLMs into their workflow more and more, until they are managing multiple agents at one time. The final level in his AI Coding chart reads: "Level 8: you build your own orchestrator to coordinate more agents."

At my work, this wouldn't fly-- we're still doing things the sorry way. Are you using orchestrators to manage multiple agents at work? Particularly interested in non-greenfield applications and how that's changed your SDLC.

Re: Ask HN: Are you using an agent orchestrator to write code?

#2
No, I don't even use agents to generate code most of the time. I mainly use the inline assistant to modify or fill out blocks of code, and agents sometimes for refactors, asking questions, search, debugging, generating documentation etc.

I feel bad for Yegge.

Re: Ask HN: Are you using an agent orchestrator to write code?

#5
No point. Claude Code with skills and subagents is plenty. If they would stop breaking it constantly it would be fine.

The bottleneck has not been how quickly you can generate reasonable code for a good while now. It’s how quickly you can integrate and deploy it and how much operational toil it causes. On any team > 1, that’s going to rely on getting a lot of people to work together effectively too, and it turns out that’s a completely different problem with different solutions.

Re: Ask HN: Are you using an agent orchestrator to write code?

#6
I think people should figure out what works for them rather than letting people on the internet gate-keep what is good. Everything is about personal choices and refining your own taste. I would not be happy being unable to understand everything deeply so having a million agents all doing stuff would just cause me a load of stress even if I could churn stuff out more quickly.

Re: Ask HN: Are you using an agent orchestrator to write code?

#7
> Steve Yegge said he feels "sorry for people" who merely "use Cursor, ask it questions sometimes, review its code really carefully, and then check it in."

Steve Yegge is building a multi-agent orchestration system. This is him trying to FOMO listeners into using his project.

From what I've observed, the people trying to use herds of agents to work on different things at the same time are just using tokens as fast as possible because they think more tokens means more progress. As you scale up the sub-agents you spend so much time managing the herd and trying to backtrack when things go wrong that you would have been better off handling it serially with yourself in the loop.

If you don't have someone else paying the bill for unlimited token usage it's going to be a very expensive experiment.

Re: Ask HN: Are you using an agent orchestrator to write code?

#8
post #5

No point. Claude Code with skills and subagents is plenty. If they would stop breaking it constantly it would be fine. The bottleneck has not been how quickly you can generate reasonable code for a good while now. It’s how quickly you can integrate and deploy it and how much operational toil it causes. On any team > 1, that’s going to rely on getting a lot of people to work together effectively too, and it turns out…

What if you could remove that toil.

Re: Ask HN: Are you using an agent orchestrator to write code?

#9
The stumbling block we have is spinning up separate environments for every agent so they have isolation for their branches. I think this is solveable, but we aren't trying to solve it ourselves. In practice it means we aren't doing a lot of agent supervision.

Re: Ask HN: Are you using an agent orchestrator to write code?

#10
"Claude writes, Codex reviews" has shown huge promise as a pattern for me, so I wrote a Dockerfile and some instructions on how to make that happen for agents, and ended up with https://github.com/pjlsergeant/moarcode

I am spending most of my day in this harness. It has rough edges for sure, but it means I trust the code coming out much more than I did just Claude.

Post reply on HN