Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Will you use software that has telemetry on by default?

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 25 posts

Re: Ask HN: Will you use software that has telemetry on by default?

#2
The answer for me is a hard no, but I'm curious what others think. The justification often used is that it's the only way to "make the product better". That's not been my experience as either a developer or user. My favorite tools are opinionated and created by people with a desire to solve a problem and good UX skills (think git, vim...). My least favorite tools are corporate software that was obviously built and designed by committee.

Re: Ask HN: Will you use software that has telemetry on by default?

#3

The answer for me is a hard no, but I'm curious what others think. The justification often used is that it's the only way to "make the product better". That's not been my experience as either a developer or user. My favorite tools are opinionated and created by people with a desire to solve a problem and good UX skills (think git, vim...). My least favorite tools are corporate software that was obviously built and de…

This could be a good use of HN's polling system [1]. To answer your question I would not and if required to use it I would make a serious attempt to block or spoof it make it think it's sending data to the right place.

[1] - https://news.ycombinator.com/newpoll

Re: Ask HN: Will you use software that has telemetry on by default?

#4

The answer for me is a hard no, but I'm curious what others think. The justification often used is that it's the only way to "make the product better". That's not been my experience as either a developer or user. My favorite tools are opinionated and created by people with a desire to solve a problem and good UX skills (think git, vim...). My least favorite tools are corporate software that was obviously built and de…

if i was bored, i would lift the telemetry monster out, and subvert it to send spoofs.

Re: Ask HN: Will you use software that has telemetry on by default?

#9
It's possible I've let myself develop too negative a knee jerk reaction to the idea of telemetry. Sometimes I've lost a feature I use in a product that I'd turned off the telemetry for, and the developers cited low usage of that feature. Did I shoot myself in the foot?

Re: Ask HN: Will you use software that has telemetry on by default?

#10

The answer for me is a hard no, but I'm curious what others think. The justification often used is that it's the only way to "make the product better". That's not been my experience as either a developer or user. My favorite tools are opinionated and created by people with a desire to solve a problem and good UX skills (think git, vim...). My least favorite tools are corporate software that was obviously built and de…

You also don't use anything in the Google ecosystem, or Facebook, or any online apps? Those all have telemetry..
Post reply on HN