Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How Do You Utilize Your Personal Knowledge Base?

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 34 posts

Ask HN: How Do You Utilize Your Personal Knowledge Base?

#1
I am always intrigued to read about how individuals construct, organize, maintain, and expand their personal knowledge bases. There's a wide range of tools at our disposal, including Obsidian, Notion, Markdown and plaintext, Zotero, Evernote, among others. Likewise, organizational structures are just as diverse - anyone here a fan of Zettelkasten?

Despite a couple of serious attempts, committing to the process for a few months each time, I've rarely found myself referring back to the stored information. More importantly, the process of adding to and maintaining the knowledge base felt more burdensome than beneficial. I've tried adjusting the content and format of what I'm storing in an attempt to make the experience more manageable, but to no avail.

My main motivation for exploring this further is my growing concern about my recollection ability as I age, and I'd like to fully exploit the available tools to counteract this.

So, for those of you who do have a functioning system that you use regularly - regardless of its simplicity or complexity - how do you employ it to retrieve information or enhance your understanding of topics? Insights into how your system operates would be useful, but are secondary for me at this point. I feel like I've read about all the possible configurations a system could have, yet I'm skeptical about the tangible benefits they can provide. I would be delighted to be proven wrong.

Re: Ask HN: How Do You Utilize Your Personal Knowledge Base?

#2
I have a smart RSS reader I am working on called YOShInOn. The main UI looks like TikTok or Stumbleupon, I can thumbs up, thumbs down or favorite articles, out of maybe 2000 articles a day it picks maybe 300 to show me, maybe I really read 200 on the average day.

Once the articles get favorited though there is the problem of navigating them, I just added some simple text search capability but there is a huge amount of room for improvement there. If it gets the ability to ingest articles via bookmarklet than it becomes a bookmark manager, add some ability to enter notes locally and it becomes a more general knowledge base manager.

It could really use "tags" but when it does these will be tags for the ML age, particularly it will be possible to have positive, negative and indeterminate tags. If the ML system thinks a tag applies it goes into indeterminate status and could be set to negative or positive to make it a training example.

Re: Ask HN: How Do You Utilize Your Personal Knowledge Base?

#3
I keep everything on a wiki I run on a home server.

Over the decades, I think I've tried just about every method of maintaining my knowledge base, project notes, to-do lists, etc. And the only one that works even halfway decently for me is a wiki.

It's searchable, the simplicity of markup means I won't get side-tracked into wasting time on layout and eye candy, it's easy to search, if I have internet access then I can access it from anywhere, and the wiki I use allows simple embedded spreadsheets and other such functionality for more complex data.

Plus, it's very easy to allow others secure access to it for when I want to share notes, or keep notes that are updated by multiple people (such as when collaborating on a project), or to distribute very large files.

Re: Ask HN: How Do You Utilize Your Personal Knowledge Base?

#4
I keep all my zettles at https://wiki.malloc.dog/.

When I was doing my masters in anthropology at the same time as my SWE job, I ran into this issue of having too many notes and not enough organization. Random other tools never quite did it, generic search didn't work, notion et all kind of sucked, so I ended up rolling my own thing on top of Org roam. It's all plaintext org files, easily accessible.

When I do scholarly work, it's great because all of stuff is in one place. It's also useful for tracking the breadcrumbs I do for my real tech job.

Re: Ask HN: How Do You Utilize Your Personal Knowledge Base?

#7
The secret sauce is orgmode in emacs.

My personal notes are a .org file that is backed up on a private GitHub repo.

I have sprawled about 5k lines at this point since around 2020.

Some things get a org-bullet (*) and a TODO.

Then I just do org-agenda and it pulls up a nice view of all my TODO items for pruning and prioritising.

Having an automatic agenda and the fact the bullets are tab-collapsible and can be used as an outliner is the only way my notes are not out of control.

My other writing is in apple notes (short lived) or exists in tickets. I’ve tried various things like zettlekasten and obsidian but nothing sticks for me.

My other daily task setting and personal planning is a bullet journal with a future log and monthly logs. Bullet journaling is how to get it all out and process and plan personal things. Actual Knowledge is in the org-mode.

For email I follow getting things done and have an inbox an @action and a @waiting folder. I keep inbox empty and the others get pruned every day.

Re: Ask HN: How Do You Utilize Your Personal Knowledge Base?

#8

The secret sauce is orgmode in emacs. My personal notes are a .org file that is backed up on a private GitHub repo. I have sprawled about 5k lines at this point since around 2020. Some things get a org-bullet (*) and a TODO. Then I just do org-agenda and it pulls up a nice view of all my TODO items for pruning and prioritising. Having an automatic agenda and the fact the bullets are tab-collapsible and can be used as…

Lol...

    % wc -l `find . -name \*.org`
    ...
    361427 total

Re: Ask HN: How Do You Utilize Your Personal Knowledge Base?

#9
I use Joplin and I am playing with emacs orgmode. So far Joplin has been a lot better at finding stuff I forgot about but knew a few letters that would be there (like ssh). I have many 1000s of notes; from emacs to notepad to ms docs to onenote to I forgot to Evernote to vim to notion to Joplin. And maybe back to the emacs. I use and have used it daily ; it makes me think clearer to write things down before implementing or discussing. I basically write down my mind voice to remember it verbatim.

Re: Ask HN: How Do You Utilize Your Personal Knowledge Base?

#10
My motivation was multi-sided and I went with a completely ad-hoc structure. I store different kinds of information in very different ways. I sometimes reorganize a section. I don't use any monolithic or gate-keeping tool - the information and data is far more important than the tools. The oldest sections go back about 30 years. I have a few conclusions:

(1) It takes time to reach critical mass. Until then, it's overhead. But even then some content was useful from the very start.(2) After that it became very reliable - it's there and I rely on it. (3) For me, it's clearly not just knowledge base, it's PIM - personal information management - KB is just mixed with the rest. (4) After decades, retrieval is still a mix of ideas and tools - not great. (5) I still wish for more efficient data entry / collection.

In balance, for sure a majority of the content is never accessed.That's fine. The system allows un-foreseen uses to happen commmonly and I like that. Do the positives outweigh the costs over the years? I have no idea. I add stuff constantly, some things I rely on again and again, some query ideas are one offs... and usually they work which is great. I know I have a very solid base for recollection. It's not clear how I would do a cost/benefit analysis.

I feel perfectly fine with the ad-hoc collection and storage strategy. That has worked well enough.

Post reply on HN