Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What do you recommend to build desktop apps?

news.ycombinator.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

1–7 of 7 posts

Ask HN: What do you recommend to build desktop apps?

#1

Post by mc »

What's your favorite SDK (or framework or toolkit) for building desktop apps?

I've got few requirements: - Cross-platform (Can build and distribute Windows, Mac, & Linux executables)

  - Great documentation

  - Open source or commercial licensing
I do Java and Ruby programming, so there a few that come to mind:

  * Swing

  * SWT

  * HotCocoa
I've also found:

  * Qt

  * wxWidgets
If you've used one of these SDKs, was it successful? Did you get the job done on time? What was the learning curve like?

Thanks

Re: Ask HN: What do you recommend to build desktop apps?

#2

Post by kls »

If I where doing a Desktop Java app, I think I would take the time to learn JavaFX. While I don't think we will see widespread adoption, I do think most people will favor it over swing. I did a simple app in it and I prefer it to swing. Take my advise with a grain of salt though, I have not been deep in desktop for a long time. It was a fluke that I had a Java desktop app contract.

Re: Ask HN: What do you recommend to build desktop apps?

#3

Post by davyjones »

Mine is Qt.

I am developing an admin client for PostgreSQL: pgXplorer (github.com/davyjones/pgXplorer). I was coding primary on a Windows platform and decided at some point that a Linux build would be useful as well. I was surprised when the project compiled the first time I imported it into my Linux environment, and that too without any tweaks. So yeah...more than surprised actually.

But...there are some issues I am facing with window behaviour, mouse events, etc. Still working on that.

Re: Ask HN: What do you recommend to build desktop apps?

#4

Post by thejteam »

davyjones wrote: post #3

Mine is Qt. I am developing an admin client for PostgreSQL: pgXplorer (github.com/davyjones/pgXplorer). I was coding primary on a Windows platform and decided at some point that a Linux build would be useful as well. I was surprised when the project compiled the first time I imported it into my Linux environment, and that too without any tweaks. So yeah...more than surprised actually. But...there are some issues I am…

We use QT extensively at work. It is the best documented framework that I have ever worked with. I am primarily a C programmer who dislikes GUIs, but the it has made GUI development pretty painless for me. Their networking classes are also good.
Post reply on HN