Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Are you leaving Heroku?

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 114 posts

Ask HN: Are you leaving Heroku?

#1
It seems like Heroku has been dying on a vine. The platform is still incredible and unmatched in Developer Experience, but recent security incidents (along with a severely prolonged resolution), downtime, and (just yesterday) a DNS-related issue is making me reconsider and quite possibly will move some mission-critical apps to AWS.

Are you migrating away from Heroku? If so, which cloud provider are you using (AWS, Google Cloud, Azure, etc)? What's your stack and what service are you migrating to (ECS, Elastic Beanstalk, etc)?

Re: Ask HN: Are you leaving Heroku?

#3
3 years ago, I tried Heroku and was quite impressed by it. Although the price is prohibitive for a hobby project that needed resources but wasn't generating any revenue, I had to start seeking other options.

Ended up developing my own Heroku but focused on Django deployments.

Three years later, it works like a charm and has many happy folks who thank me for making it.

Meet Appliku: https://appliku.com

Re: Ask HN: Are you leaving Heroku?

#4
All of the companies I've worked for in the last few years who were Rails stack on Heroku have or were migrating to k8s deployments on the big three (AWS/GCP/Azure). For personal apps I'm looking at consolidating my stuff to Digital Ocean.

Re: Ask HN: Are you leaving Heroku?

#5
I was pretty unhappy with the outage last night. All the user blogs for https://bearblog.dev went down for about an hour and a half (and I had so many emails to respond to this morning).

I'm looking to move Bear over to either a Digital Ocean droplet (I have the staging server running on one with SQlite and Litestream running, and believe it could actually scale well), or to Fly.io (to be seen).

Re: Ask HN: Are you leaving Heroku?

#7
Short answer: no.

Every year I try out new things (fly, render), but stick with heroku because I'd rather focus on building products and not devops.

I'm a solo dev making $700k a year on my projects. I'm happy to pay the extra cost for things to just work.

If there is a catastrophic issue though, I do have backups elsewhere that I will use.

Re: Ask HN: Are you leaving Heroku?

#8
I was happy with Heroku for a while but had to leave it because of request timeouts being limited to 60 seconds (my app is a scraping api and sometimes requests take more time).

I switched to Appliku and never looked back. Setting up CI/CD pipeline for EC2 can be complicated and with AppLiku I get the Heroku experience without the limitations.

Re: Ask HN: Are you leaving Heroku?

#10
post #2

You might also note there has been little to no feature development for Heroku in some time

Not just that, trivial bugs aren't getting fixed. The charts showing response times, for instance, sometimes go crazy when you change the settings for time window or interval.
Post reply on HN