From what I've read it seems all too dystopian to me so I'm wondering if there's anything redeeming about the concept that I'm just not seeing.
Ask HN: Are there any actual redeeming qualities of the metaverse concept?
1–8 of 8 posts
Re: Ask HN: Are there any actual redeeming qualities of the metaverse concept?
#2Will Facebook be at the center?
I know the only real VR headsets Best Buy sells are from Oculus (Facebook.). With stimulus cash burning a hole in my pockets I thought about buying a VR system and found that competitors for Oculus are more expensive relative than what you get considerably. No way am I logging into Facebook, but most folks won’t care.
That might not turn into a meaningful advantage.
See the movie Ready Player One that makes Zuckerberg look like a clueless follower instead of a bold leader. Sword Art Online particularly in the arcs after the death game is better science fiction, but Spielberg tamed the nostalgia of the book to make something which I think speaks to all generations in the ‘West’ and is a great jumping off point for conversations.
Re: Ask HN: Are there any actual redeeming qualities of the metaverse concept?
#3Re: Ask HN: Are there any actual redeeming qualities of the metaverse concept?
#4The problem is that everyone wants to “simulate” reality. I’m not interested in that. No one wants to go to a virtual mall. They want to be somewhere unique. A game. A story. Something… else.
Re: Ask HN: Are there any actual redeeming qualities of the metaverse concept?
#5Imagine collaborative art sculptures in the park that you only see of you want to. Cool art without disrupting the physical space. This is just one example. What might science or history class be like? Empathy training?
I think there will be so many new ways of interacting with technology and each other, that the positives will outweigh the negatives.
Re: Ask HN: Are there any actual redeeming qualities of the metaverse concept?
#6Games already implement a usable metaverse environment, which is why we see things like concerts in Fortnite, etc..
And AR games like Pokémon Go already connect a virtual environment to the real world.
Re: Ask HN: Are there any actual redeeming qualities of the metaverse concept?
#7The problem is that everyone wants to “simulate” reality. I’m not interested in that. No one wants to go to a virtual mall. They want to be somewhere unique. A game. A story. Something… else.
Precisely. I don't understand that part of it either... owning virtual Nike sneakers or virtual land? Why? Idk, maybe I'm just old.
Re: Ask HN: Are there any actual redeeming qualities of the metaverse concept?
#8The problem is that everyone wants to “simulate” reality. I’m not interested in that. No one wants to go to a virtual mall. They want to be somewhere unique. A game. A story. Something… else.
Precisely. I don't understand that part of it either... owning virtual Nike sneakers or virtual land? Why? Idk, maybe I'm just old.
If you had it all in a unitary system like the OASIS from Ready Player One it might be possible but unless all the games are under the same framework it would take a lot of coordination.