Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: I purchased a domain and now the registry wants to take it back

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 76 posts

Ask HN: I purchased a domain and now the registry wants to take it back

#1
I purchased a very nice .io domain 2 days ago and I received an email from my registar today saying there was a bug in the registry and that the domain should not have been available so they are going to cancel my registration.

Right now I own the domain. What can I do? Is it okay for registries to do this? Does it happen often?

Thanks!

Re: Ask HN: I purchased a domain and now the registry wants to take it back

#3
post #2

Can you transfer it to a different registry?

The registry is the .io registry so it's bound to the domain (so no)

I might be able to transfer it to another registar, but I'm not sure it would help (the registar is Gandi and I trust them)

Re: Ask HN: I purchased a domain and now the registry wants to take it back

#5
If they screwed up somehow, they're kind of obligated to fix it. Otherwise, they just stole somebody else's domain and let you register it.

I would be a little skeptical. Make sure that the email really is from your registrar. Also, it's likely that "do nothing" is your best course of action, in any case. If the email is legitimate, there's nothing you can do to stop them. If it's a scam of some kind, you avoid increasing your exposure to risk.

Re: Ask HN: I purchased a domain and now the registry wants to take it back

#6

This is part and parcel of participating in the centralized domain name system.

Absolutely. I'm not screaming that's it's unfair or anything. The good things about centralized systems like this is that there are rules and laws. If the ICANN rule says the registry can do that in this case, then fine, I won't fight. But I would like to make sure it's really the case.

Re: Ask HN: I purchased a domain and now the registry wants to take it back

#7
2 Days ago management of .io registry was transfered from Afilias to Donuts (Due to an acquisition). It is likely that during that window you registered the domain and they are now cleaning up the issue. It may be your registrar took your registration and then when they went to actually process it the registry was down, so someone else got it during that period. It could be other things, however, the bottom line is that the domain was probably never yours and there is really not much to do here. It's bad timing and bad handling of a process on your registrars end.

Re: Ask HN: I purchased a domain and now the registry wants to take it back

#8
post #5

If they screwed up somehow, they're kind of obligated to fix it. Otherwise, they just stole somebody else's domain and let you register it. I would be a little skeptical. Make sure that the email really is from your registrar. Also, it's likely that "do nothing" is your best course of action, in any case. If the email is legitimate, there's nothing you can do to stop them. If it's a scam of some kind, you avoid incre…

The thing I'm wondering is whether the registry is not trying to get the domain back for them (which would be possible given the domain).

I cannot find any trace of the domain on the internet, so at least I don't think it was used. I don't know if there is some kind of way back machine for domain name records / whois ?

Re: Ask HN: I purchased a domain and now the registry wants to take it back

#9

2 Days ago management of .io registry was transfered from Afilias to Donuts (Due to an acquisition). It is likely that during that window you registered the domain and they are now cleaning up the issue. It may be your registrar took your registration and then when they went to actually process it the registry was down, so someone else got it during that period. It could be other things, however, the bottom line is t…

At least right now I control the domain. I think the registry messed up as they allowed my registration, not the registar.

Thanks for the info on the migration, that could indeed explain this.

Post reply on HN