Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Any colleges or universities offering credit for CS courses by exam?

news.ycombinator.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

1–10 of 16 posts

Ask HN: Any colleges or universities offering credit for CS courses by exam?

#1

Post by rateofchange »

Looking to attempt to accelerate reaching a BS in CS. Having worked as a software developer for decades, I can teach any introductory, intermediate and most advanced programming courses. Anything from basics to data structures, algorithms, computer architecture, embedded systems, real time operating systems, web development, etc. I have worked with over half a dozen languages on various systems, including everything from bare-metal bring-ups in Assembly/Forth to, robotics systems and Python/Django applications.

The point is, I know this stuff. What I know is equivalent to several years of university coursework. I am now interested in obtaining a degree in CS, initially a BS and possibly going on to an MS. This is mostly for personal fulfillment rather than a need.

What I don't want to do is spend three years writing basic code I can write in my sleep.

To this end, I am looking for schools where I might be able to take exams to pass courses rather than have to devote entire semesters or quarters to obtain the credit. I contacted our local college's CS department. While the school does offer credit for prior learning through examination, the CS department is the only one that does not, at this time, offer that option.

There are many interesting online CS courses (For example, I've done the MIT 6.00.1x series), yet none of them provide transferable credits. Does such a thing exist?

An alternative would be super-short terms. If I could take courses that only go for, say, 8 weeks, instead of 20, well, that might be a decent option. I would not have to study much, if at all. So, pass a couple of exams every eight weeks and knock out a few years off a degree timeline quickly.

I'd appreciate any input on this.

Frankly, this is what is missing in online education today. A degree granting program that is compatible with people who might have acquired the knowledge outside university walls. Coding is coding. Algorithms are algorithms. Theory is theory. If you know the subject, and you can prove it, it should not matter one bit where you did the learning.

Thanks.

Re: Ask HN: Any colleges or universities offering credit for CS courses by exam?

#3

Post by WheelsAtLarge »

A lot of schools offer credit by exam for the intro classes. Very few people take advantage of the opportunity so it's not highly known. You need to be enrolled and you need to look in the school's catalog to see what they offer. You can even take the exam in one school and transfer the credits to another school where you want to graduate. Look at junior colleges. They are easy to enroll in and you can transfers the credits to a four year university. Don't expect to get a degree by exam but you can get some of the intro and general education classes out of the way. Also there are so many schools doing remote that it's a very good time to enroll in a school and never have to go to a classroom. This expands your choices.

Re: Ask HN: Any colleges or universities offering credit for CS courses by exam?

#4

Post by rateofchange »

endisneigh wrote: post #2

There’s no US degree they offers credit by only taking the exam as far as I know.

That wasn't the question, or intent. Sorry if I didn't make that clear.

The idea is to knock out as many credits as possible through examination. Not the full degree.

Re: Ask HN: Any colleges or universities offering credit for CS courses by exam?

#7

Post by nextos »

In Europe there are many universities where you can register for as many courses as you want, ignore lectures, sit the exam, and get full credit in case you pass.

In principle, nobody prevents you from passing the whole BSc in two semesters.

This opportunity gets especially interesting when you consider national open / remote universities, as you won't need to travel to pass the exams.

However, coding is one thing, theory is another one. Even if you know theory pretty well, you will need to review a bit which kind of imposes a speed limit on how fast you can pass said courses.

Re: Ask HN: Any colleges or universities offering credit for CS courses by exam?

#8

Post by rateofchange »

nextos wrote: post #7

In Europe there are many universities where you can register for as many courses as you want, ignore lectures, sit the exam, and get full credit in case you pass. In principle, nobody prevents you from passing the whole BSc in two semesters. This opportunity gets especially interesting when you consider national open / remote universities, as you won't need to travel to pass the exams. However, coding is one thing, t…

> However, coding is one thing, theory is another one. Even if you know theory pretty well, you will need to review a bit which kind of imposes a speed limit on how fast you can pass said courses

Yes, definitely. For example, I did a lot of work with genetic algorithms about ten years ago. Jumped-in head-first, read a pile of university-level books on the subject. However, I haven't touched any of that in probably five or six years. I would likely have to do a deep review for two or three months before being able to take a real test on the subject.

I am looking at the online program offered by the University of London. Not sure if they have the ability to just take tests one one's own schedule as opposed to only being able to take a test at the end of the term, which defeats the purpose by imposing artificial time constraints.

The other thing I see at universities in Europe is that they don't tend to make you waste a year of your life taking non-degree coursework. One ought to be able to obtain a degree in CS, Engineering or Mathematics without having to devote a year passing courses in history, philosophy, etc. We could argue about the idea of general education, etc. Well, this ought to be a part of primary and secondary education. In the US, that extra year or more devoted to non-degree coursework can cost you USD $30K, $50K or $60K, depending on where you go. This is insane.

Yes, give people the option to study such courses, and, if they have career value or are valued by employers, graduates can list them as part of their resume. The reality is that the vast majority of employers don't give a shit. This ads no value at all. I would much rather a CS student spend another solid year on real CS course work than on general education. Far more value in that.

I bit of a rant, I know. It just bothers me to see young people in the US leave school with debt they did not need to incur. Last I checked the hiring process at FAANG companies does not include an essay on ancient European history. And yet our students spend tens of thousands of dollars and a massive amount of time (opportunity cost) getting enough of a good grade on this stuff to be able to obtain a degree.

Re: Ask HN: Any colleges or universities offering credit for CS courses by exam?

#9

Post by robcohen »

I’ll go one step further, with most lower level courses, there should be large open knowledge banks of questions which can be solved within a reasonable time (<15 min) and all homework/tests for testing knowledge should be automatically generated from a random subset of questions. Testing would occur in proctored settings and the knowledge banks should be large enough to not be able to be gamed. Separate the instruction from the certification. Why this hasn’t happened yet for things like CS and Math I have no idea.

Re: Ask HN: Any colleges or universities offering credit for CS courses by exam?

#10

Post by elonmollusc »

The term you're looking for is competency-based education. If you can demonstrate that you meet the learning goals for a course, usually by taking an exam, you get credit for it. You only need to invest time in studying the parts of the course that you haven't yet mastered.

Western Governors University is the largest and best-known school with competency-based degrees. They use an online model where you pay a fixed amount per semester, but with no cap on the number of credits you can complete.

Post reply on HN