Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Is your company sticking to on-premise servers? Why?

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 782 posts

Ask HN: Is your company sticking to on-premise servers? Why?

#1
I've been managing servers for quite some time now. At home, on prem, in the cloud...

The more I learn, the more I believe cloud is the only competitive solution today, even for sensitive industries like banking or medical.

I honestly fail to see any good reason not to use the cloud anymore, at least for business. Cost-wise, security-wise, whatever-wise.

What's a good reason to stick to on-prem today for new projects? To be clear, this is not some troll question. I'm curious: am I missing something?

Re: Ask HN: Is your company sticking to on-premise servers? Why?

#5
University research group here.

Simply, _cost_

Our compute servers crunch numbers and data at > 80% util.

Our servers are optimized for the work we have.

They run 24/7 picking jobs from queue. Cloud burst is often irrelevant here.

They deal with Terabytes or even Petabytes of moving data. I’d cry paying for bandwidth costs if charged €/GB.

Sysadmin(yours truly) would be needed even if it were to be run in the cloud.

We run our machines beyond 4 years if they are still good at purpose.

We control the infra and data. So, a little more peace and self-reliance.

No surprise bills because some bot pounded on a S3 dataset.

Our heavy users are connected to the machines at a single hop :-) No need to go across WAN for work.

Re: Ask HN: Is your company sticking to on-premise servers? Why?

#6

University research group here. Simply, _cost_ Our compute servers crunch numbers and data at > 80% util. Our servers are optimized for the work we have. They run 24/7 picking jobs from queue. Cloud burst is often irrelevant here. They deal with Terabytes or even Petabytes of moving data. I’d cry paying for bandwidth costs if charged €/GB. Sysadmin(yours truly) would be needed even if it were to be run in the cloud.…

Interesting. How many machines do you have, roughly? Are you the only sysadmin for this? Also, do you have any public facing services hosted from that infrastructure?

Re: Ask HN: Is your company sticking to on-premise servers? Why?

#7
post #3
post #2

TCO.

Which, all things considered, seems lower on the cloud. Could you give more details on this answer?

A 2u asus with 2 xeon silver, 64gb ram and 4 x 2080ti is maybe us$15k?

We'll use it for as long as its producing useful output. Lets say 5 years? Probably a little longer?

A 60bay 4u western digital with 14tb drives is under us$50k?

definitely got a dell md1280+1u server with 70x10tb 2yrs ago for under us$50k. Fully populated the following year..

A 2u dell with maybe 20 cores n 128gb ram each should cost less than us$10k.

And we just got 4 or 5 dell switches with 48x10g ports for 50-70k? I'm not sure.

What's the equivalent in the cloud?

Post reply on HN