Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: room for a new forum platform?

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 19 posts

Ask HN: room for a new forum platform?

#1
Stackoverflow obviously raised the bar for Q&A type forums. Whilst that format might not be suitable for all use-cases, so many sites seem to be implementing the old web 1.0 forum - e.g http://mailwatch.co.uk/forum/

I'm guessing many of these are self-hosted too. What opportunity do you think think there is for a updated, threaded, hosted forum service is? What kind of features would you want?

Re: Ask HN: room for a new forum platform?

#2
Quora has also dramatically raised the bar. If you haven't already, go join and ask / answer a couple of questions. It's slick, efficient and impressive to use.

My feeling is that, for forum software to really be useful (and lucrative), it needs to be usable by businesses. That means allowing customization, probably allowing file attachments, and integrating with a wide variety of software via APIs or installable plugins.

Re: Ask HN: room for a new forum platform?

#3
post #2

Quora has also dramatically raised the bar. If you haven't already, go join and ask / answer a couple of questions. It's slick, efficient and impressive to use. My feeling is that, for forum software to really be useful (and lucrative), it needs to be usable by businesses. That means allowing customization, probably allowing file attachments, and integrating with a wide variety of software via APIs or installable plu…

I hear Quora is good. But they only seem to allow login/signup via facebook.

Re: Ask HN: room for a new forum platform?

#4
post #3
post #2

Quora has also dramatically raised the bar. If you haven't already, go join and ask / answer a couple of questions. It's slick, efficient and impressive to use. My feeling is that, for forum software to really be useful (and lucrative), it needs to be usable by businesses. That means allowing customization, probably allowing file attachments, and integrating with a wide variety of software via APIs or installable plu…

I hear Quora is good. But they only seem to allow login/signup via facebook.

Or Twitter, I think. But yes, it's a very odd choice to not allow (1) OpenID logins, and (2) basic registration - particularly given their early adopter audience.

Re: Ask HN: room for a new forum platform?

#5
post #2

Quora has also dramatically raised the bar. If you haven't already, go join and ask / answer a couple of questions. It's slick, efficient and impressive to use. My feeling is that, for forum software to really be useful (and lucrative), it needs to be usable by businesses. That means allowing customization, probably allowing file attachments, and integrating with a wide variety of software via APIs or installable plu…

thanks for letting know about Quora

Re: Ask HN: room for a new forum platform?

#6
That's something I often thought myself, phpBB/vBulletin type of forums have been around for 10+ years now, and they haven't changed a lot since then.

I think there might be lots of things to rethink on the UX side now that we have so many new frameworks available.

If you aim to build a 100% hosted service, I feel like suggesting to let the client keep ownership of the database at least. I wouldn't like to give total control of all the posts on my forum to somebody else.

I'd say simplier & better looking interfaces + open customization features is the path to follow. Just my 2c.

Re: Ask HN: room for a new forum platform?

#7
post #4
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I hear Quora is good. But they only seem to allow login/signup via facebook.

Or Twitter, I think. But yes, it's a very odd choice to not allow (1) OpenID logins, and (2) basic registration - particularly given their early adopter audience.

Maybe they don't allow it because of their early adopter audience: who among that crowd does not have a twitter or FB account?

Re: Ask HN: room for a new forum platform?

#8
post #6

That's something I often thought myself, phpBB/vBulletin type of forums have been around for 10+ years now, and they haven't changed a lot since then. I think there might be lots of things to rethink on the UX side now that we have so many new frameworks available. If you aim to build a 100% hosted service, I feel like suggesting to let the client keep ownership of the database at least. I wouldn't like to give total…

Yes - it seems amazing that 90+% of web forums are the old php/vBulletin type. My major gripe with these is that they do not have threaded comments. Not to mention a very old-skool UI/UX as you say.

Interesting what you say about db ownership. And I guess for established forums there would be migration considerations too (maybe this is why they haven't upgraded?)

Customization would be no problem. You could allow users to source their own css for example.

Re: Ask HN: room for a new forum platform?

#9
post #7
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Or Twitter, I think. But yes, it's a very odd choice to not allow (1) OpenID logins, and (2) basic registration - particularly given their early adopter audience.

Maybe they don't allow it because of their early adopter audience: who among that crowd does not have a twitter or FB account?

I'm obviously not an early adopter :) Actually, in seriousness I'm probably not. But still, I like to remain anonymous and only reveal personal data when I have absolute control and trust in over who/where I am releasing it to (and I don't mean I don't trust Quora, it's exposing myself to their users that I have an issue with)

Re: Ask HN: room for a new forum platform?

#10
post #2

Quora has also dramatically raised the bar. If you haven't already, go join and ask / answer a couple of questions. It's slick, efficient and impressive to use. My feeling is that, for forum software to really be useful (and lucrative), it needs to be usable by businesses. That means allowing customization, probably allowing file attachments, and integrating with a wide variety of software via APIs or installable plu…

Hi Ben - a couple more questions: what kind of APIs do you envisage? And what sort of plugins?
Post reply on HN