Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What are the best-designed things you've ever used?

news.ycombinator.com

891–900 of 994 posts

Re: Ask HN: What are the best-designed things you've ever used?

#893

One example of quality design which I gleaned from reading Don Norman's "The Design Of Everyday Things" is the metal plate I've frequently seen on doors which are meant to be pushed. The only affordance of such a plate is its push-ability, and the fact that someone actively installed a metal plate (instead of just relying on the door's natural flatness), as well as its location at the point of maximum leverage (all t…

I'm currently in a country where I can't read the language and memorizing push vs pull feels so unnecessary when you could just design a door with obvious operation mechanics

Well,learning a few words can help you anywhere really.

Re: Ask HN: What are the best-designed things you've ever used?

#894

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Inside the bathroom itself, the doors on individual stalls usually open inwards. One pragmatic advantage of this approach is that if the door opens while you are seated, you can push it closed without getting up. Or requiring help from someone else outside. This also drives the use of push-in-pull-out handles.

One major disadvantage of this approach is that if you are coming in with a bulky bag, or more (hauling carry-on luggage in an airport for instance), you have sharply limited space within to maneuver you and your stuff to a position where you can lift your skirts and do what you came here to do. Every time I go to a public bathroom with stall doors that open outward I am delighted.

IIRC the Dallas airport had large selves in the wall behind the toilets for luggage. It was extremely convenient.

Re: Ask HN: What are the best-designed things you've ever used?

#895

Macromedia Fireworks. UI was better than any other graphics program I tried, ever.

That and Macromedia Flash! I love how easy it is to make shapes and curves in Fireworks and Flash. Its an object-oriented UX. You click an object on screen, you'll get its visual and textual properties. You click the screen, you get your canvas properties. You can group, ungroup or do unions on objects. Layers are only secondary to objects, unlike Photoshop with its layer-oriented UX. Illustrator? I dont even know what the UI/UX is supposed to be, its just a mish-mash of tools.

Re: Ask HN: What are the best-designed things you've ever used?

#896
This may sound silly, but: - my hacked iPad. It's first generation, original software was stupid, but with "RedSn0w" and all of Freeman's Cydia apps, it has turned into my favourite device. It has a full, Linux-like file system, I can have all sorts of material on it, SSH works fine, can use it as a controller, and I can still browse (some) internet sites. (Using it to write this). I have Macbook Pro, a bunch of Linux boxes, couple of nice Acer laptops, but this ancient iPad is so very well made, and all the Cydia stuff just works. My partner has a modern iPhone, but I like this old iPad, where each key on the screen is half-an-inch across! - my AR-15. AK's are prohibited where I live (and so now is my AR), but folks need to understand what a fine triumph in modular design and excellent ergonomics, the American-designed AR-15 rifle really is. Early rifle designs were just not good - soldiers would pull the trigger, and be blinded as the breech blew up in their face. The AR is light, lethal, and reliable. Like most good design, it is the result of continuous improvements over a long time span. - The Piper PA-28 "Warrior" general aviation light aircraft. This is just an amazingly successful design effort. Everything in aircraft design is a series of trade-offs, weight, strength, durability, reliability, ease-of-use, safety, complexity, simplicity, and so on. I did all my fight training as a young fellow on Cessna 172's, which are also excellent examples of very good design. But the 172 feels like what it is, to fly - a solid, simple workhorse. The PA-28, with a 160 or 180 hp engine, manages to feel quite different - like being able to drive a Camaro around in the sky. It's not a Ferrari, but it had several fine design features that made it feel like a much more substantial and flyable aircraft, especially for a kid learning to fly. It was real fun. The wings were tapered. Compared to older "Cherokee" models, which did not have tapered wings, the difference was significant. It is, of course, a low-wing aircraft. This makes for a much more attractive flying experience - you are driving a platform, not hanging from a wing, in a little box. And this aircraft has a stabilator, instead of a tail-plane and an elevator. On the Piper, as you pull and push the control wheel, the whole rear wing tilts up and down. This is just a genius design feature, and gives the aircraft a nice lively feel, even if you are flying the cheapest, entry-level version, which does not have retractable gear. (If renting at a flying club, you probably won't have any retractables - since some student might forget to drop the gear, and may well wipe out the aircraft.) Our club had one Warrior, and it was a very big treat, when I could book it and take it away up north, for a weekend. The little design genius features, made it very fun to fly. I recall dropping the flaps involved pulling on a lever, much like a sports-car emergency brake. (On the Cessna, to put down flaps, you throw a switch on the panel, and listen for the servo-motors). But on the Piper, you pull on this lever, and feel the wind on the flaps, as you pull them down. You literally could feel the air, as you flew thru it. And with those tapered wings, and the rear stabilator, you could drop a wing and dive down quick, and the whole experience was wonderful, because of these specific design improvements over the old square ( non-tapered) wings of the older "Cherokee" models. - lastly, (call me crazy, if you must), the original APL computer language, which I learned when very young, because it was the only interactive environment available. APL was (is) very different, but it turned out to be an amazingly useful languange and environment to learn. I met Ken Iverson (the inventor author of APL), and he and I did not see eye-to-eye on things. But APL was a work of genius. APL was very popular inside IBM in the early days, and the first IBM P/C was actually pre-dated by an IBM Personal Computer that ran APL, called the SCAMP, which came out in 1973, if I remember correctly. I still use APL applications, and we use them, because they make us money. And that is always important in any product design... :)

Re: Ask HN: What are the best-designed things you've ever used?

#897

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't know what you'd consider light but the Akto packs to around 1.3-1.5 kg. Given that I've been in it during weather reaching up to 35 on the Beaufort scale (~20m/s) with severe rain I feel it packs a fantastic punch for its weight. I'm sure there are some niche ultra light space age material tents out there. But that would be like saying a Tesla isn't a good car because it can't reach space.

A solo tent needs to be below 1kg before I'd consider it light. Maybe it is the lightest tent when considering the weather it can deal with, but this was not mentioned in your original message. I don't get the analogy with the Tesla going to space? You don't expect cars to fly. What would be the tent equivalent? Using the tent as a boat?

Can you give an argument why we should adhere to your personal standard of a tent being light only if its under 1kg? Is it supported somewhere else? What if someone comes and claims that a tent is light only if its less than 500g?

Re: Ask HN: What are the best-designed things you've ever used?

#898

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The kindle hardware is excellent, but the kindle software is one of the worst pieces of garbage ever. Just filled from top to bottom with utterly deranged behaviors.

The thing that drives me crazy is that when you select word to translate, it includes commas and points. Then, dictionary can't translate!!! This is such a basic issue and still exists for years. Ppl from Amazon, I pray to you to fix this

I've complained about these issues with the Kindle for years, but the problem is that Amazon has absolutely no incentive to fix any of these issues.

Re: Ask HN: What are the best-designed things you've ever used?

#899
post #65

Kinesis Advantage2 keyboard. Without it I would not be able to work as a software developer.

Yeah, the Evoluent Vertical Mouse gave me two working hands and a lucrative career. Pretty good value. Five Stars. Would buy again, in fact I have, so I have one for every place I use my laptop.

I have so far purchased 4 Kinesis Advantage2 keyboards. I always keep a brand new one ready in case my work or home one breaks.

Re: Ask HN: What are the best-designed things you've ever used?

#900

Kitchenaid direct-drive stand mixer. I have one from the 1950s that has been used multiple times a week since it was bought new by my grandmother. The dough hook, whisk, and other attachments secure in place with machined fittings so there is no play or wiggle. This has made them last. I took the top off of it 10 years ago to make sure it was still properly lubricated. That’s all the maintenance it has ever had. (Wel…

The kitchen aid in our kitchen scares the heck out of me around children. That machine could rip an arm off a child very easily.
Post reply on HN