Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Do you still use physical calculators?

news.ycombinator.com

81–90 of 130 posts

Re: Ask HN: Do you still use physical calculators?

#81
I saved a scientific calculator in 1994 just in case. I never used it, as a PC was always on since then.

Today two cheap calculators are available to my children mostly as an example of "productive technology", in contrary to modern devices. This falls under a general effort to expose them to productive paradigms of 80's way of life.

Re: Ask HN: Do you still use physical calculators?

#84
TL;DR: school/tests/exams don't allow phones.

Here in NL - Casio FX-82NL is allowed during test/exams for middle/high school, and actually for Radio Amateur/HAM licence exam - they even hand you one of their FX-82NLs.

Other more advanced (graphing, with memory/Python/etc) are also allowed in some places, but they need to be set to exam mode that disables memory/python/etc.

Re: Ask HN: Do you still use physical calculators?

#87

wish i still had my hp48g, the emulator apps are the most used apps on my phone/ipad, they re glorified calculators*ipod by now with worse buttons.

I still have my HP graphing calculator, but I haven't used it in years. I just use the emulator on my phone. It's crazy that in decades of having much better hardware, including an entire decade of phones in the exact same form factor we use today, we haven't come up with better software that would make a calculator emulator irrelevant.

Re: Ask HN: Do you still use physical calculators?

#88
post #21

I don't, but I sometimes see them used here in Japan. Some small-shop operators use them to add up charges and show the total to the customer. I was recently in the office of a small company, and I noticed that the bookkeeper had a calculator next to a pile of paper (receipts?) on her desk. She also had a computer in front of her with a spreadsheet on the screen. When I moved here forty-three years ago, it was common…

Back in the (early 1960s?) Isaac Asimov wrote a book on how to do arithmetic calculations in your head. He pointed out that someone who developed that skill could solve problems faster in their head than by reaching for a slide rule, and they wouldn't necessarily be limited to slide rule approximations. Engineers, accountants, etc. would be more productive by being able to do calculations without having to reach for a slide rule or pencil and paper.

[pause for 'slide rule' chuckle]

The same applies to "open calculator app and key the figures in," though. I'm not sure that "user interface" was a thing back when he wrote that, but that's what he was talking about.

Re: Ask HN: Do you still use physical calculators?

#89

I use a junky $5 calculator when I'm working with my mill and lathe. It's easier to have the little thing there at hand in the machine shop to do quick calculations than to have a whole computer.

Same, but for the cleanliness and safety of my phone.

Re: Ask HN: Do you still use physical calculators?

#90
> I’ve noticed that most physical scientific and graphing calculators are easily outdone in terms of performance, capability and ease of use by the likes of Desmos and the default calculators on OS’es like the iOS, Android, and Windows.

Citation needed. They are pretty clunky, unless you have a numpad typing on them takes way longer. Graphing and fast access to mathematical functions is way worse.

I mean I do substituted my calculator with the computer, but the replacement is Python and GeoGebra, not the built in calculator. And the reason is mostly convenience of not replacing batteries. I do use the standalone calculator while the batteries are full.

Post reply on HN