Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How do you manage photos, philosophically?

news.ycombinator.com

81–90 of 91 posts

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage photos, philosophically?

#81
post #52
post #32

Somewhat less philosophically: there is a huge technological problem in keeping photo archives. We entrust our photos to companies like Apple and Google with the attention span of a fruit fly — nobody seems to give any thought to long-term archival. Solutions appear and disappear within several years. Also, all current photo library solutions are deficient and built mostly for a single flashy keynote presentation, no…

https://cyme.io/avalanche-photo-conversion/ I haven't used it personally, but worth checking out. It supports Aperture in the past and worth checking if they still support, or if you can download an older version which supports it.

This looks promising! Thanks!

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage photos, philosophically?

#82
I've finally decided on a system that works for backups and devices that don't have image recognition as well as Google photos and iCloud!

I have two types of folder:

Folders for specific events or activities

And folders for common themes for the year.

The themed folders can change throughout the years which is interesting to see but I tend to have the same core few.

I found if I grouped too many things into YYYY-MM(-DD) format I couldn't find the photo of a night out from ten years ago because I didn't remember the month (or year!) But I did know that it was with uni friends or work friends which narrowed down the folders greatly! Ofc iCloud and Google photos make that much easier now but I prefer to have my primary backups managed by me!

YYYY-MM Christmas YYYY-MM Holiday to abc YYYY-MM-DD day out at the zoo YYYY-MM House YYYY-MM Food YYYY-MM Gaming YYYY-MM Travel - days out YYYY-MM [Name of town i live in] YYYY-MM PC and tech YYYY-MM Inlaws YYYY-MM Family YYYY-MM Guinea pigs

Etc

One of the interesting things I found was that I was taking photos of random things around the house, some flowers, or the light at a particular time of day was interesting. Previously I'd have tried to organise those by month or more granularly but I now have a 'house' (or flat) folder for each year which I really enjoy looking back through to see how the house has changed. It's also useful for before/after photos I forgot to take! I have one of these folders for other houses or locations I visit often or take photos of random objects in like my parents or in law's house! I also have one for my local area.

I also have a series of Outbox folders for memes, references etc. In more recent times I've started removing screenshots and images I've saved from places from my phone and albums since they're not useful in a photo album!

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage photos, philosophically?

#83
I used to have a limit of 3-4 photos a day (or one photo per event that day). If I took more than that, I would go through and delete the others. That's changed a bit since I started WFH.

The concept for me was that the point of the photo was to remind me of the event/ memory, and one photo did that for me. If I had 10-20-30 photos from a day or an event, I found that I was not mindful of each individual photo and just glanced at them (ignoring details and remembering memories). With a limited photo option, I was forced into mindfulness more. The added benefit, of course, was that it resulted in a conservative use of my phone's storage.

As for backup, I have syncthing running on my phone. It copies my photos into my laptop which funnel it into a time-machine storage and I have it up on google - photos. I would like to add one more syncthing instance (preferably out of my home) for redundancy, but that's about it for now. Maybe I'll start burning them on optical media or SD-Cards, once I have kids.

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage photos, philosophically?

#84
Here’s a question I’ve wanted to ask — how many people just don’t take photos? I don’t have any philosophical bone to pick with it, I still take a photo if I need to reference something like where I parked; but I used to take photos on my phone at probably a normal frequency when I first became an adult, and I realized after a few years that I had never looked back on any photos I’d taken, so I just stopped taking them afterwards and never really felt any loss from not having them.

Incidentally, one unintended consequence of this behavior is realizing just how insignificant of a difference there is between smartphones even over 5+ years, if the camera is zero value add.

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage photos, philosophically?

#85
post #57

I don't take many photos, because the act of taking a picture removes me from being present for whatever it is I'm taking the picture of, and thus reduces my enjoyment of things. But my wife takes a gazillion photos of everything. I organize them in a directory hierarchy by date, on my NAS. I also run a private wiki at home, and have pages of "special collections" of certain photos by subject matter/event/ whatever t…

Unless, of course, you take pictures very mindfully vs. just taking snapshots. I think the ease of which we can take photos now makes it very easy to cheapen photography. But we can still bring ourselves to be very present and mindful when doing so.

But if you're out there and your intent isn't to take a picture (but you're doing so anyway), I agree that'd also take me out out of the moment and reduce enjoyment of things.

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage photos, philosophically?

#86
I make an album of the photos I like after an event. I'll make another pass after adding them, and if I don't love it or it doesn't make me feel good again, I remove it from the album (but don't delete it).

I have a few albums that are a category as opposed to an event and I'll occasionally add to those randomly.

I use google photos and backup using the same.

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage photos, philosophically?

#89
post #88

I do not like memories, as change can hurt my heart. I try to look back only about a year and just take a lot of photos anyway because my memory of events isn’t so good.

You're the first person I met who feels the same way I do. I don't like looking at old photos. Nothing to do with "regret" everything to do with those lovely times are never going to happen again.

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage photos, philosophically?

#90
post #88

I do not like memories, as change can hurt my heart. I try to look back only about a year and just take a lot of photos anyway because my memory of events isn’t so good.

You're the first person I met who feels the same way I do. I don't like looking at old photos. Nothing to do with "regret" everything to do with those lovely times are never going to happen again.

Yes, exactly! 0 regrets, all about some moment literally never happening again until the end of time.

Furthermore, the person I'm with is extremely emotionally intelligent, and she has experienced deep loss of over 20 people... she is an extreme veteran when it comes to emotionally accepting death/change.

For me, I feel like looking at memories is only a reflection how I can be hyper intelligent, but emotionally I feel like I'm 12 sometimes with how I deal with certain things. Maybe that it takes me a long time to integrate things which are painful. Above all else, daily, I feel perfectly capable and sharp, and I know deep down I will be fine, but then there is always this otehr side... hard to explain

Post reply on HN