Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Do you still miss your RIM BlackBerry?

news.ycombinator.com

81–90 of 268 posts

Re: Ask HN: Do you still miss your RIM BlackBerry?

#81
I miss my Sidekick2 (aka, Danger Hiptop2) That thing was a joy. Amazing typing speed. Best opening motion (quality of a fidget toy) and it ran a flavor of BeOS.

The Blackberry of millennials.. my wife had one too. We texted a lot back then.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danger_Hiptop

Re: Ask HN: Do you still miss your RIM BlackBerry?

#82
My first phone was my dad's Blackberry Curve 8520 and it had Whatsapp and Brickreaker, two of my favourite pastimes at the time. I could also type on it crazy fast, it had a crappy web browser but even then, I would discover a whole lot about the internet, both good and bad.

Re: Ask HN: Do you still miss your RIM BlackBerry?

#83
When I came to states in 2012, missed using a phone with physical keyboard. Got a used Bold 9700 on eBay for $100 and instantly fell in love with it. Optical trackpad complimented the physical keypad. Sometimes I wonder why Apple hasn't used the home button as optical trackpad, atleast in the pro models.

Re: Ask HN: Do you still miss your RIM BlackBerry?

#84

I wished I had a Blackberry when I was a much younger, but personally I miss Windows Phones a lot more.

Same. There was a time when Nokia's Lumia series with Windows Phone OS was all the rage in India - and for good reason. They were really good phones at incredible price points, their only drawback was that the number of apps on offer in the Windows Phone Store was very limited. I wonder why they stopped making them. Later in life I passed my phone (I had the Lumia 520) on to my grandmother - and it was great because…

To me it seems they weren't content being a niche for whatever percentage of the market wanted phones that were simple, consistent, and didn't bother them. When Windows 10 Mobile came out, they started adding a bunch of useless animations, it became harder to use in every way. Although I guess the writing was on the wall by then. When I returned my phone they didn't even bother to ask why.

Re: Ask HN: Do you still miss your RIM BlackBerry?

#85
post #36

Yes I miss it everyday, I feel so clumsy typing on a piece of glass, and make soo many typos. I could type BLIND without typos whole emails while maintaining a casual conversation (much to the annoyance of my girlfriend). There are a lot of BlackBerry-stans still on crackberry.com holding out on older and newer BlackBerry phoned (key2 being the latest). Really loved my Q10 with bb10os and my Keyone running Android! S…

I really am surprised that with of all models of Android phones in the world, no one is making one with a keyboard. Even if it was a niche product, you'd think there would be an audience...

Planet computers are making them, but based on Psion PDAs rather than blackberry. I had a Gemini, but physically it wore out rather fast, and the camera was rubbish. Not sure how good their next generation is.

Re: Ask HN: Do you still miss your RIM BlackBerry?

#86
post #4

I wished I had a Blackberry when I was a much younger, but personally I miss Windows Phones a lot more.

Windows Phones were awful in general but provided something that no full featured smart phone can: simplicity. Notifications? Hardly. Browser? Barely works. Apps? Pshh. Instant messaging? I hope you like SMS! Games? There’s a couple good ones you never heard of that won’t be maintained. But heck, if you want peace and quiet and while still offering the basics in good form, the Windows Phone couldn’t be beat.

As a former Windows Phone user, The Palm Phone is about as close to that experience as you can get to that experience of a smartphone that generally leaves me alone.

Of course, they only made one version, they botched the marketing by marketing it as a "companion phone" initially, and it was released in 2018, so eventually it won't be an option with modern apps.

Re: Ask HN: Do you still miss your RIM BlackBerry?

#87
I really loved having the red notification light for when a message was received on my BB. Having to click a button on my iPhone in order to check whether I have a notification or not is quite jarring, and time consuming.

And like everyone else here I really miss having a proper keyboard. That thing was great.

Re: Ask HN: Do you still miss your RIM BlackBerry?

#88
post #87

I really loved having the red notification light for when a message was received on my BB. Having to click a button on my iPhone in order to check whether I have a notification or not is quite jarring, and time consuming. And like everyone else here I really miss having a proper keyboard. That thing was great.

Notification light is a feature that exists on a lot of android phones still, it's one feature I wouldn't want to lose.

Re: Ask HN: Do you still miss your RIM BlackBerry?

#89
We have a lot of positive nostalgia, so time for some negative views :D I hated most every blackberry I owned. Stupid, clumsy and bulky devices.

BlackBerry was not that massive a shift from the standard. It was just _slightly_ different to what feature phones of the day were doing. Sony Ericson had some P800/P900 devices that clouted the BB in terms of power and feature sets. Here's a quick roundup of why I don't hold BB in high regard

1. BBM was not unique or innovative. Many a chat app had existed on J2ME devices LONG before RIM were a thing.

2. BB launched apps from a Main method, making architectural changes all but impossible going forward. This also lead to that goddamned spinning hour glass that needed a device restart to resolve.

3. Not many claims about their security and compression turned out to be true. Whilst the encryption was excellent, handing over the keys to various governments was not. The compression I remain unconvinced about, many a conflicting report out there.

4. Ultimately RIM were unable to execute on the BB platform in a meaningful manner. They were very quickly outclassed by Google and Apple despite an incredible market lead. Looking back, blackberry always felt like a polished proof of concept but not quite production grade. Even low level Android devices had a more polished feel. Touchscreen became popular for a reason, BB pretty much refused to believe it was more than a fad. Then they made the Torch, and they deserved to die at that point. I loathed how useless and unpredictable that phone was at being a phone.

5. This one is subjective: Those keyboards were utter garbage. I could do 60 wpm on a t9, and that was slower than most people I knew. None of those people could match their speeds on a BB. Today's touchscreen keyboards are worse, so point there.

I don't miss my blackberry, but I do miss BBM and that time of my life.

I do miss some of my old feature phones though, such as the Samsung D600 and the Motorola V3 Razer

Re: Ask HN: Do you still miss your RIM BlackBerry?

#90

I could type 55 wpm on the keyboard. Every time I use a screen keyboard I feel like I lose 10 IQ points. I can use a physical keyboard without looking, but the screen keyboard takes twice as long and consumes my full attention if I want any speed. The blackberry felt like an extension of my brain on the internet. Touchscreen devices feel like an extension of the internet in my brain + eyes, not as nice. I used my bla…

Do you use Swiftkey-like typing on your keyboard? On my Android phone I find I can type so fast with it, and I barely have to look at the keyboard.
Post reply on HN