Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Do you like/use Reddit's redesign?

news.ycombinator.com

81–90 of 165 posts

Re: Ask HN: Do you like/use Reddit's redesign?

#81
post #77

For most people who don’t like the new design, there is still https://old.reddit.com

This is how I can tell the design's actually bad -- that when I get on the new design by mistake, I'm not like "meh, links are still here", I'm like "whoops, have to go to the old one!"

Re: Ask HN: Do you like/use Reddit's redesign?

#82

Reddit keeps on putting a banner at the bottom of its pages saying "Try the redesign! It has INFINITE SCROLLING!" and I am like, guys, that's the last thing I want, I like having those little moments where I have to explicitly decide if I want more of what you have or not, that makes it easier to stop and go do something useful .

I'm currently using uBlock origin to get rid of the banners.

The fact that they've called it an `onboardingbar` is not exactly reassuring.

Re: Ask HN: Do you like/use Reddit's redesign?

#83
Interesting, I just closed Reddit while complaining in my head about how poor the experience is:

- You can't seem to persist the "old reddit" design any more. It keeps switching you back to the new design

- It's just much slower to load content. The old site was fairly snappy

- Comment are CONSTANTLY failing to load in most of the threads I open

- The autoscroll is also regularly failing to load new items

- Using the mobile site, I'm nagged by numerous attempts to get me to install the native app

Re: Ask HN: Do you like/use Reddit's redesign?

#84
Apparently my "That's enough Reddit, time to go do something productive" check only happens when I reach the bottom of the page and have to click for another page.

Endless Scroll basically destroyed my productivity for a week until I figured that out. I switched to Old Reddit and my life is back in balance.

Just one of those subtle little things nobody would've anticipated, I guess.

Re: Ask HN: Do you like/use Reddit's redesign?

#86
post #64

No. Largely the dark pattern mobile "get the app" hassling. But also the sheer load time on desktop. And to a lesser extent the breaking of the "a bunch of mostly-static links with associated commentary" model. Using the site is quite unpleasant now. And it's enough unpleasantness to keep me from going back to checking it regularly. I hope they keep it.

I think you can disable the "get the app" in your Reddit settings panel. How persistent that is, not sure.

Re: Ask HN: Do you like/use Reddit's redesign?

#88
post #83

Interesting, I just closed Reddit while complaining in my head about how poor the experience is: - You can't seem to persist the "old reddit" design any more. It keeps switching you back to the new design - It's just much slower to load content. The old site was fairly snappy - Comment are CONSTANTLY failing to load in most of the threads I open - The autoscroll is also regularly failing to load new items - Using the…

Just so you know, there's this[1] firefox addon that always force the redirection to old.reddit.com. I imagine there's a similar thing for chrome.

[1] https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/old-reddit-re...

Re: Ask HN: Do you like/use Reddit's redesign?

#89

Not at ALL. I’ve never seen a single site design repel me more quickly. I depend heavily on the simplicity and information-density of the old design (e.g. being able to pick from a dozen link titles that all fit on screen at once). I also depend on the pinch-to-zoom simplicity of focusing on exactly what I want, which only works well in the “normal” web pages of the old design. The new “design” breaks everything that…

If there was a cookie cutter reddit alternative and there was no content, would you use it? The network effects of reddit are a reasonably strong barrier of entry.

For a viable competitor to Reddit, you only need enough other users to fill a few pages worth of content, so the barrier of entry is much lower than if you wanted to outcompete something like Whatsapp. I mean, Hacker News has like 1% of the number of users that Reddit has, and it's already better.
Post reply on HN