Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How do I give my son a head start?

news.ycombinator.com

81–90 of 157 posts

Re: Ask HN: How do I give my son a head start?

#81
Alice and Scratch both look like good learning tools (and have educational research backing them up).

I think it's more important though that there's someone who loves hacking in the child's life. Children pick up on genuine enthusiasm quickly, whether it's from you, your spouse, or someone who's a role model.

Re: Ask HN: How do I give my son a head start?

#83
post #19

Here is a good approach: Answer every question he asks. Help him find his interest. And as Patrick says, read to him now. (Just not Knuth).

> Answer every question he asks

Louis CK would disagree with you there: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fdc28bZ90G4 :)

Re: Ask HN: How do I give my son a head start?

#84
post #58

Love him. Unconditionally. And make sure he always knows it. Everything else is just details. With this, things will inevitably fall nicely into place, no matter what tactics you take. Without it, he will be fucked up no matter what you do and will be coming to hacker news in 2028 posting, "Ask HN: I'm confused and depressed and don't know why."

Meta: interesting that you think HN will exist in a recognizable form by 2028. 18 years ago, the web looked very different. I wonder what will we call "web" in 2028.

Re: Ask HN: How do I give my son a head start?

#85
Teach them how to solve problems, and how to work through getting stuck. I've seen lots of kids (and adults) who give up when they can't figure something out right away or get it to work the first time. Learning how to work through this will certainly help once you are ready to introduce more IT specific knowledge, but will be invaluable in several aspects of their life.

Re: Ask HN: How do I give my son a head start?

#86
post #35
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I claim that my daughter recognized me by voice at birth when I first spoke to her.

As ridiculous as it sounds, I'm with you on this. I'm certain my little dude recognised my voice when he was born.

My 3 month old daughter knew my voice, but didn't recognize my face when I shaved my beard. She would turn to see me when she heard my voice, but cry when she saw a stranger.

My second daughter easily recognizes her older sister voice at birth. My older one spoke to her constantly in the womb (usually asking her when she is going to come out and play with her). The best way to stop her crying is to ask my oldest daughter to sing to her (works better than my singing/soothing)

Re: Ask HN: How do I give my son a head start?

#87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> don't force anything on him. This is absolutely true. One of the risks that you take when you have a child is that he'll turn out totally different than you. My father was a farmer, and so we're from basically two different worlds. He could never understand why I wanted to be on the computer on the time, I couldn't understand why he wanted to be outside all the time. But since neither of us tried to force each othe…

> > don't force anything on him. ... Just let him use a computer in a completely natural way. > This is absolutely true. I disagree, sort of. I have a 5 yo and an 8 yo. If you let kids use a computer without guidance, they will learn how to use a computer from their friends at school. And what they learn is to fire up a browser (chrome if you've got it, otherwise Firefox) type " games" into Google and play thousands…

We're talking about two different things. I'm trying to say "Don't force Jimmy to program if he wants to be a football player" and you're saying "Help Jimmy to learn about what he's doing."

I'm not an expert on children, by any means, but I'd agree with both you and myself.

Also, I don't think there's anything wrong with playing flash games.

Re: Ask HN: How do I give my son a head start?

#88
I attended a TEDx event yesterday and a few parents had their middle-school aged kids there. It was an eye opener for a few of them.

My parents watched a lot of PBS or National Geographic type documentaries with me as a child. It gave me a view of the world outside of mine.

Internships. I did mine in my late college years but if you can start kids in high school, again it gives them a view of the future (possibly THEIR future) and great insight on paths to take.

Best of luck to you!

Re: Ask HN: How do I give my son a head start?

#89
post #49

I would just forget about computers and programming completely and focus on the building blocks by a playful approach to solving day-to-day problems with logic and reasoning. Like how do we decide which things belong together? You can also play progressively more complicated iteration games like for-each-time-this-happens-let's-do-this-this-and-this! Or make complicated rube goldberg devices out of household objects…

Not to discourage computer use, but I'd like to second the importance of the playful aspect. Our innate playfulness seems to be beneficial to creative processes. At the very least, it makes learning more fun, engaging. My dad used to hide notecards around the house, with a little clue ("turn around 90 degrees and walk 2 * 3 - 1 steps"). At the location specified, there'd be another little candy and a clue. Worked won…

I agree. Open-ended play is very important, I think. Give him stuff to build things that don't require instructions or guidance (or, at least much guidance). I am routinely amazed at what my kids build with tinker toys and blocks...

Re: Ask HN: How do I give my son a head start?

#90
Make it clear from the start that success comes from hard work not necessarily raw intelligence, it took me quite a while to overcome this idea instilled in me by my parents (i.e. when your kid does something good, "well done, you must have worked so hard to do that" opposed to "well done, you're so smart")
Post reply on HN