Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What super projects could unite humanity?

news.ycombinator.com

81–83 of 83 posts

Re: Ask HN: What super projects could unite humanity?

#81
post #78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Let me recolor that question: If you had some Lex Luthor powers, and there were 4 billion people hell bent on killing you, and the only way you could stop them was to use your huge robot army and your giant space lasers as a military force against them -- would you do that? I suppose the fundamental question here is: to what extent can you exercise your actions of self interest if they mean countering similar actions…

Yeah, that's an easy one, I feel perfectly okay applying force in response to aggression against what's belongs to me (like my body). And no, the fundamental question is "why would someone think that ozone layer or forests etc belongs to them" (because if it doesn't, they are not in position to decide if it should be kept or destroyed).

If you absolutely rely on something to live (without an ozone layer or oxygen, you're gone), don't you have a right to defend it? Although I admit, using robots to kill billions of people would give me pause. It's definitely a complex issue.

Do you have the right to defend yourself against an indirect attack? Here's another ridiculous scenario to think about - let's say you're diabetic, and some group of thugs is destroying all the world's supply of insulin. It doesn't belong to you, but you definitely need it. What would you do?

Re: Ask HN: What super projects could unite humanity?

#83
Redesign more of the things we use to meet cradle-to-cradle standards (this includes changing laws/restrictions).

Granted, there's many things that can't be made this way, but it's also an approach that doesn't lead us down a malthusian path of wanting nothing either.

Post reply on HN