Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Whats the worst startup idea you've heard, which turned out to be genius?

news.ycombinator.com

71–80 of 90 posts

Re: Ask HN: Whats the worst startup idea you've heard, which turned out to be genius?

#71
Snapchat. Thought it was a pretty dumb idea till recently. I'm now an active user. To be fair though, I still think the messaging feature of it is fun only as the occasional gimmick. The value tapers off as soon as you pass a certain age (at least that's what I feel). But when they introduced stories, and "live stories" in particular, their value just skyrocketed. It suddenly became genius. Being able to follow a full day of Red Bull's highlights, experiencing a country or city from multiple viewpoints in the span of a couple of minutes was amazing. Watching UFC from the front, back stage, way at the back of the ring, seeing the reactions of people in a curated-ish form that lasted 5 minutes was incredible. Snapchat suddenly became a whole lot more valuable for me.

One other idea. Yo. I don't think anyone's really using it to its potential. Apart from the "Yo" feature, the idea of it as a notification broker is fantastic. I still carry bets that it won't hit "critical mass/momentum" in its current form. Way too clunky.

Re: Ask HN: Whats the worst startup idea you've heard, which turned out to be genius?

#73
post #72

Facebook. I still think it's stupid.

You and many other people, including myself. Unfortunately being a bit of a traveller, it's probably the best practical ways of keeping in touch with other friends/family.

We still use email like we did 15 years ago...

Re: Ask HN: Whats the worst startup idea you've heard, which turned out to be genius?

#74
post #50

My mate had a university assignment several years back to come up with an online business idea. His idea was to set up an online "home delivery" service for restaurants (including those that don't do home delivery but do take-away). He got a shitty mark because the lecturer thought the idea was "stupid".

Since we are talking about genius ideas, where is the idea now? (Apologies if this was supposed to be obvious and I did not get it).

Google Shopping Express

Re: Ask HN: Whats the worst startup idea you've heard, which turned out to be genius?

#75
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Since we are talking about genius ideas, where is the idea now? (Apologies if this was supposed to be obvious and I did not get it).

https://www.doordash.com/ , heavy funding by KPCB

http://waiter.com has made a few cool megabucks in SV.

The original was http://waitersonwheels.com, which I used in the 1990's. It started as a catalog-based service, which waiter.com knocked off and improved.

It's not a defensible business model unless there's some exclusivity agreements with restaurants on the menu. (too tasty to resist.)

Re: Ask HN: Whats the worst startup idea you've heard, which turned out to be genius?

#76
post #71

Snapchat. Thought it was a pretty dumb idea till recently. I'm now an active user. To be fair though, I still think the messaging feature of it is fun only as the occasional gimmick. The value tapers off as soon as you pass a certain age (at least that's what I feel). But when they introduced stories, and "live stories" in particular, their value just skyrocketed. It suddenly became genius. Being able to follow a ful…

I still think Snapchat is a dumb idea. Maybe well executed? I tried myself to start using it, but everytime I install it, I'll uninstall after few minutes..

Re: Ask HN: Whats the worst startup idea you've heard, which turned out to be genius?

#77
post #2

Yes I worked for a guy in 1998 who basically invented both salesforce and AWS and wanted me to join him as the technical lead. I thought he was nuts and told him no. Due to the geographical location of the company he couldn't find anyone else to do it and went back to fixing PCs. Now I look back with regret.

One missed hire shouldn't have been enough to stop him, which I think is why you're getting downvotes.

You're right. But this was in an area where there were no staff. One reason I quit was we couldn't even get someone to repair PCs in so I ended up having to do it.

Re: Ask HN: Whats the worst startup idea you've heard, which turned out to be genius?

#78

I thought the YO app, was stupid and pointless till I realized it was used to warn Israeli citizens of missile strikes! Now that app is everywhere and seems to have mastered the concept "notification-is-the-message" philosophy.

I think Marc Andreessen made a good point here, how such one-bit communication turns out to be rather useful for some folks. Don't think this is was YO's initial vision though! :)

https://twitter.com/pmarca/status/479520791671750656

Re: Ask HN: Whats the worst startup idea you've heard, which turned out to be genius?

#79
post #46

I thought the YO app, was stupid and pointless till I realized it was used to warn Israeli citizens of missile strikes! Now that app is everywhere and seems to have mastered the concept "notification-is-the-message" philosophy.

YO is stupid and pointless, and i'm honestly shocked if it even still exists. I guess there's a market for anything.

You think warning Israeli citizens of missile strikes is silly and pointless?

Re: Ask HN: Whats the worst startup idea you've heard, which turned out to be genius?

#80
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

YO is stupid and pointless, and i'm honestly shocked if it even still exists. I guess there's a market for anything.

You think warning Israeli citizens of missile strikes is silly and pointless?

No, I think YO, the app is silly and pointless.

Unless you want to suggest there is literally no other way on a device capable of running the YO app to send a message to a group of people (which would be an absurd thing to assert), then I will stand by my statement. If it's useful, it's useful in spite of its own stupidity, not because of its own brilliance.

Post reply on HN