Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Is it still worth pursuing a software startup?

news.ycombinator.com

71–80 of 239 posts

Re: Ask HN: Is it still worth pursuing a software startup?

#71
post #59

> Big companies can copy your product in no time Your advantage in this case, now or 10 years ago, is that this is simply not true. If your business is "a flashlight app", yeah, eventually they'll copy it (as it happened). However they'll take an unusual long time to do that simple thing (as it also happened). Why? Because everything at big companies is a political game, full of internal conflicts, multiple prioritie…

While I agree with sone of your points, there are many evidences that this happened in the past.

One example is Microsoft creating teams to take on Slack.

Re: Ask HN: Is it still worth pursuing a software startup?

#72
post #62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's a cynical take, but a more positive interpretation is that pivots are needed if your company isn't actually solving a problem. Otherwise people would pay for it, and the founders would be getting rich. So you need to pivot until you actually create a solution to a problem that people will pay for.

> That's a cynical take One that you apparently agree with, given the rest of your comment. > you need to pivot until you actually create a solution to a problem that people will pay for. In other words: You don’t care about the problem, you care about the profit from selling a solution. If a startup is “created to solve a problem” and then pivots to solve a different problem because the first one wasn’t profitable,…

Of course profit is a priority how else are you going to pay the bills/employees etc?

Re: Ask HN: Is it still worth pursuing a software startup?

#74
post #64

It’s still hard to create something successful. Remember that Mark Zuckerberg has had “AGI” for over a decade in the form of tens of thousands of human software engineers and Facebook still has barely been able to create a new successful product on their own without acquiring it from a smaller company.

> Mark Zuckerberg has had “AGI” for over a decade in the form of tens of thousands of human software engineers

This makes me think that companies like Open AI, Anthropic etc are simply new types of body shoppers. body shoppers don’t have their own products they just supply talent to help other companies make products and services.

Re: Ask HN: Is it still worth pursuing a software startup?

#75
Yes, big companies can copy your product. But at what cost, especially when including opportunity cost and the levels of bureaucracy in larger companies? I have heard your question many times during the last 20 years, and still there are more software startups.

In many cases it would cost them less to buy your company than to create it from scratch. Which is why so many small companies are acquired instead of copied. The question should be more what do you want to do and are you able to follow up on creating a startup? Writing the code is a small part of creating a successful startup

Re: Ask HN: Is it still worth pursuing a software startup?

#76
post #72
post #62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> That's a cynical take One that you apparently agree with, given the rest of your comment. > you need to pivot until you actually create a solution to a problem that people will pay for. In other words: You don’t care about the problem, you care about the profit from selling a solution. If a startup is “created to solve a problem” and then pivots to solve a different problem because the first one wasn’t profitable,…

Of course profit is a priority how else are you going to pay the bills/employees etc?

[deleted]

Re: Ask HN: Is it still worth pursuing a software startup?

#78
post #72
post #62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> That's a cynical take One that you apparently agree with, given the rest of your comment. > you need to pivot until you actually create a solution to a problem that people will pay for. In other words: You don’t care about the problem, you care about the profit from selling a solution. If a startup is “created to solve a problem” and then pivots to solve a different problem because the first one wasn’t profitable,…

Of course profit is a priority how else are you going to pay the bills/employees etc?

“The”, not “a”.

There is a chasm of difference between “I care about this problem and want to solve it, but I also need to think how to make it sustainable” and “I don’t really care what I’m tackling, as long as I make bank”.

Both exist. The second one is ever more the norm.

Re: Ask HN: Is it still worth pursuing a software startup?

#79
post #71
post #59

> Big companies can copy your product in no time Your advantage in this case, now or 10 years ago, is that this is simply not true. If your business is "a flashlight app", yeah, eventually they'll copy it (as it happened). However they'll take an unusual long time to do that simple thing (as it also happened). Why? Because everything at big companies is a political game, full of internal conflicts, multiple prioritie…

While I agree with sone of your points, there are many evidences that this happened in the past. One example is Microsoft creating teams to take on Slack.

I dont think the founders or early team at slack are upset with how things played out

Re: Ask HN: Is it still worth pursuing a software startup?

#80
post #71
post #59

> Big companies can copy your product in no time Your advantage in this case, now or 10 years ago, is that this is simply not true. If your business is "a flashlight app", yeah, eventually they'll copy it (as it happened). However they'll take an unusual long time to do that simple thing (as it also happened). Why? Because everything at big companies is a political game, full of internal conflicts, multiple prioritie…

While I agree with sone of your points, there are many evidences that this happened in the past. One example is Microsoft creating teams to take on Slack.

Teams is still nowhere near Slack's features and usefulness. I wouldn't say it's a direct competitor, it's like store brand vs a mid-luxury item
Post reply on HN