Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: AI “white mirror” – what are some inspiring future visions you've seen?

news.ycombinator.com

71–80 of 81 posts

Re: Ask HN: AI “white mirror” – what are some inspiring future visions you've seen?

#71
Anything that prevents us from fucking up this planet and its native inhabitants for good would be nice (and that doesn't involve reducing civilization to ashes).

Something along the lines of a hyperintelligent/-wise and eternally benevolent super ruler AI perhaps.

Re: Ask HN: AI “white mirror” – what are some inspiring future visions you've seen?

#72

Technology just magnifies what's already happening in society (occasionally it disrupts it). What are some good things in our modern society? I'm not a biologist but probably mRNA stuff or medicine that works with your genetic code to give you true immunity, cure chronic diseases, etc. Automation creating a post-scarcity environment where people focus more on expanding their freedoms and quality of life instead of wo…

I really love that last point. Being able to be closer to our fellow citizens of Earth really helps bring things down a notch. Being able to see the movement in HK and what is happening in Ukraine first hand has really affected how we process global events

Re: Ask HN: AI “white mirror” – what are some inspiring future visions you've seen?

#73
Distant, like when we start getting desperate and have to send off individually-piloted space pods to hopeful exoplanets:

AI would pretty much be the only way we can preprogram enough entertainment for an interstellar journey that works for every pioneer.

By feeding back their individual preferences and unique quirks onto tried-and-true scaffolding like Seinfeld or the Marvel franchise, we can probably more easily endure really long stretches of boring space travel.

Re: Ask HN: AI “white mirror” – what are some inspiring future visions you've seen?

#74
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're getting downvoted but I literally just got a memo at work last week reminding people to stop using the terms blacklist and whitelist and switch to block-list and allow-list.

Such a waste of energy and time to get upset at people using these words. Its not like using the word block-list and allow-list was the problem in the first place and using different words wont change anything.

There's a big difference between picking fights about traditional forms in language (wasteful) and pointing out that this person jumped to the wrong conclusion that black mirror = bad mirror, when it's just a poetic way of saying tv. Downvote, call me keyboard sjw be upsed I don't care. Big yikes from me OP, rethink things.

Re: Ask HN: AI “white mirror” – what are some inspiring future visions you've seen?

#75

AI babysitter for infants to supplement – not replace – parents. Captures audio / biometrics and responds to the baby with targeted music, positive affirmations, cooing, etc, to promote positive emotional state. Also notifies parents of states that require their intervention, like hunger, soiled diaper, abnormal vitals, inconsolability. Parents can take a break, watch a movie, entertain friends, etc, with the comfort…

While that's decent, I would wish for something more like, "A boy and his dog" type AI. Having an "invisible friend" that you can speak with and see, who knows everything, is a perfect confidant, who grows with you through life until you are ready to set them down, possibly as a rite of passage into adulthood.

And even then, you could keep in in your computer or phone, be able to talk to it and discuss problems with an intelligence that knows your life almost as closely as you do, but not carrying it with you all of the time.

IDK, I think that would be pretty cool even if the idea of robot nanny scares the pants off of some people.

Re: Ask HN: AI “white mirror” – what are some inspiring future visions you've seen?

#76
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

10 years ago I wrote my academic thesis claiming electronic medical records would fix these things too. They won't. An early warning system is useless if there isn't any funding for public health programs that could help people address said warnings.

> funding for public health programs Why do you believe the solution needs to come from tax collected revenue? If you had a way to make people live healthier, don't you think people would pay you for it?

What creates better public health outcomes, making condoms available widely available at no cost, or letting market forces take care of it?

Re: Ask HN: AI “white mirror” – what are some inspiring future visions you've seen?

#77
Star Trek seems to be a good starting point, but the most obvious parts - space travel, phasers, teleporters - might actually be the least interesting in this context. Here are the parts that stand out to me.

* Energy so abundant it might as well be infinite.

* Instant availability (via replicator) of any food, with infinitesimal environmental or ethical concerns about its production.

* Universal translation.

* Instant diagnosis of injury or disease, and often instant treatment to go with it.

It's noteworthy that none of these involve robots, or necessarily even AI (though that might definitely help with the last two). To be honest, I'm not convinced those technologies will lead to more good outcomes than bad ones. Certainly not with the people currently driving and hyping it. I'll take the boring old physical-world improvements over that dystopia incubator any day.

Re: Ask HN: AI “white mirror” – what are some inspiring future visions you've seen?

#78
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

More effective

The effectiveness comes from exploiting the baby's primal recognition of the mother, which is why it's dystopian. Additionally, by "effective" you mean "the baby spends less time crying," which means that the parents are spending less time with their baby. So parental time is being replaced by an AI. I think it's fair to call that "being raised by AI."

I hope the "Robot nanny optimizes for minimal crytime" argument wasn't written by a parent. What a cold angle.

Re: Ask HN: AI “white mirror” – what are some inspiring future visions you've seen?

#79

AI babysitter for infants to supplement – not replace – parents. Captures audio / biometrics and responds to the baby with targeted music, positive affirmations, cooing, etc, to promote positive emotional state. Also notifies parents of states that require their intervention, like hunger, soiled diaper, abnormal vitals, inconsolability. Parents can take a break, watch a movie, entertain friends, etc, with the comfort…

Selling it as "free up the parents to do other things" is not going to fly. But enhancing the baby's experience or learning is fine. An AI-powered rocker that plays soothing music till the baby sleeps would be great. People already use rockers, it's very accepted. I would never have trusted a computer to be in charge of my infants. Even trusting another human adult is pretty tough already.

The Control Problem is scary enough already. What's the Paperclip Galaxy equivalent for a robot nanny?

Re: Ask HN: AI “white mirror” – what are some inspiring future visions you've seen?

#80
post #14

The one where we stop wishing AI or whatever other toy du jour will solve all our problems. The road to hell is paved with good intentions. I don't buy your utopia, no matter the label. I guess my utopia is where people stop making utopias and start behaving pragmatically.

And off he went to search for berries!
Post reply on HN