Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Macbook Air + Remote Server = Macbook Pro?

news.ycombinator.com

61–70 of 76 posts

Re: Ask HN: Macbook Air + Remote Server = Macbook Pro?

#61

Could you not easily upgrade the RAM to 16gb on the W500? Disk upgrade to 512GB should also be doable. (My x220 has 16Gb/512Gb and it does well for similar vm based setup.) Or do you have an older model w500?

No, the W500 is limited to 8GB. The W510 can take 16GB and the W520+ 32GB

Is it actually limited to 8GB, or is that just what Lenovo says/is willing to support?

My x220 limited to 8GB in ever bit of published Lenovo literature, but I bought 16GB of RAM at the same spec as the 8GB I have running now and everything works fine.

Re: Ask HN: Macbook Air + Remote Server = Macbook Pro?

#62
post #15

I have asked myself the same question as I would like to upgrade my machine. I currently run a MBA 2011 with 4GB of RAM. It is by far my best computer purchase. When I'm at a desk, it's plugged into an external monitor. Until Mountain Lion, I never had a problem with RAM, but I've adjusted how I do things on my laptop to fix the issue. I wrote up a PrOACT and found that it came down to 1 point for me. - Do I require…

Thanks, I don't do any gaming but I would like the ability for multiple monitors. This article suggest that the latest 2012 models do support 2 external displays - http://arstechnica.com/apple/2012/06/new-macbooks-can-manage...

While it can drive two external displays, it only has one Thunderbolt port. The only easy way to attach multiple monitors is chaining Apple's Thunderbolt Displays. Other setups may require Thunderbolt docks or the like.

Re: Ask HN: Macbook Air + Remote Server = Macbook Pro?

#63
Get the retina MBP. You won't have to think about setting up, backing up, connecting to, updating, or securing a remote server if you do. Unless you enjoy doing those things, you are better off saving that time and especially effort for other things like family time.

I get awful headaches using anything more reflective than the MBA display, so unfortunately Apple's retina notebooks are all unusable for me. It is something to consider if you are coming from a high quality matte display like a Thinkpad.

Re: Ask HN: Macbook Air + Remote Server = Macbook Pro?

#64

Could you not easily upgrade the RAM to 16gb on the W500? Disk upgrade to 512GB should also be doable. (My x220 has 16Gb/512Gb and it does well for similar vm based setup.) Or do you have an older model w500?

No, the W500 is limited to 8GB. The W510 can take 16GB and the W520+ 32GB

I upgraded my Dell Latitude E6520 to 16Go while it is supposed to be limited to 8. Don't be fool by the manufacturer specifications.

Re: Ask HN: Macbook Air + Remote Server = Macbook Pro?

#65
I am using an early 2011 MPB. It was my first Mac (after using Debian for 4+ years). I needed it for my school work (using Adobe Photoshop was a must). I needed a computer I could easily carry (home to school and home to girlfriend's home, which is 700km from where I live).

I use my computer for web development, watching a few high resolution movies and playing to some humble bundle games. I didn't buy a MacBook Air because of the integrated graphic chip (some of my friends have one and using it with a 27' monitor made the MBA/MPB 13' really really hot, especially during the summer ; it was around 30/35°C in France). Plus I ended up doing my internship in a company where their core knowledge was working using WebGL. Anyone trying to use our product with a MBA/MBP 13' couldn't because of the integrated graphic.

I also tried to work directly on a server (for coding), it's really great but as soon as you don't have Internet (either you use your phone for the connection or you are stuck and you can't work) you are stuck. And I've been stuck more than I thought I will. I didn't know about mosh at the time and had also a few problems with connection/deconnection and that is really painfull when you are using a few ssh terminal at the same time.

As contingencies said, it's really about comfort, carrying one more kilo was not a problem for me and even if I could spare spending more money having the setup I needed and not being "stuck" when doing something is better than not spending a few euros.

Re: Ask HN: Macbook Air + Remote Server = Macbook Pro?

#66
post #27
post #26

I have the same sort of problem, and went with the MBPr. I need large VMs (6gb+ of ram) and travel a fair bit, so dragging around a big Dell was taking its toll. The MBPr has been great, the only limit being disk space, 512GB fill up quickly when each Windows image takes 40+ GBs. Also, the gorgeous screen, 6 months later, is now ghosting on me. A colleague went with Air + VPN to his home lab, but that fails when your…

Take your MacBook in and you'll get a replacement one, typically on the spot. I know at least 3 people who've had their rMBP replaced due to ghosting.

Just to reiterate this - I had the exact same problem, and they replaced the display immediately.

Re: Ask HN: Macbook Air + Remote Server = Macbook Pro?

#67
post #9

Re portability with the Retina MacBookPro: I've had mine (15") for about 3 months now, and I have to say it's absolutely great. The Air is very thin, and weighs in at 1.35Kg, but has a weak CPU and Intel graphics. The rMBP is not that extremely thin, but it's amazingly thin as well, a lot thinner that the old MBPs and other laptops. It weighs only 2Kg which still makes it very light to carry around. I'd say that for…

Thanks prody, thats really helpful. I've also got an awful habit of consuming media content on my laptop whilst lying back in bed and on the sofa etc. Do you ever do this and find the 15" cumbersome or heavy in these situations?

It's light enough to carry in bed, and is really comfortable to use. I actually do it very often, I even have a laptop bed table but I actually never use it since the rMBP has such a nice solid feel to it.

Even considering bed use, I'd still go with a rMBP over an Air, for the rest of the advantages.

The one thing you might find annoying is that the rMBP can get pretty hot when under stress, e.g. if you watch a movie in bed, it will get warm around the top rows of the keyboard. The way I hold it, it doesn't really bother me that much, though after I got it I took it to an Apple store because I was worried with how hot it would get. You can use something like smcFanControl to turn up the fans, which will make it cool down fast, but it's nicer to use it in bed without it making any noise at all.

If you'd like to see exactly how hot it gets, just go to an apple store, and stress it's CPU a bit

e.g. open a terminal and pipe yes to dev null in 16 processes:

for i in {1..16}; do yes > /dev/null &; done

It should get really warm in ~2 minutes, you can walk around while this happens. (when done, remember to kill the processes: killall yes)

Re: Ask HN: Macbook Air + Remote Server = Macbook Pro?

#68

I have been Macbook Pro based since April 2010. It's my first Mac. I got ~full specs at the time (1GB SATA non-SSD drive - no regrets there, I've needed the space; 2.3Ghz Core i7; 8GB 1333Mhz RAM). I've taken the system through about 10 countries in 2 years. I don't really have a house, and I have to carry everything with me. (That includes a video camera, a heavy pro DSLR, chargers, etc.) I do use VMWare, plus occas…

Did you mean 1TB SATA non-SSD drive :-)?

Re: Ask HN: Macbook Air + Remote Server = Macbook Pro?

#69

MB Air are too big and heavy these days. Go for a Samsung Series 9 or Chromebook, especially if you don't care about Retina. Certainly not the MBPro, they're incredibly heavy and overpriced. I do basically what you're proposing here, with a lightweight ultrabook, and it works very well.

Is that supposed to be a joke or are you really being that ridiculous? MBA is too big and heavy? Right... The Samsung Series 9 is typical Samsung poorly made junk and a Chromebook is a whole different story. The MBP is not heavy or overpriced for what you get. Show me something else in the PC World that compares..oh thats right, there isn't anything.

Re: Ask HN: Macbook Air + Remote Server = Macbook Pro?

#70
post #4

The Air is a somewhat paradoxical machine in that it is extremely portable and therefore perfect for travel, which is when you often lose the data connection and therefore need more power to run VMs! You, however, don't have that problem, if indeed you are most often working from home. In the case you describe, definitely go for the Air, or wait a few months to see if the Air gets a retina screen. I have an air, and…

The 13" retina would be a perfect solution if you could get it with more than 8GB of ram. But since people are suggesting Airs with that much ram I would certainly take the retina 13" instead. Actually smaller but a little heavier than the Air but with that fantastic screen.
Post reply on HN