Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Does anyone use a Raspberry Pi as your main computer?

news.ycombinator.com

61–70 of 194 posts

Re: Ask HN: Does anyone use a Raspberry Pi as your main computer?

#61
I've done so as a trial for a week, and then while traveling. It's not something I'd want to do unless the tiny form factor and price were strict requirements. I found it perfectly adequate for my style of programming (vim + command line), and occasional web browsing (limited when traveling, just to assist in doing stuff off the computer, like buying tickets, but even then, I'd mostly use my phone).

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30783775

> I spent some time traveling where my only computer was a Raspberry Pi 4 running 64 bit mode, and the only sensible graphics performance I could get in wayland was with “foot”. https://codeberg.org/dnkl/foot

> I was really only using it while staying with family and friends where I was always able to use an old monitor or a tiny "bedroom/kitchen" TV, but a hotel TV would be fine too (I'm assuming ports aren't blocked). I brought a Logitech K400 which is small, wireless, and has a builtin trackpad. Was also only using it for programming and basic web browsing. I don't recommend the keyboard (keys are a bit wobbly, some odd key positioning and shapes, definitely takes some getting used to, and the trackpad is relatively poor), but I just wanted something I could use for an hour or two a day, and it was perfectly acceptable for that. If I had to use it for a few more hours, I'd just bring a proper keyboard and mouse (weight permitting).

> I was confident I'd be fine though, I set it up in advance and used it briefly on the couch with a tiny monitor for about a week.

> I strongly recommend taking advantage of the USB HDD boot that's now supported on Pi 4 -- even some 15 year old 60GB spinning platter you have lying around from a long dead laptop is in my experience going to be faster than an SD card. USB3 to SATA connectors are cheap and reliable.

> The reason I did it was just trying not to be wasteful. My laptop died and I have no problem getting a new one, but I'm pretty sure I'll need a new one in a year for work -- the problem is I won't know the specifications (even OS, architecture, etc.) that I'll need until then, so I just wanted to see if I could get away without having to guess in advance. Generally I like to buy only when I need to, and to buy the best thing available at that time (within reason), and use that for a long time.

My uses that are not as a main computer, are that I use a Raspberry Pi 3B+ primarily as a Plex server (streaming content from two big USB3 connected WD HDDs to a PS4 via DLNA), but also a few other things (gitea, Time Machine (though my Macbook is now defunct), tunneling to a supercheap VPS elsewhere). I also use that same RPi3B+ and a Raspberry Pi 4 (4GB, running in 64-bit mode) for occasional ARM dev (armv7h and aarch64, respectively), but it's purely educational (assembly, etc.)

Re: Ask HN: Does anyone use a Raspberry Pi as your main computer?

#62
Since my primary computer is a 2008 MacBook Pro with a Core 2 Duo and 6 gigs of memory, I wanted to see if a Pi 4 with 8 gigs would be an improvement. Of course, I'm not using an SD card for primary storage - I'm using a USB attached SSD.

For many things, it is definitely faster: compiling, ffmpeg, running lots of shells with lots of scrolling in the background, interactive use with high loads.

For browsing, it was definitely slower. Firefox on ARM is significantly slower than Safari on a Core 2 Duo, even when Firefox has more and faster memory and has four real cores.

I eventually decided to build my Pi in to a 1U case with two mirrored 8 TB disks and a serial console, and colocate it. It makes for an excellent, low power server.

Re: Ask HN: Does anyone use a Raspberry Pi as your main computer?

#63
post #32
post #21

I've done this but got tired of it eventually. I had an 8gb raspberry pi 4. I ran xfce4 under raspbian/raspberry pi OS with lightweight applications - luakit for a browser, claws mail for email, terminal, and a few background processes. I also casted to my TV from Gnomecast and, later, VLC. Coding was all done in micro with a few plugins enabled. Mostly it worked pretty well, but with too many tabs opened it would st…

This is close to my answer. Good alternatives for not much more money. Good for limiting wasteful time. The more system I have, the more I want to screw around. I use Visual Studio Code and Obsidian on my system and they both run fine. They are probably among the better Electron apps though.

Except that Udoo is 10x the price I paid for a pi 4, actually 13x including exchange rates.

Re: Ask HN: Does anyone use a Raspberry Pi as your main computer?

#65
I have a Pi 4 (8gb) that I use as a home web server. I use a USB flash drive for the OS (Raspbian)/storage and run Apache on it. I have it running in a case with heat sink and a fan. It's quite a useful device for my purposes but it simply isn't up to the task of general computing. I notice big lags when trying to do literally anything. Even just opening up a code editor (VS Code) and a single browser tab you'd think the thing was on its last legs.

I ssh into it from my Windows machine and that seems to work really well. I have noticed a slight amount of lag in the ssh sessions but it's nominal and not a show stopper.

That being said, I only use it as a server and for the last year haven't had a single issue with it. I love it for what it is and want as many as I can get my hands on.

Re: Ask HN: Does anyone use a Raspberry Pi as your main computer?

#66

For the people who answer this, I'd like to know if they booted from an sd-card or ssd-device as well. I noticed a huge difference in the responsiveness when using my Pi 4 (only via ssh and with a terminal) for some machine learning jobs after I switched to boot from an external SSD. For Pi4s made in the last couple of years, booting from ssd seems to be a built-in feature, without any need for flashing anything on t…

For me using SSD with Pi is the key point to make it useable for daily driver. SSD plus overclocking.

Re: Ask HN: Does anyone use a Raspberry Pi as your main computer?

#67

For the people who answer this, I'd like to know if they booted from an sd-card or ssd-device as well. I noticed a huge difference in the responsiveness when using my Pi 4 (only via ssh and with a terminal) for some machine learning jobs after I switched to boot from an external SSD. For Pi4s made in the last couple of years, booting from ssd seems to be a built-in feature, without any need for flashing anything on t…

I was going to say this. The sdcard is the weak link in the Raspberry Pi system. Even a USB flash drive is better. I have a Pi 4 that I use as a secondary system and it boots from an external SSD. It makes a real difference in responsiveness.

Re: Ask HN: Does anyone use a Raspberry Pi as your main computer?

#68
post #65

I have a Pi 4 (8gb) that I use as a home web server. I use a USB flash drive for the OS (Raspbian)/storage and run Apache on it. I have it running in a case with heat sink and a fan. It's quite a useful device for my purposes but it simply isn't up to the task of general computing. I notice big lags when trying to do literally anything. Even just opening up a code editor (VS Code) and a single browser tab you'd think…

server that does what? is there anything good to do with a home server? like host a webpage?

Re: Ask HN: Does anyone use a Raspberry Pi as your main computer?

#69

Since my primary computer is a 2008 MacBook Pro with a Core 2 Duo and 6 gigs of memory, I wanted to see if a Pi 4 with 8 gigs would be an improvement. Of course, I'm not using an SD card for primary storage - I'm using a USB attached SSD. For many things, it is definitely faster: compiling, ffmpeg, running lots of shells with lots of scrolling in the background, interactive use with high loads. For browsing, it was d…

Did you jump of the MacOS upgrade path? I had to get rid of a computer that couldn't upgrade around the same age (but maybe slightly older)

Re: Ask HN: Does anyone use a Raspberry Pi as your main computer?

#70
post #65

I have a Pi 4 (8gb) that I use as a home web server. I use a USB flash drive for the OS (Raspbian)/storage and run Apache on it. I have it running in a case with heat sink and a fan. It's quite a useful device for my purposes but it simply isn't up to the task of general computing. I notice big lags when trying to do literally anything. Even just opening up a code editor (VS Code) and a single browser tab you'd think…

server that does what? is there anything good to do with a home server? like host a webpage?

I host web apps that I serve on my local network only. Little utility apps for myself and my fam and the like.
Post reply on HN