Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Why there are so many ads on YouTube?

news.ycombinator.com

61–70 of 114 posts

Re: Ask HN: Why there are so many ads on YouTube?

#61

Anybody reading this site can afford to pay for YouTube Premium to eliminate the ads. How much is your time worth?

That’s an overly broad generalization without any data behind it. And my self respect and stance against such corporations are worth more than other things. Why would I want to pay and encourage extortion and abuse?

Re: Ask HN: Why there are so many ads on YouTube?

#62
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A lot of people watch YouTube using their smart TVs.

Yes, not so smart now… Edit: However I do marvel at the infrastructure in place to support this, even at scale it can’t be cheap.

You mean Youtube's infrastructure? Don't worry, Google and Youtube are rolling in enough green dough thanks to those very ads they are serving. They can afford all the infrastructure they need and the engineers to build it.

How? Google made $182 billion in revenue in 2020, of which $41 billion was profit [1] (mostly in ads), and Youtube alone is on track to generate $15 billion of those [2] on an annualized basis (also almost all in ad revenue).

[1] https://abc.xyz/investor/static/pdf/2020Q4_alphabet_earnings... [2] https://www.theverge.com/2020/2/3/21121207/youtube-google-al...

Re: Ask HN: Why there are so many ads on YouTube?

#64
I like to think that the ads help me moderate my Youtube usage. When someone sends me a Youtube link and I open it instinctively, I now have approximately half a minute to decide if I really want to waste my time and attention on it. A lot of the time I decide I don't, and so the ads turn out to be useful for me.

Re: Ask HN: Why there are so many ads on YouTube?

#66

I would vouch they need money to pay for hosting and everything else, and as a free service perhaps ads are the only way. Not sure how one can expect youtube to host that amount of content for free perpetually. I dislike ads, particularly dark patterns, and shocking I pay for youtube premium. An unpopular opinion but can someone please explain how can all this be hosted for free? Or why do some believe they should?

If youtube becomes paywalled, I'll just stop using youtube. It's that simple.

Re: Ask HN: Why there are so many ads on YouTube?

#67

I would vouch they need money to pay for hosting and everything else, and as a free service perhaps ads are the only way. Not sure how one can expect youtube to host that amount of content for free perpetually. I dislike ads, particularly dark patterns, and shocking I pay for youtube premium. An unpopular opinion but can someone please explain how can all this be hosted for free? Or why do some believe they should?

I'd honestly pay for their premium 13$ per month if it wasn't Google:

Doing so would allow them to cross reference all their tracking to my personal details, or at least to a fixed id.

Re: Ask HN: Why there are so many ads on YouTube?

#68
post #51
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A lot of people watch YouTube using their smart TVs.

Smart as in 'Stephen Hawking smart' or smart as in 'Machiavellian smart'? Things can be one or the other (but not exclusively).

The word "smart" is so overloaded with definitions as to be nearly useless in such discussions. I like this set of definitions:

- Intelligence is being able to observe systems [1] and understand how they work. Both Hawking and Machiavelli objectively have this.

- Smartness is being able to use one's understanding of a system [1] to achieve one's own goals. Both Hawking and Machiavelli objectively have this.

- Wisdom is being able to choose the right goals. This is where there is a clear distinction between Hawking and Machiavelli, and since it requires moral judgment to deliberate whom of them chooses "the right goals", this cannot have an objective answer.

By the way, it's easy to see with these systems that existing machines that are supposedly "intelligent" and "smart" are in fact neither.

[1] "System" shall be interpreted in the broadest way possible, i.e. "any network of interconnected actors", e.g. a machine or the financial system or any society of people.

Re: Ask HN: Why there are so many ads on YouTube?

#69

Just use an adblocker. The only time I see see ads on YouTube are when I'm using someone else's browser.

Exactly. I don't understand people not having an ad blocker... Otherwise pi-hole is a good option for your local network.

With pihole I keep getting playback error when video starts basically cause the ad can't play. If I refresh then it plays normally cause YouTube doesn't show the ad the 2nd time being tricked it was already watched.

Re: Ask HN: Why there are so many ads on YouTube?

#70
post #10

Just use an adblocker. The only time I see see ads on YouTube are when I'm using someone else's browser.

I have ad blocker. I block all ads at the DNS level. I don't think you can block some of the ads on YT. Is that possible with browser plugins?

For Android blockada seems to fail to block them
Post reply on HN