Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Do you keep a personal journal?

news.ycombinator.com

61–70 of 109 posts

Re: Ask HN: Do you keep a personal journal?

#61

Do you keep a personal journal? Yes. If yes, do you find it useful? Yes What tools would you recommend? A well-crafted acid-free paper notebook, comfortable pens. Is there any specific methodology that you follow? Yes. When journaling, do you try to track any specific aspects of your life or just write about anything that is currently occupying your mind? I keep a system of journals. One series for personal thoughts,…

What is your specific methodology? Or is that what you mean by your next answer? Also, do you revisit your journals?

What is your specific methodology? Or is that what you mean by your next answer?

To answer both at once: the methodology used is specific to my goals. They're specified by me and probably only work with how I approach each topic.

For example, my mathematical journals are rather structured. I move between branches over time but I tend to stay focused in a single area for quite some time working on problems, derivations, and occasionally formulating simple proofs from theorems I've built up as I ask questions. Often re-inventing much of what has been discovered but the purpose of the journals is to learn the process and to make maths a habit as much as it is to document the journey.

My personal journals are much more free-form. I just write stream-of-consciousness what I'm thinking as I look at the page.

Also, do you revisit your journals?

Often. The point of objectifying myself is to examine why I think the way I do, how opinions and habits entered my life, etc. The result of such examinations is that I can choose to change these qualities over time.

The unexamined life is not worth living. The significance came to me late in life but began as child when my mortality and that of those I loved came to me in the night. Life is a horizon of filth, gore, tears, laughter... surviving. On the shores of death I do not wish to go without leaving some evidence of my journey. The pursuit of wisdom, to me, is the joy of being human.

Re: Ask HN: Do you keep a personal journal?

#62
For years I've tried to keep something like a journal, but I've never quite found an app that ticked all my requirements.

Funny you should post this now - the solution that is working for now - is a google form for which I have a shortcut on my phone.

I did as much as a could to minimize typing - lots of multiple choice, linear scales, checkboxes, etc. Then one open text field at the end for notes.

I've actually been sticking with this - before I go to sleep I open the shortcut and fill out the form. If I feel up to it I elaborate on the notes, but at the very least I fill out everything else.

Been working so far - quick, easy, and the fact that it's in a spreadsheet makes it useful.

Re: Ask HN: Do you keep a personal journal?

#63
I began journaling in my 20's by quickly recapping the day's itinerary in a Sierra Club day calendar given to me on every birthday. (Sadly, those somehow went missing during a move years ago. I'm hoping they're just buried in the bottom of a box somewhere!)

Since 1999, I've been using DailyDiary [1] to journal and track specific topics such as my personal day-to-day activities, weight, exercise, health issues, kid's day-to-day, specific projects, etc. The key for me is to be consistent, and the email nature of DailyDiary tries to reduce that friction as much as possible.

Having so much (searchable) written history has proven immensely helpful on occasion. And it's fun to reminisce when reminded of an event in the past. The kids get a kick out of hearing stories of their past too.

[1] https://www.dailydiary.com/

Disclosure: I'm the founder.

Re: Ask HN: Do you keep a personal journal?

#64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What is your specific methodology? Or is that what you mean by your next answer? Also, do you revisit your journals?

What is your specific methodology? Or is that what you mean by your next answer? To answer both at once: the methodology used is specific to my goals. They're specified by me and probably only work with how I approach each topic. For example, my mathematical journals are rather structured. I move between branches over time but I tend to stay focused in a single area for quite some time working on problems, derivation…

> the methodology used is specific to my goals

I strongly recommend this attitude. A tool off the shelf rarely fits the hand well; when the tool in question serves to help investigate the self, a prepackaged methodology poses the risk of shaping oneself to fit the tool, rather than the other way around.

Re: Ask HN: Do you keep a personal journal?

#65
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The general idea sounds good to me (just spend 60 seconds on it, and no more). But I wouldn't use it on principle because a journal is private, and having it handled by a third-party doesn't sound like a good idea at all. Especially when you explicitly state that it is transcribed, archived, and searchable.

Why would it being transcribed and searchable mean it's not private? Everything is automated and encrypted along the way, so I won't be able to look at it even if I wanted to. I realize that privacy is an important concern which is why I've taken it extremely seriously. So rest assured, this journal is private.

That's nice to say and all, but there would seem of necessity to exist a point at which the incoming audio data is present on a server you control but has yet to be encrypted. In any case, since all the encryption and decryption necessarily takes place on hosts you control with keys you hold, your claim of privacy comes with a whole constellation of caveats which you choose not to mention. This fails to inspire confidence.

Perhaps I've misunderstood how your service works, and these concerns have no basis in fact. If so, it would be awesome to know that! Such information might make a very good fit for a privacy policy, which I'm having a very hard time finding any mention of on your site. (Yes, I saw the brief, breezy dismissal of such concerns in the FAQ section of your pricing page. That doesn't count. And, no, I haven't tried it. I shouldn't need to try it to get some idea of what you actually do to mitigate these risks.)

I hate to seem overly harsh on this point, but these are uncertain times, and your service is one which invites people to trust it with the sort of deeply personal information which, in the wrong hands, could be misused to ends from embarrassment to social and professional annihilation. Perhaps you have given this hazard the degree of concern it merits, and engineered your service to minimize it to the maximum possible extent. If so, you might do well to present the appearance of having done so, too.

Re: Ask HN: Do you keep a personal journal?

#66
post #55

No, because it would be used against me in a court of law.

Don't fall victim to the chilling effect. There are ways to safely keep a journal. If you're afraid of being actively targeted you could even use a airgapped journaling laptop that never gets connected to anything or updated.

Why would I go through the trouble of writing something down in the first place if I had to use an airgapped laptop?

I'd either just remember it or decide it's not worth remembering.

Re: Ask HN: Do you keep a personal journal?

#67

I use notational velocity for logging. Every day I create an entry with today's date. For example, today I am writing on "20170126". I use it primarily as a todo-list. Each morning I write down what I plan to do today. I also try to plan each task in terms of time, so for example: --- 9am - 10am: work on task A 10am - 11am: look into task B ... --- Then as the day progresses I mark down things as [DONE] when I finish…

Have you tried to nvALT? Its an update to Notational Velocity.

Re: Ask HN: Do you keep a personal journal?

#68

I use notational velocity for logging. Every day I create an entry with today's date. For example, today I am writing on "20170126". I use it primarily as a todo-list. Each morning I write down what I plan to do today. I also try to plan each task in terms of time, so for example: --- 9am - 10am: work on task A 10am - 11am: look into task B ... --- Then as the day progresses I mark down things as [DONE] when I finish…

Have you tried to nvALT? Its an update to Notational Velocity.

yup in fact that's what i use

Re: Ask HN: Do you keep a personal journal?

#69
I have kept one off and on. I like writing using pen and paper. Given that I type much more quickly and I'm at a computer all day, a file-based journal is more pragmatic.

I wrote a simple script 14 years ago to automate the organization for me.

http://pastebin.com/pnWQemAf

I just alias a simple one letter command to "jour.py work" or "jour.py blog" and running it will open a file with a date-based name in my editor of choice. Re-running it on the same day gets me the same file.

This method has the advantage of a very organized, timeless format. The disadvantage is that it's on my local machine. Of course, a cloud based file store could be used, but there is no default encryption and there is no mobile option.

Re: Ask HN: Do you keep a personal journal?

#70
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Don't fall victim to the chilling effect. There are ways to safely keep a journal. If you're afraid of being actively targeted you could even use a airgapped journaling laptop that never gets connected to anything or updated.

Why would I go through the trouble of writing something down in the first place if I had to use an airgapped laptop? I'd either just remember it or decide it's not worth remembering.

There's plenty of anecdotes in this thread on why it's a good idea to keep a journal. It's also not just about remembering, but about better understanding what you're thinking in the first place.

Beyond that, for me personally it's about liberty. If I don't want to do something, sure I won't do it. But if I do want to do something then I wouldn't let fear get the best of me. Thus not keeping a journal because its contents might be used in a court of law is just a sad state of affairs. Something which I would actively work against, and indeed it's what motivated me to comment here in the first place. It's not even that I think keeping a journal is the best thing ever, but not doing it due to chilling effects is quite horrible.

Post reply on HN