Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Distributed data centers in our basements

news.ycombinator.com

51–60 of 69 posts

Re: Ask HN: Distributed data centers in our basements

#51

Lots of people have had this idea since the early days of Bitcoin mining. Some have even done it. I recommend looking up how people have set up mining rigs in their homes.

I’d imagine it’s a bit easier with Bitcoin, as the mining rig would belong to the home owner.

It comes vastly more complex when a company is looking to rent a portion of a person’s basement. They’d probably want to have levels of physical security, then access for any required service. Power usage would need to be tracked and accounted for—-who pays it? I’d imagine there would also need to be a common interface for collecting and making use of the heat, if it isn’t just a generic space heater.

I’ve also wondered if some kind of Folding@home project would work for distributing training or load of an open-source model that isn’t owned by a megacorp.

Re: Ask HN: Distributed data centers in our basements

#53
For those who did not know you can get Telekom Deutschland to give you a fixed IP on your fiber or DSL for only a little more than consumer rate if you have a business (but thats easy to just register).

If you ask nicely they give you fiber and vdsl combined with 2 fixed IPs for under 90€ a month. Means you can host everything from bind9 authoritative nameservers at home.

I like my homeservers. Heat. And also if the platters work on my hdds it sounds a bit like rain lol.

Re: Ask HN: Distributed data centers in our basements

#56
Actually reading that Iran attacked AWS and is going to attack other major cloud providers, the massively distributed compute is going to be the only solution that will be resilient enough for the current civilization to survive attacks on the infrastructure.

We'll be certainly less performant and less capable, but the data will continue to flow and business processes will proceed. If cloud data centers are destroyed, everything that's important to sustain us stops and we die.

Re: Ask HN: Distributed data centers in our basements

#57

100 computers in 100 homes is way harder to maintain than 100 computers in one place

100 computers in 100 homes are way harder to find and get destroyed, unlike dropping one bomb on an AWS region. Also it's much easier to get rebuilt and running again than $1-5 bn data center.

Re: Ask HN: Distributed data centers in our basements

#59
post #31

Does your house have redundant power connections to the grid and a failover generator? That said, my plex server for my friends is on an ups and I'm on 1Gb fiber and I have better uptime than AWS.

> I have better uptime than AWS. You're not serving tens of millions of people.

Nor the amount of computers. So what

Re: Ask HN: Distributed data centers in our basements

#60
I guess it'd only work in places where the locals don't use AC. Otherwise it'd be a killer to run in the summer, and so you'd have capital goods rotting in a persons basement half the year.

If the user has AC for the summer, then running the AC in reverse for the winter will provide the homeowner with far more heating per joule than running a computer.

So the issue boils down to, there's not enough people living in places cold enough to make it worthwhile.

Of course, Id argue AI data centers aren't worth it full stop.

Post reply on HN