Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Where do you sit?

news.ycombinator.com

51–60 of 74 posts

Re: Ask HN: Where do you sit?

#51

The Steelcase leap is the best when it comes to the high end office chairs. I had aerons for the longest time but the non adjustability is not worth the price paid.

For me it was a tossup between the Herman Miller Aeron ($450 refurb) and Steelcase Leap 2 ($250 refurb).

I picked the Leap 2 and never looked back. Fabric seats, more adjustability, very sturdy and cheaper refurb prices (I think at full price it's similar to the Aeron).

The Aeron has that coolness factor which the Leap 2 doesn't (Leap 2 looks very conventional) but it has been a sturdy chair throughout the pandemic to now.

Re: Ask HN: Where do you sit?

#52
We have IKEA chairs. But everyone has different chair needs. One of the best things about IKEA is that you can go to one of their stores and try them all out to see which one(s) suit you most.

Re: Ask HN: Where do you sit?

#53
Herman Miller Embody, had it for over the 12 year warranty and it’s still going strong. Got another for work and my wife has used it since WFH.

It’s super comfortable. I do need to wash the red fabric. Black one is still perfect.

I used a company that let me borrow them (tried Aeron too) for a week, so got a solid test before buying.

Re: Ask HN: Where do you sit?

#54
I don't work for Herman Miller. I sit in an Herman Miller since 12 years and the warranty on my Aeron is expiring now (they come brand new with a 12 years warranty, which speaks about it's quality). Is it pricey brand new? Yup (although I ordered mine without the armrests and it was a bit cheaper). Is it worth it? Totally.

I read its manual and spend about 30 minutes configuring it when I bought it. I've done that once, 12 years ago. Settings haven't changed.

Some complain about the plastic part hurting their legs: that's either an inappropriately sized or inappropriately configured or a wrong sitting position.

Basically the "trick" to configuring an Aeron is that if you put both your hands behind your head the chair should basically lean back by itself. And if you then extend your arms on top of your keyboard, the chair must lean forward again.

The "pellicle mesh" on the Aeron was at first designed for old people, to prevent injuries and sweating due from sitting hours and hours. Then they realized that offices had people sitting long hours and they pivoted.

I do prefer the Aeron to the more recent models Herman Miller made.

As a bonus the Aeron is at the MoMA as a permanent exhibition. It's a work of art. It's seen in oh-so-many series and movies and it used to be the iconic Web 1.0 chair.

Fun story: sister-in-law saw mine at my home office back when I bought it and told me "oh, I've got the same at work, I don't like it I'm not comfortable in it". So I told her to have someone come and configure it correctly for her. A few weeks later my brother ordered four of them for its house.

My best friend has one. My brother has two, my sister in law has two. My wife has one.

Should mine break I'd buy a new one instantly and be good for 12 years.

They're pricey but it's my endgame: it's the last chair I'll be using.

Re: Ask HN: Where do you sit?

#55

The trouble with chair recommendations is that the best chair for me isn't the best chair for you. If you are able, going to a warehouse or store of some kind where you can try the chairs out will make all the difference. To answer your q directly: I have tried Herman Millers in the past but they just didn't do it for me, too stuffy and I dislike the arms. I went for a Humanscale Diffrient World instead, it is all me…

> too stuffy and I dislike the arms.

I cannot stand arms on any chair. That's why I ordered my Aeron without armrets.

Re: Ask HN: Where do you sit?

#56
I've been using an IKEA Markus chair for -- I believe -- at least 10 years. It's pretty OK. I can sit in it for a whole day (sans brief breaks) and not experience any pain. I'm a bit shorter and a lot lighter than the average adult male in the US.

It's starting to show signs of wear around the headrest -- flakes of the covering are coming off.

Re: Ask HN: Where do you sit?

#57
post #46

Currently on a couch with a laptop since I've been too lazy/cheap to set up something like an Altwork Station (imagine a, $8,000 dentist's chair with a monitor above it). Hopefully Apple Vision Pro will be good enough that I can strap one of those on and working from almost anything where I can recline (sofa chair, couch, bed, car seat, etc.)

[dead]

Re: Ask HN: Where do you sit?

#58
post #41

I sit half-standing at a really tall desk on a stool I made out of a big sheave, a 3" steel pipe, and a piece of rough-cut 3/8" plate. so I get to stand up and work and sit down and work without a big fuss. it tilts forward and back just because of the way the casters sit under the sheave. it sounds really uncomfortable, but anything else makes me feel all cramped up.

Any chance you've got pictures? It sounds like a few of us here are happier without the padding, and I've been passively looking out for a sit/stand solution for my in-office days.

just left, but I'll take one when I get in tomorrow - so check back. padding aside i think having a tall work surface and a stool is really alot more natural and convenient than a desk with motorized screws.

Re: Ask HN: Where do you sit?

#59

I sit and sleep on solid, hard surfaces. None of that springy, bouncy, squishy surfaces for me. My bed is custom build from hard oak wood with a very thin layer of cushioning. And my main work chair has also a solid wood seating area, with some thin cushioning of the base.

[dead]

Re: Ask HN: Where do you sit?

#60
Posture is most affected by muscle (im)balance, so if you want to fix hunching, consider exercises like face pulls that strengthen the back muscles that counter the chest muscles that pull your shoulders forward. There are ways to do these exercises at home with no equipment.

Second to that is the fit of all of your equipment: chair height, keyboard/mouse height, and monitor height. This can be difficult, especially if you are below the median male height.

I use motorized standing desks because they offer the greatest amount of control over surface height. I have a keyboard tray on one that allows me to set the keyboard lower than the work surface. I have all my monitors on arms so that I can set them to the proper height.

As for seating, other posts about spending for quality are right, as are options to buy used.

Herman Miller isn't the only game in town, though. I've been very happy with Steelcase products. I have the Gesture at work, and it's a great work chair with fantastic back support. At home, I have the Leap. Also a great chair for work, but I find it's easier to use in more relaxed tasks (e.g., gaming or watching YouTube).

It's taken me a while to get everything set up ergonomically, and while if you are judicious there are ways to save money, it isn't cheap. Of course, it's a lot cheaper than healthcare, so spend what your budget allows to take care of your body during working hours.

Post reply on HN