Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Best practices for safeguarding master password in organization?

news.ycombinator.com

51–53 of 53 posts

Re: Ask HN: Best practices for safeguarding master password in organization?

#51
post #28

The way I'd in principle want to solve this problem (controlling access to root-level resources that don't support delegation) would be with some kind of "escorted remote access" system, wherein an authorized set of people can remotely log into a special browser session that's able to act as the root user, but only with another authorized party watching and monitoring the session and able to kill it, so that no one c…

I've been thinking of a similar project but over SSH rather than a browser based thing.

Problem with that is that not everything is controllable over ssh. Sometimes you have to use a web interface provided by a vendor because that's the only thing they offer.

Re: Ask HN: Best practices for safeguarding master password in organization?

#52
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've been thinking of a similar project but over SSH rather than a browser based thing.

Problem with that is that not everything is controllable over ssh. Sometimes you have to use a web interface provided by a vendor because that's the only thing they offer.

true,

On the other hand I think a two-person SSH is probably an easier thing to build in terms of recording what was done for audit, and maybe even require both parties to confirm commands before executing them. Also your SSH server could require both parties with different keys to login before it starts or something. I think this kind of stuff would be harder to implement in a web browser (but just as useful probably)

Re: Ask HN: Best practices for safeguarding master password in organization?

#53
The only password I know by heart is Bitwarden master password, and if MacOS would let me skip it typing it for weeks (say with some kind of biometric authentication) I'd be toasted by now...

(Ok to be honest is related to a book I have in my room, so I feel like I'd at some point remember it when desperate...)

Post reply on HN