Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How is your experience with a mechanical keyboard?

news.ycombinator.com

51–54 of 54 posts

Re: Ask HN: How is your experience with a mechanical keyboard?

#51
I've got a Keyboardio Model 100 on order which I'm hoping will arrive in January. I'll be graduating from a Microsoft Natural Ergonomic 4000, the model I've loved and used for donkey's ages.

I'll admit I'm a bit anxious about choosing the switches. Every time I read about mechanical keyboards it seems to be "a big deal™". I'll be choosing between Kailh Silent BOX Brown (tactile), BOX red (linear), BOX white (clicky) switches, plus a fourth yet to be decided.

Noise is a bit issue - quieter the better - so the whites are off the menu. Have to dig into the pros and cons at some point.

Re: Ask HN: How is your experience with a mechanical keyboard?

#52
I have an Ergodox-EZ. I originally ordered it with loud clicky key switches but have converted to a much quieter switch with a weaker spring. I chose that model because of the columnar layout. I really only use about 48 keys on it due to the layers that firmware gives you. I have a full size number pad on the right if I hold down the “a” key, and the home row on the right switches to arrow keys if I hold down “f”. I’ve got another layer for working on MacOS so I don’t have to have funky layouts to make it work between Apple, Windows, and Linux.

The model I have is also tented and that’s where there’s a huge gain for me. The fact that I can position the two halves of my keyboard anywhere and that they’re tented relives a lot of stress in my wrists and elbow. I might not still be a developer without this tool. Whenever I travel with just a laptop I bring a Keyboardio Atreus. It’s not tented but it’s enough to help me get through short trips.

Re: Ask HN: How is your experience with a mechanical keyboard?

#53
I use a Das keyboard, full with Cherry MX Brown switches, that I bought most of a decade ago, early on in college. I've tried a variety of mechanical keyboards, from friends and at a student-run computer lab, so I know the sensations available, in terms of actuation force and tactile and linear variants.

I bottom out hard, and feel knuckle-, eventually wrist-pain, when typing intently for more than half an hour on Apple external keyboards. In the long run, it keeps typing more comfortable, so it's a kind of survival advantage.

To reduce noise, it's my current practice to put a thin hand towel under the keyboard, both at home and at co-working spaces. It eliminates some of the deeper more noticeable noises. This helps lessen annoyance, or at least comments, from friends, roommates, and partners, and so is again, a survival (of on-going use of my current setup) advantage.

Re: Ask HN: How is your experience with a mechanical keyboard?

#54

I'm using Keychron K2 - https://www.keychron.com/products/keychron-k2-wireless-mecha... So far it was great, I love tactile sound of a mechanical keyboard. There is some sort of pleasure in it. But to be honest, it's easier to use MX keys or an Apple Keyboard. Because my hands get sore after writing couple of hours without break. Would I suggest K2? Yeah it's a great keyboard but If I'm on a market for Mechanical Key…

On a Mac you can change the keyboard settings where it makes media keys the default.
Post reply on HN