Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Why there are so many ads on YouTube?

news.ycombinator.com

51–60 of 114 posts

Re: Ask HN: Why there are so many ads on YouTube?

#51
post #18

Just use an adblocker. The only time I see see ads on YouTube are when I'm using someone else's browser.

A lot of people watch YouTube using their smart TVs.

Smart as in 'Stephen Hawking smart' or smart as in 'Machiavellian smart'? Things can be one or the other (but not exclusively).

Re: Ask HN: Why there are so many ads on YouTube?

#53

I would vouch they need money to pay for hosting and everything else, and as a free service perhaps ads are the only way. Not sure how one can expect youtube to host that amount of content for free perpetually. I dislike ads, particularly dark patterns, and shocking I pay for youtube premium. An unpopular opinion but can someone please explain how can all this be hosted for free? Or why do some believe they should?

I would pay, except youtube had these ads that are like, " hate being annoyed by ads? Pay us!" Fuck youtube.

TANSTAAFL

Re: Ask HN: Why there are so many ads on YouTube?

#54
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A lot of people watch YouTube using their smart TVs.

Alternate/hacked YouTube apps exist that you can install on your TV that won't show ads... Also, if you cast stuff to the TV, you only need a modded version of YouTube on your phone - you don't need to make any changes to the TV.

YouTube Vanced[1] for Android is awesome. It supports background playback and allows you to block all ads as well as community posts, surveys, premium movies, and just about anything else. They recently integrated SponsorBlock[2], which allows you to block in-video intros, outros, sponsored sections, and subscription reminders.

However it uses microG, which has long had an open issue with v2 of Google's Cast API. The issue was recently closed however I don't believe it was solved. However it is still possible to work around this. I ended up writing a quick script on my phone that uses pychromecast to initialize the cast so that it can be passed off to YouTube Vanced.

It's been a while since I've cast anything but are you certain that ads are blocked when casting from an app that blocks ads? In my experience with casting, the video is always streamed directly from the content provider's servers (YouTube) to the cast receiver (smart TV) with ads intact. You would need to mirror your phone's display in order to block ads.

[1]: https://vancedapp.com

[2]: https://sponsor.ajay.app

[3]: https://github.com/microg/GmsCore/issues/79

Re: Ask HN: Why there are so many ads on YouTube?

#55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would pay, except youtube had these ads that are like, " hate being annoyed by ads? Pay us!" Fuck youtube.

TANSTAAFL

No, literally youtube had ads which just said things like, "does your kid hate it when youtube has commercials? Does it annoy you when they scream because of that? Pay us to remove them!"

It works be one thing to advertise a service or product, but they just put ads in to literally annoy you into paying. I'm not kidding.

I WAS a YouTube premium member until recently, but dropped it because of crap like this.

I know there's no free lunch, my comment was about the way youtube does business: it's a dick move to annoy users into paying you. How is that worth a tnstaafl reply?

I wonder if the world has passed me by when I think that I'm taking a stand against corporate greed and bullshit and everyone else happily goes along with whatever.

Re: Ask HN: Why there are so many ads on YouTube?

#59

Just use an adblocker. The only time I see see ads on YouTube are when I'm using someone else's browser.

It doesn’t work against in video ads.

something works, because I don't get ads on my desktop browser at home (firefox + uBlock Origin + Privacy Badger + PiHole) but I do see them when I'm away from home on the app on my tablet.

OK, because ppl are gonna ask, I checked: I'm not seeing ads in the app on my tablet at home, so its the PiHole cutting ads. Ooops, I'm not seeing ads on my desktop when using my smartphone as a hotspot either (no PiHole), so Firefox + uBO + PB also blocks YT ads.

Re: Ask HN: Why there are so many ads on YouTube?

#60
post #13
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have ad blocker. I block all ads at the DNS level. I don't think you can block some of the ads on YT. Is that possible with browser plugins?

I use uBlock Origin and I never see a single ad on YouTube. This is for my laptop though; I still haven't figured a decent solution for my phone.

There's uBlock Origin for Firefox on Android
Post reply on HN