Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What are your personal red flags when you're interviewing at a company?

news.ycombinator.com

41–50 of 133 posts

Re: Ask HN: What are your personal red flags when you're interviewing at a company?

#41
post #34
post #15

Pro-tip: Too many interviewers can be threatened by incoming talent being better than them.

That's so sad. I get so excited when I interview candidates that are ahead of me in their knowledge and experience.

Many managers are very sad shadows of what they could be.

Re: Ask HN: What are your personal red flags when you're interviewing at a company?

#42

The ones that come to mind: * If they are a small company who outsources any step of their interview process to another company. If you're only interviewing for a couple positions—people you will work with every single day—take the time to do it yourself. * If they are a startup that says they are looking for people who are interested in solving exciting problems . For some people, this is going to be an enticement,…

"looking for people who are interested in solving exciting problems."

This and other grandiose language is an immediate red flag. I fully expect the people writing these to be the equivalent of used car salesmen.

Re: Ask HN: What are your personal red flags when you're interviewing at a company?

#43
post #29
post #23

All of these have happened to me: - The interviewer is wearing a suit. - The interviewer asks "you've worked with [person who now works at our company] before, what do you think about them?". Bonus points if they insist after I give a diplomatic answer. - "Why are you using microservices?" "Because everyone is doing it" - Not following up. For weeks. - "Can you send us your high school diploma?" - Take home assignmen…

"Take home assignment with a time limit." What's your concern there? (Honest question!) I feel terrible about asking for home assignments but I feel like it's good for people like myself who are terrible about coding live. (I usually have a choice of live or homework.) I put a "limit" as a guideline about what kind of quality to expect, usually with language about things not to worry about. I don't expect/want folks…

The main issue is that you can give any guidelines you want but a ton of people will take "Don't spend more than 4 hours on this" with an implied nudge/nudge/wink/wink.

That said, as I wrote elsewhere, if you can't pull a reasonable version of a work product out of a folder, I may be asking you to create one. I'm not necessarily talking code but I absolutely am looking for some proof that you can do the work if it's not already in the wild.

Re: Ask HN: What are your personal red flags when you're interviewing at a company?

#44
post #23

All of these have happened to me: - The interviewer is wearing a suit. - The interviewer asks "you've worked with [person who now works at our company] before, what do you think about them?". Bonus points if they insist after I give a diplomatic answer. - "Why are you using microservices?" "Because everyone is doing it" - Not following up. For weeks. - "Can you send us your high school diploma?" - Take home assignmen…

What's wrong with the interviewer wearing a suit?

There's nothing morally wrong with it, it's just not an environment where I'm likely to be comfortable.

Re: Ask HN: What are your personal red flags when you're interviewing at a company?

#45
post #23

All of these have happened to me: - The interviewer is wearing a suit. - The interviewer asks "you've worked with [person who now works at our company] before, what do you think about them?". Bonus points if they insist after I give a diplomatic answer. - "Why are you using microservices?" "Because everyone is doing it" - Not following up. For weeks. - "Can you send us your high school diploma?" - Take home assignmen…

What's wrong with the interviewer wearing a suit?

For what it's worth, I'm near 40 and have never once seen anybody at any work place wear a suit (who wasn't giving a speech at a town hall).

There is nothing wrong with wearing a suit, and it may be common in some workplaces/cultures, but in others it can be corollary to a work culture you are not compatible with.

Re: Ask HN: What are your personal red flags when you're interviewing at a company?

#46

Back when in-person interviews were a thing, I’d use the opportunity to just look at the office space. Specific red flag signals: 1. Dominated by Windows 2. Too many people in formals 3. Nobody wears badges (and other indicators of a lax security policy) 4. Old/worn out office furniture 5. Low resolution displays 6. Old laptops 7. No evidence of people collaborating or chatting at a microkitchen etc.

What's this "office space" you're talking about? :)

But seriously, we'd fail 1, 3 (we've never had anything like badges to wear), 4 (some of it is old, not too much us worn out though - chairs get replaced, desks are pushing 25 or more now), 5 (every one, including receptionist has multiple monitors but they're standard 300dpi), 6 (depends what you mean by old), probably 7 as well as most folk are remote now.

I guess we're not for you.

On the up side we dress very informally.

Re: Ask HN: What are your personal red flags when you're interviewing at a company?

#47

The ones that come to mind: * If they are a small company who outsources any step of their interview process to another company. If you're only interviewing for a couple positions—people you will work with every single day—take the time to do it yourself. * If they are a startup that says they are looking for people who are interested in solving exciting problems . For some people, this is going to be an enticement,…

1-2 hour long interview?

Re: Ask HN: What are your personal red flags when you're interviewing at a company?

#48
post #23

All of these have happened to me: - The interviewer is wearing a suit. - The interviewer asks "you've worked with [person who now works at our company] before, what do you think about them?". Bonus points if they insist after I give a diplomatic answer. - "Why are you using microservices?" "Because everyone is doing it" - Not following up. For weeks. - "Can you send us your high school diploma?" - Take home assignmen…

What's wrong with the interviewer wearing a suit?

My guess is it just doesn't fit their style. Some people want more formal clothes in the workplace and others would rather not have a dress code. Even then, just the interviewer wearing a suit doesn't necessarily mean it's a strict dress code culture, but probably a strong signal.

Re: Ask HN: What are your personal red flags when you're interviewing at a company?

#49
Frat bro vibes. Bragging about alcohol in the office, offering me liquor around 1pm, talking about how great every is to hang out with at the office late. I don’t have a problem with others enjoying things, but assuming they are a major selling point for people during the interview is a big red flag to me.

Re: Ask HN: What are your personal red flags when you're interviewing at a company?

#50

When I was 35, I had a mid-20's startup CEO ask me if I still had it in me... what?

Hehe "ask your mom" might have been a response I'd give. Maybe not an appropriate response, but at least it'd be entertaining.
Post reply on HN