Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: AI “white mirror” – what are some inspiring future visions you've seen?

news.ycombinator.com

41–50 of 81 posts

Re: Ask HN: AI “white mirror” – what are some inspiring future visions you've seen?

#41
post #36
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah op yikes to jumping to 'black = bad, white = good' metaphor space. What is wrong with you?

You're getting downvoted but I literally just got a memo at work last week reminding people to stop using the terms blacklist and whitelist and switch to block-list and allow-list.

[deleted]

Re: Ask HN: AI “white mirror” – what are some inspiring future visions you've seen?

#42
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Baby isn't being raised by a machine. How is this different from a crib mobile (for entertainment) + video monitor?

If it's the same as a crib mobile, then what benefit does it provide?

More effective

Re: Ask HN: AI “white mirror” – what are some inspiring future visions you've seen?

#44
post #4

AI babysitter for infants to supplement – not replace – parents. Captures audio / biometrics and responds to the baby with targeted music, positive affirmations, cooing, etc, to promote positive emotional state. Also notifies parents of states that require their intervention, like hunger, soiled diaper, abnormal vitals, inconsolability. Parents can take a break, watch a movie, entertain friends, etc, with the comfort…

That's 100% black mirror, not white mirror. Babies being raised by machines is dystopian as hell.

There's some point where the robot is realistic enough that it's functionally no different than a nanny. I agree it would be dystopian as hell if the kid was just raised by the robot, but giving the parents a bit more sleep and an opportunity to have a date night once a week would help them be way better parents.

As an extreme case, some parents get so stressed and chronically sleep deprived that they get frustrated at their babies for continually crying and shake them, leading to permanent brain damage and even death.[0] To be clear, these parents don't mean to hurt their child but they're not operating coherently anymore. A robot that can give parents a breather here and there would significantly improve quality of care for soooo many babies.

[0] https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/shaken-baby-s...

Re: Ask HN: AI “white mirror” – what are some inspiring future visions you've seen?

#45
post #43

This story features part of the world going Black Mirror at the same time as another part goes (arguably) White Mirror: Manna – Two Views of Humanity's Future by Marshall Brain https://marshallbrain.com/manna1

Sounds like The Time Machine (from your description, I didn't read the article)

Re: Ask HN: AI “white mirror” – what are some inspiring future visions you've seen?

#46

AI babysitter for infants to supplement – not replace – parents. Captures audio / biometrics and responds to the baby with targeted music, positive affirmations, cooing, etc, to promote positive emotional state. Also notifies parents of states that require their intervention, like hunger, soiled diaper, abnormal vitals, inconsolability. Parents can take a break, watch a movie, entertain friends, etc, with the comfort…

Batteries die and the parents are left without a clue how their child actually operates. They've been playing real life tamagotchi while their newborn evolves into an alien. Funny, babies are also way more noise than signal >.<

"You won't always have a calculator in your pocket"

Re: Ask HN: AI “white mirror” – what are some inspiring future visions you've seen?

#47
"All Watched Over by Machines of Loving Grace", by Richard Brautigan (1967)

I like to think (and

the sooner the better!)

of a cybernetic meadow

where mammals and computers

live together in mutually

programming harmony

like pure water

touching clear sky.

I like to think

     (right now please!)
of a cybernetic forest

filled with pines and electronics

where deer stroll peacefully

past computers

as if they were flowers

with spinning blossoms.

I like to think

     (it has to be!)
of a cybernetic ecology

where we are free of our labors

and joined back to nature,

returned to our mammal

brothers and sisters,

and all watched over

by machines of loving grace.

Re: Ask HN: AI “white mirror” – what are some inspiring future visions you've seen?

#48
post #7

I think AI-assisted healthcare is inevitable and will probably offer the biggest improvement in the general population's health for decades, it will focus on disease prevention and flagging up those early warning signs that most people don't usually notice

This would suggest some alternative "shortcuts" to good health for a broader population. Instead of the time-consuming approach which includes physical activity, fasting, good nutrition, etc and corresponding things for good mental health.

Re: Ask HN: AI “white mirror” – what are some inspiring future visions you've seen?

#49
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If it's the same as a crib mobile, then what benefit does it provide?

More effective

The effectiveness comes from exploiting the baby's primal recognition of the mother, which is why it's dystopian. Additionally, by "effective" you mean "the baby spends less time crying," which means that the parents are spending less time with their baby. So parental time is being replaced by an AI. I think it's fair to call that "being raised by AI."
Post reply on HN