Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What is example of good documentation in your opinion?

news.ycombinator.com

41–50 of 71 posts

Re: Ask HN: What is example of good documentation in your opinion?

#44
The manual for my dishwasher. What I learned from it was that technical writing is a skill and that it does not come from technical knowledge alone.

The best documentation knows its audience and what they want to know. I quite like cppreference and usually ISA documentation is quite good. But this is because I am part of their target audience.

The worst documentation is the one which has entirely lost sight of its audience. Particularly offenses are it being a mix of tutorial and reference, which is filled with explanatory prosa potentially even serving as a first introduction to the given topic.

Cppreference is about the worst way to learn C or C++ and if it weren't it would be far less useful to me. Documentation writers have to know their audience first and foremost. There is a place for walkthroughs and tutorials, but they can not replace an actual language reference.

Re: Ask HN: What is example of good documentation in your opinion?

#46
A counter example: any official Java docs are pretty sparse and unhelpful. Jenkins docs too.

The other commenter mentions docs from the past being better, but I have always found Java’s docs to be particularly atrocious.

No examples, and barely any information beyond a type signature.

When I open up a project’s docs and they have that same Java html formatting, I get that faraway stare…

Re: Ask HN: What is example of good documentation in your opinion?

#49
Two long-form examples for programs I don't see here yet. Note that they won't necessarily be great for other projects (e.g. for a library, where you as the user will probably need/expect "on-point documentation" for specific details while working with the product in question), but as a wholistic introduction to a specific tool, I've yet to see much better examples.

- https://dtrace.org/guide/preface.html

- https://archive.org/details/pdfy-MgN0H1joIoDVoIC7

Post reply on HN