Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Do you meditate? How/Why?

news.ycombinator.com

41–50 of 122 posts

Re: Ask HN: Do you meditate? How/Why?

#41
I do it whenever it feels like my brain needs a reboot, that is, when my mental processes seem to be frozen and don't flow properly. That's like a pair of times every day. Some days more, some other less.

Nothing fancy, I just sit there breathing and take everything else out of my mind.

Since I do it when I feel I need it doesn't feel like a waste of time or anything like that. I know I'll be more focused after meditating and will do a better job.

Re: Ask HN: Do you meditate? How/Why?

#42

Never meditated in the Buddhist sense. I'm not a particularly spiritual person, and the idea of doing some sort of 'meditating' doesn't appeal to me at all - it's not something that fits my concept of 'me'. That said, I do spend a little bit of time - every day if I can - thinking about the many good things in my life and how much worse things would be without them. By doing so I find that I appreciate my situation a…

With respect to your own self-examination, I don't find that one need be a spiritual person in order to meditate according to some Buddhist traditions. And interspersed in a lot of Buddhist teaching seems to be the caveat that the same approach may not work for different individuals.

Re: Ask HN: Do you meditate? How/Why?

#43
I do pretty traditional, mainstream Buddhist-style meditation on the breath every day. At the moment I'm sitting 30 minutes a day; there have been times when I've averaged an hour a day.

I find it has great benefits-- much more than any other activity I could do in the time I'm spending.

I'd definitely recommend that you (or anybody else interested) go to a center, and take a few sessions with an in-person teacher. Learning to meditate from a book (or website, etc.) is a bit like learning to swim from a book: it might be possible to do it that way, but it is far from optimal.

In my experience, Buddhist centers are happy to show people how to meditate with absolutely no expectations or conditions; there's nothing special you have to believe or commit to, or anything like that.

Re: Ask HN: Do you meditate? How/Why?

#44

I can relate a little about my experiences doing zen-style meditation over the last few years. After long periods of meditation, like a weekend retreat or even a day of sitting, I tend to be very focused and relaxed. My normally chaotic emotions are subdued and I have a profound feeling of well-being and peace. This generally lasts for several days to several weeks depending on the lengths of sitting. Sitting daily s…

A lot of anxiety that I had apparently suppressed over the years came to a head, which was anything but pleasant

I obviously don't know you or your situation, but is it possibly a good thing that these suppressed things are coming out now? In the long run, perhaps you can work through them and you'll be in a better place at the end?

Re: Ask HN: Do you meditate? How/Why?

#49
I've a little bit periodically over the past few years. The most I've ever done is 20m at a time, but every day.

I've had the same reservations as you, is it doing any good, how can I tell? It is trivially easy to be wrong.

I do like something I see in the people who are more advanced practioners and I keep being drawn back to it.

My latest thinking is that since I can not for the moment find anything longterm to measure, I'll do it for the immediate enjoyment I get directly from the session - from physically relaxing if nothing else. This has now made my sessions very short, just a few minutes at a time before I stop enjoying it.

I'll add another recomendation for "Mindfulness in Plain English", I like it a lot. I'm slowly consuming it, reading a few paragraphs before each meditation session.

Re: Ask HN: Do you meditate? How/Why?

#50
Simming through the comments, it seems that there is noone who actually had bad experiences with meditation or at least decided that it was waste of time/lacked any significant effects. I really would like to read that kind of opinions (to get fuller picture of this activity), however most topics (sites) about meditation are full of people who actually do and 'like' it or who want to start. Can somebody share that kind of stories (or point to them)?
Post reply on HN