Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How would you fix cities?

news.ycombinator.com

41–47 of 47 posts

Re: Ask HN: How would you fix cities?

#41
post #26
post #25

I came up with some ideas a year or two ago : http://tinyvillages.org

Fun! But what if I want to learn tuba or practice opera singing? (Not trolling you, I really mean this.)

There's plenty of sound dampening low tech solutions and social norms that work just fine. Hopefully there's a whole population of the orchestra to create specialized architecture.

Re: Ask HN: How would you fix cities?

#42
post #27
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Fun! But what if I want to learn tuba or practice opera singing? (Not trolling you, I really mean this.)

I think what you are implying is that since the buildings are close together there will be a noise pollution issue. Obviously little buildings are not going to be adequate for everything like an orchestra or opera performance. So that isn't meant to apply to every single building. But as far as practicing those things, generally there is sound proofing in those types of music practice rooms, and also I have suggested…

The homes look too small for practice rooms, and I practice a lot--this couldn't be in a shared community room. It would have to be at home (I think). Asking b/c it applies to other noisy activities such as running a saw for DIY projects or even just neighbors who scream at each other.

Re: Ask HN: How would you fix cities?

#43
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Fun! But what if I want to learn tuba or practice opera singing? (Not trolling you, I really mean this.)

There's plenty of sound dampening low tech solutions and social norms that work just fine. Hopefully there's a whole population of the orchestra to create specialized architecture.

> sound dampening low tech solutions and social norms that work just fine

Examples? I sing opera and live in a big house on an acre, and it still reaches the neighbors.

Re: Ask HN: How would you fix cities?

#44

That's not easy. Take public transit, for instance. Arguably, that would be a good thing to change - supply fast, frequent, convenient public transit. But how would you do it? US cities (with few exceptions) have reached a stable equilibrium where cars are necessary because there's no convenient transit, there's no transit because the city doesn't have the density to make it worthwhile, and it can't have the density…

If the citizens don't want it, then of course it's game over.

If the citizens do want it, you can just gradually make private car ownership more expensive and less convenient vs public transit.

Anecdotally many anti-public transit opinions from US folks seem to be around having the less well-to-do present in buses, complaints about hygiene and/or safety. So maybe improve the social safety net at the same time, or go full classist and have separate 1st class & 2nd class compartments.

Re: Ask HN: How would you fix cities?

#45
I think Jacque Fresco's idea with the Venus Project is worth pondering: https://www.thevenusproject.com/. I wish the philosophy makes it in new cities being built now. Whatever it may be, we need to live alongside nature and make sure the city produces waste that can be broken down by nature readily, and at the same time it must be a symbiotic relationship.

Re: Ask HN: How would you fix cities?

#46

I think Jacque Fresco's idea with the Venus Project is worth pondering: https://www.thevenusproject.com/ . I wish the philosophy makes it in new cities being built now. Whatever it may be, we need to live alongside nature and make sure the city produces waste that can be broken down by nature readily, and at the same time it must be a symbiotic relationship.

I didn't "get" the Venus project, but I am wary of "designed" cities, they aren't very liveable (see: Brazilia or Astana).

Re: Ask HN: How would you fix cities?

#47
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's plenty of sound dampening low tech solutions and social norms that work just fine. Hopefully there's a whole population of the orchestra to create specialized architecture.

> sound dampening low tech solutions and social norms that work just fine Examples? I sing opera and live in a big house on an acre, and it still reaches the neighbors.

Oh, you know, like just being a good neighbor. Not after 9 on weekdays and not too early on the weekends. Golden rule, you know that stuff.
Post reply on HN