Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Did anyone use ruinmysearchhistory and get Google account suspended today?

news.ycombinator.com

41–50 of 124 posts

Re: Ask HN: Did anyone use ruinmysearchhistory and get Google account suspended today?

#41

I'm curious: does anyone know whether Google searches are truly monitored, and how, if it's HTTPS? I showed ruinmysearchhistory.com to a Pakistani Muslim friend, not having clicked it myself, and he thought it was funny until the ISIS application parts started coming up, when he consequently freaked out, as you might imagine. But this got me wondering -- it seems to be widely accepted that googling things like "how t…

In the US, the query "where to buy guns" seems perfectly legitimate.

Re: Ask HN: Did anyone use ruinmysearchhistory and get Google account suspended today?

#42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I often wonder if I'm going to get arrested searching for the best way to kill a hung child process.

Or searching "man cp" instead of typing it in the terminal...

Sets up a pitchfork

Re: Ask HN: Did anyone use ruinmysearchhistory and get Google account suspended today?

#43

I'm curious: does anyone know whether Google searches are truly monitored, and how, if it's HTTPS? I showed ruinmysearchhistory.com to a Pakistani Muslim friend, not having clicked it myself, and he thought it was funny until the ISIS application parts started coming up, when he consequently freaked out, as you might imagine. But this got me wondering -- it seems to be widely accepted that googling things like "how t…

> It's never been clear to me whether this is superstition or if there's truth to it. Google is fully HTTPS-- how could your searches be monitored unless google was handing them over to the government? They could be monitored if the government had surreptitiously gained access to Google servers or internal data transfers by compromising infrastructure such as Google's datacenter-to-datacenter links. I use that exampl…

The name of that program was MUSCULAR:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MUSCULAR_%28surveillance_progr...

That was the famous slide that showed where Google took off SSL with a little smiley face--which reportedly caused Google engineers to "explode with profanity."

The NSA actually did not do the actual hacking. The British GCHQ did, with technical assistance from the NSA. Thus the NSA could pretend that since the GCHQ collected all the information, it was foreign-sourced and therefore not subject to FISA court jurisdiction.

Re: Ask HN: Did anyone use ruinmysearchhistory and get Google account suspended today?

#44
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is a small difference between ruining ones search history and being brought to the attention of whatever authority is watching[1]. It does seem like a https://xkcd.com/576/ situation applied to search. 1) I would bet our web filter would be sending me some reports

what part of "ruin" don't you understand ?

Ruining your search history not your livelihood.

Re: Ask HN: Did anyone use ruinmysearchhistory and get Google account suspended today?

#45

I'm curious: does anyone know whether Google searches are truly monitored, and how, if it's HTTPS? I showed ruinmysearchhistory.com to a Pakistani Muslim friend, not having clicked it myself, and he thought it was funny until the ISIS application parts started coming up, when he consequently freaked out, as you might imagine. But this got me wondering -- it seems to be widely accepted that googling things like "how t…

I often wonder if I'm going to get arrested searching for the best way to kill a hung child process.

Or outed as gay for Googling linux manual pages.

"Honey, why do searches for 'man date' and 'man find' appear in your your internet history?" - My future wife.

Re: Ask HN: Did anyone use ruinmysearchhistory and get Google account suspended today?

#46

As I am currently in a North African country I freaked out when the ISIS shit started popping so I immediately deleted my google history and nothing happened now. I still don't get why something so malicious was upvoted so much.

The name of the site is pretty clear.

I didn't click on it since I don't want a site to do anything whatsoever to me ever.

But it wasn't evident at all to me that it was a site that would do what it apparently did.

It seems like having a link like that on a major, moderated website like hn is a serious problem and failing.

Re: Ask HN: Did anyone use ruinmysearchhistory and get Google account suspended today?

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is, but seeing it on HN made me think it was "ruin" along the lines of "throw off Google interest-based ads" not "get you on a list".

I didn't follow the original link, but maybe the point was to get lots of people on a list to show how silly lists are?

Maybe, but it depends on whether the location of the query is taken into account. In that case, the majority of the people who clicked through (which is based in the USA/Europe) won't get picked up as opposed to the small percentage of people located in the MENA area.

Re: Ask HN: Did anyone use ruinmysearchhistory and get Google account suspended today?

#48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Most Third World governments control ISPs and DNS queries can be easily monitored but whether those are implicative or not depends on where the content embedded in the search results is hosted/served from. Also, even if Google is fully HTTPS, if a query returns images hosted on unsecured websites, those urls will be plainly visible and hence implicative. Edit: The embedded thumbnails are actually encrypted as pointed…

I was curious and just checked -- until you click on an image in google's search results to see it fullsize in the semi-lightbox, you're actually getting the "thumbnail" sent from google as a b64 encoded string

Well, that's good news. thank you for checking, I stand corrected.

Re: Ask HN: Did anyone use ruinmysearchhistory and get Google account suspended today?

#49
Recently (maybe the past ~6mo or so) I've noticed that when I start pasting logs/errors/tcpdump into Google, it is now especially suspicious that I'm making automated queries and makes my IP solve a captcha.

I doubt my lack of a Google login and random UA spoofing does anything to help this, though.

Re: Ask HN: Did anyone use ruinmysearchhistory and get Google account suspended today?

#50

I ran it using private Safari mode (akin to Incognito in Chrome). There were naturally no consequences to my Google Account, nor my IP Address.

> I ran it using private Safari mode ... There were naturally no consequences to my ... IP Address.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=46Kv4rBJi68

Post reply on HN