Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What are you doing to improve your health?

news.ycombinator.com

311–320 of 370 posts

Re: Ask HN: What are you doing to improve your health?

#311

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Let's go point by point: > strength training 3x a week will with no other exercise will leave the average person with extremely poor cardiovascular fitness. This is actually not true. I wont argue it's going to give you the same level of cardiovascular conditioning as running daily, but it absolutely gives you a baseline of cardiovascular conditioning. Since we are talking about basic fitness, I would still hold to m…

starting strength involves perhaps 30 minutes of active exercise in a week with most time in the gym sent recovering between sets. that is simply not enough to develop any sort of cardiovascular fitness unless you have an abnormally strong response to training. your links in support of the injury prevention and mass building benefits refer to startingstrength.com and Practical Programming. That book is health cult li…

I'm doing something similar to Starting Strength and I really enjoy it, but it's not the be-all end-all. If bodyweight exercises are your thing, more power to you.

I have to disagree with you on the machines though. From what I've read, they tend to train large muscle groups but fail to build up stabilizer muscles, which can cause some nasty problems if you keep at it for a long time. A good friend of mine worked out exclusively on machines for a while and wound up having to work (as a developer) in wrist braces because the muscles in his arms were all out of whack. He thought he'd gotten carpal tunnel syndrome or something similar, but his physiotherapist did a quick exam and asked him if he worked out on machines X or Y. He answered in the affirmative, and she told him to stop immediately and start stretching and do some bodyweight stuff.

Bodyweight or barbell exercises won't lead you down that path, but machines can and do cause problems. Be careful!

Re: Ask HN: What are you doing to improve your health?

#312
post #309

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I can second this from personal experience. People that spend an hour in the gym pumping away at 50% capacity with bicep curls are never going to see the kinds of gains they imagine. You will get the gains you want by pushing yourself to muscle failure within a couple of sets every single time you hit the gym. Short, powerful workouts is how you encourage testosterone production, which is exactly how you get strength…

Hmm, didn't he just said opposite?

Yes, the person you responded to has it completely backwards. Strength training is important, but volume training is what will give you big muscles. Look for any body building routine(which is solely focused on aesthetics, and not at all focused on strength), and you will see that it has a very large volume. I lifted for strength only for 5 years and saw very little progress in aesthetics. I've seen more progress in 6 months of GVT(a volume focused training program) than I did in 5 years of heavy weight training.

Here is Kai Greenes(runner up Mr. Universe) take on the matter: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m8wZNGL4iA4 . You probably don't want to look like him, but you have to admit he knows what he's talking about.

Just google "volume vs intensity training" for a million hits on the subject.

Re: Ask HN: What are you doing to improve your health?

#313

1. Sleep a minimum of 7-8 hours a night, and go to bed at the same time and get up at the same time. 2. Screens off after 8:30pm. 3. Stop work at 6pm and spend time with family or doing things I find fun, stimulating. After about 40 hours of work the brain isn't any more effective. This forces me to ignore social media and get stuff done during the day. 4. Exercise: run 3x per week and one additional strength trainin…

> 8:30pm How long is this before you go to sleep?

typically lights out 10-10:30 as I get up at 6:30 each day.

edit to add: during this time I:

1. walk the dog 2. read (book or kindle paperwhite which doesn't impact sleep) 3. tidy up 4. lay out clothes for the next day, pack lunches or bag as needed. 5. sit and chat with my partner (shocking!)

Re: Ask HN: What are you doing to improve your health?

#314

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can you provide some details about your setup? Also, do you work remotely or onsite?

I have a lifespan fitness TR1200DT machine. Got it off Amazon. I had it in my office for the first couple months, but then moved it home.

The idea of treadmill desks has been starting to float around my office and I've been pushing for it.

Do you find that it generates much noise? Do you work with others in a typical open-office pit o' desks or in a private office?

Re: Ask HN: What are you doing to improve your health?

#315
post #178

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It really helps to do it in small steps. It is really hard to try to do everything at once. My first step was to be more active. I take breaks at work and I spend my entire 1 hour lunch walking around outside. Lately, I've been doing speed-walking and a bit of running too now that weather is getting nicer. Once I got into that habit of moving more, I started looking at my diet and changed a few things around. Started…

Well, there were times in my life where I was going to the gym 3x a day, biking and playing tennis and soccer on the weekends. Now, life has gotten in the way a bit, but I try to make sure I'm still moving during the day, eating well, and getting enough sleep.

Oh, I only go to gym about 3 or 4 times a week. Things somewhat change when kids come into play :)

Re: Ask HN: What are you doing to improve your health?

#316
post #270

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Starting strength and similar routines are great but be very careful of starting light and maintaining proper technique as getting injured can really impact your health and happiness in a lot of ways especially as we get older. It is very easy to get injured doing squats or power cleans with any kind of sizable weight. For example the injury rates in CrossFit are estimated to be between 20-75% [1,2] of participants w…

While I agree with your point (start low, build up slowly) I wish you hadn't used Crossfit as a textbook example of weight training. Weight training has one of the lowest injury rates in sports. Reference: http://www.exrx.net/WeightTraining/Safety.html

I'm sorry if my comment came across as saying that CrossFit is exemplary of all weight training.

My intention is to just highlight the importance of taking your time. Weight training can have very low injury rates, but the rates go up when looking at power lifting[1]. Under "soreness and injury section" in Starting Strength Mark Rippetoe himself says "...everyone who trains with weights will have: soreness and injuries."

Both Starting Strength and Crossfit utilize large compound exercises like squats and power cleans that can be difficult to master and my assumption is that more people have heard of Crossfit so I thought it would be useful for comparison. Personally I am a big fan of the squat and other compound exercises for results but it is important to learn them well before advancing to higher weights, hence Starting Strength is 300+ pages for a 5 exercise routine.

[1] Table 2 - http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3483033/

Re: Ask HN: What are you doing to improve your health?

#317
post #241

I've been vegan for 4 months. I feel stronger, fitter, and my joints feel looser. I turn 40 soon.

I've been vegan for over 8 years (eating mostly whole foods), and I can say that the positive effects are long-lasting. I'm approaching 40 too and I don't really feel like I'm getting old like most of my peers do.

Re: Ask HN: What are you doing to improve your health?

#318

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree with you completely, just adding my two cents: I've done strength training for 5 years and am just now getting into volume training(strength is basically moving high weights for low number of reptitions, volume is moving medium weights for a high number of repititions). If I could go back, I would do a mixed routine from the beginning. Strength gains are nice, but the aesthetic gains from a volume routine are…

Sure, this thread is about health, which true volume training is not necessary for.

The most important part of an exercise routine is sticking with it. Doing a volume program is way, way healthier than doing nothing at all. I find that the aesthetic gains make me more motivated to go to the gym than when I was just increasing the total poundage of weight I could move in one rep.

Re: Ask HN: What are you doing to improve your health?

#319
I am 53 year old male. I have been working out variety of approaches but very consistently for the past 14 years.

My current routine has me lifting free weights 3 days a week (M,W,F). Squat, Deadlift, Bench Press, Military (overhead) Press, Pull-ups, Decline sit-ups, bicep curls, leg curls on a machine to hit hamstrings better. Although I strive for a full body resistance workout 3 times a week - I will sometimes go light on all the exercises except one of them and really push that focus exercise.

Jog or run intervals on treadmill set at an incline twice a week.(T,TH). I generally go about 3 miles.

Rest on the weekend.

I do a form of intermittent fasting (16/8 or sometimes 18/6. Quit eating about 8 PM - don't eat again until noon the next day or sometimes as late as 2.

Timing: I do my workouts at the end of my fast at mid-day before eating.

Diet: My meal right after working out is a giant multi-ingredient salad with a bit of protein. After that I pretty much eat what I want but make sure to get solid protein with evening meal and generally another fruit or vegetable. I do eat dessert two or three times a week. I rarely snack between meals. I drink soda maybe once a week and then only 12 oz. or less. I basically don't drink alcohol except for an occasional toast or one beer at a party. I drink lots of black coffee (no sugar or cream) I used to call this my vice and then the Harvard epidemiologists decided that black coffee and tea are both essentially health drinks - lucky me.

I feel stronger and better than ever as an adult - though I cannot run as fast as I did in my twenties. But admittedly my exercise program emphasizes strength much more than speed.

Mental well being: keep learning - that is almost a given for developers but I sometimes need to do something really different.

Relational well being: I take pretty good care of my wife of 31 years and she takes care of me. Lucky to have 4 great kids that enrich my life as well.

Spiritual well being: I actively participate in a local church which challenges me to think deeply about spirit and life. It also helps me get involved in helping others, giving to the poor and such. It also provides access to a rich circle of friends who share one or two things in common with me but are otherwise quite different.

These are the things that seem to really work for me. Hope it is helpful.

Re: Ask HN: What are you doing to improve your health?

#320

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sure, this thread is about health, which true volume training is not necessary for.

The most important part of an exercise routine is sticking with it. Doing a volume program is way, way healthier than doing nothing at all. I find that the aesthetic gains make me more motivated to go to the gym than when I was just increasing the total poundage of weight I could move in one rep.

Totally fair, I'm more interested (and thought this thread was about) figuring out the optimal ways to do things, compliance being ignored. Considering compliance changes a lot of things.
Post reply on HN