Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How many of you contribute to Wikipedia?

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 52 posts

Re: Ask HN: How many of you contribute to Wikipedia?

#31

Well, let's see... I submitted an article about one of the most important writers of my country, and it was deleted because it is apparently irrelevant. Years later someone submitted a stub, and it remains like that until today. I fixed a dead link on the Kalman Filters page, and the change was promptly reverted because apparently linking to youtube is not allowed. So now only I have the correct link. Oh, well. I con…

I've fixed typos and then they got reverted back.

Re: Ask HN: How many of you contribute to Wikipedia?

#32
I've been an active editor since 2011, primarily on the topics of computational biology and African American history.[1] I started by inserting citations, then by incorporating a couple of term papers I had collecting dust, before finally graduating to major rewrites of (relatively) popular articles.

Thankfully, in computational biology articles PR flacks and wiki-lawyers are at a minimum. The extent of my experience with the former extends to over-enthusiastic academics promoting their particular software. I recommend it to students, not only as a way to get some use out of old term papers, but also as a way to sharpen one's writing skills. Because it's an important vehicle for outreach there's the potential for recognition as well.[2]

I'd have to say that one of the highlights of my editing career has been receiving an email from the descendant of an article's subject thanking me for telling their story.

[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Estevezj

[2]: http://www.ploscompbiol.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fj...

Re: Ask HN: How many of you contribute to Wikipedia?

#33
post #12
post #7

I contribute to Wikipedia. User page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Dllu I've started a few articles on niche topics and created many pictures/animations.

Those are some really nice animations and diagrams! What do you use to make the 2d vector graphics? Inkscape?

Some of them are generated using my own C++ programs. For example, the series on Monte Carlo localization (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:Robot_localizati...) is simply too tedious to be created by hand. The C++ program source code generating the nine pictures can be found at https://gist.github.com/dllu/7076603

As for the diagram of the teletherapy capsule (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Teletherapy_Capsule_3.svg), I wrote out the SVG file by hand in a text editor. Extreme boredom sometimes makes one do that kind of thing.

Re: Ask HN: How many of you contribute to Wikipedia?

#34
post #31

Well, let's see... I submitted an article about one of the most important writers of my country, and it was deleted because it is apparently irrelevant. Years later someone submitted a stub, and it remains like that until today. I fixed a dead link on the Kalman Filters page, and the change was promptly reverted because apparently linking to youtube is not allowed. So now only I have the correct link. Oh, well. I con…

I've fixed typos and then they got reverted back.

Thats the sort of thing that would definately make me loose hope.

Re: Ask HN: How many of you contribute to Wikipedia?

#35

Well, let's see... I submitted an article about one of the most important writers of my country, and it was deleted because it is apparently irrelevant. Years later someone submitted a stub, and it remains like that until today. I fixed a dead link on the Kalman Filters page, and the change was promptly reverted because apparently linking to youtube is not allowed. So now only I have the correct link. Oh, well. I con…

Looks like your Kalman Filter change got put back: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Kalman_filter&act...

Re: Ask HN: How many of you contribute to Wikipedia?

#36
post #31

Well, let's see... I submitted an article about one of the most important writers of my country, and it was deleted because it is apparently irrelevant. Years later someone submitted a stub, and it remains like that until today. I fixed a dead link on the Kalman Filters page, and the change was promptly reverted because apparently linking to youtube is not allowed. So now only I have the correct link. Oh, well. I con…

I've fixed typos and then they got reverted back.

Maybe it was a US vs British spelling thing?

Re: Ask HN: How many of you contribute to Wikipedia?

#37
I've written a few articles for Wikipedia, and also fix vandalism occasionally. The only problem i have is when i try to create an article for a product or company. People always think that they are biased, which isn't a bad thing since the Wiki-PR came about. But it gets very irritating when the article is not biased, but still gets marked as such.

Re: Ask HN: How many of you contribute to Wikipedia?

#38
I anonymously contributed mostly to automotive pages, and mostly for the Polish versions. I found everything in English got reverted, in Polish the vast part holded up (even a link to my own on-topic website). Probably regional versions aren't that nazi as the main one, although I've seen crazy discussions on every subject even mildly touching politics, for obvious reasons (some zealots are just ridiculous).

Re: Ask HN: How many of you contribute to Wikipedia?

#39
post #8

I've tried on a three occasions to contribute to wikipedia - Two occasions where I've found articles with incorrect data based off of poor sources, and once to correct a minor grammatical issue, with all of the articles in question being small and non-political in nature. Every time I was promptly reverted. In the former's case I always provided sources for my updated info, which were completely ignored the first occ…

I'm curious to see the change you made, since I've done the same thing hundreds of times (adding or changing an article and giving a reference) and I haven't noticed random reversion.
Post reply on HN