Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Is anyone experiencing "AI brain rot?"

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 43 posts

Re: Ask HN: Is anyone experiencing "AI brain rot?"

#31

I have been "encouraged" by my company to go full throttle into integration LLMs into our workflow. I have found is has taken much of the enjoyment out of solving problems with code. As others have said, it has made me lazier and I can see myself losing my edge.

Yeah it is the strangler fig pattern but the thing getting strangled is human coders.

Re: Ask HN: Is anyone experiencing "AI brain rot?"

#32
AI is the best thing ever to happen to finally be able to objectively judge who is willing to do the hard work and face adversity vs looking for an easy ways out and quick fixes.

Of course, long term misuse by outsourcing your cognitive exercise to a machine has a negative impact.

Just auto complete your way to being completely dumb.

As a learning or exploratory tool it is best thing ever. Just don't use it to tab-tab your way out of actual work.

Re: Ask HN: Is anyone experiencing "AI brain rot?"

#33
post #2

Perhaps not surprising given what we know about how e.g. satnav usage affects our navigational competence. Feels like outsourcing our reasoning and problem solving would have an analagous effect. "Habitual use of GPS negatively impacts spatial memory during self-guided navigation": https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-62877-0

I am much better at navigating my home town than San Francisco precisely because I moved to SF by the time of Google Maps.

I caught myself at some point feeling like that was happening when going over my own codebase. I stopped being aggressive on AI usage for important stuff, and relegated for side stuff that I just want to get started.

Re: Ask HN: Is anyone experiencing "AI brain rot?"

#34
It depends, I run gpt-4o - powered instagram comment automation. We analyze reels with AI (text + image recognition), decide where to comment, and optimize replies based on top-performing engagement patterns. AI basically allowed me to remove hundreds of people from my agency.

Re: Ask HN: Is anyone experiencing "AI brain rot?"

#35
post #11
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've never heard of spelling regressing. I think my spelling ability is mostly correlated to how much I have read. I know how to spell many words I've never used myself.

One thing I notice is that I can't spell out loud anymore. I have to type or write to get the right spelling.

I would wager that autocorrect/predictive text on your phone is to blame for that. It is such an overlooked convenience to a problem we solved decades ago that it is on virtually any smartphone.

Typing in a hurry or you forgot to add one more s in the word 'necessary'? No worries! Keep typing incorrectly and the phone will take care of the proper spelling of the word for you! And it will do so faster than you figuring out the right spelling for the misspelled word. Many of us have probably regressed in our spelling ability to some degree at this point.

Re: Ask HN: Is anyone experiencing "AI brain rot?"

#36
You are right, though I think some of it is our addiction to phones and such. BUT as a very mediocre coder llms have really accelerated my ability to code. I think I am the sweet spot for them. Much more experienced than a beginner because I know when to use classes, certain data types etc and can get the LLM to do what I ask and make changes when it’s crap. But not nearly good enough to construct algorithms in my head, which is probably a big advantage to an experienced coder and LLMs help to catch the rest of us up (though definitely do not replace.)

Re: Ask HN: Is anyone experiencing "AI brain rot?"

#37
I feel like it's the opposite for me. It rewards my curiosity. I can ask it questions that Google is no longer capable of answering, either because it reinterprets my query wrong or because it only returns generic content from top sites. I use it a lot in art museums to understand the story behind certain paintings or the difference between certain art movements.

I use AI for coding, but basically as a shortcut to API documentation. It lets me stay focused on my task. It removes a lot of the tedium of coding, so that I can focus on the actual problems.

Re: Ask HN: Is anyone experiencing "AI brain rot?"

#38
Depends on what you consider a "difficult challenge". If the challenge is to remember certain algorithm, it's not worth it - coming up with djikstra without hint was fun the first time, but needing to remember the detail for the nth time isn't.

And for good measure, those stop having value in the future - as they can be referenced from AI as easily as looking up how to convert a date format or center a div.

Re: Ask HN: Is anyone experiencing "AI brain rot?"

#39
Yes and no.

It's helped me stretch & explore new things that are a touch beyond my technical competence.

...but has also made me more lazy in some ways. e.g. I paste errors I don't immediately recognise into an LLM. Pre LLM I would have looked at the error in more detail first, then tried a couple of things blindly, then googled it.

Re: Ask HN: Is anyone experiencing "AI brain rot?"

#40
post #4

Not just satnav, but as a kid I could remember at least 20 phone number of close friends and family. My spelling used to be quite good, but now I struggle with words my 9 year old can spell. I think this is the way with any new technology, we just move to the next level of abstraction and hopefully get to build bigger/better things...maybe.

Isn’t this just what previous generations called getting old lol?
Post reply on HN