Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How do you structure your shared finances with your spouse/partner

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 146 posts

Re: Ask HN: How do you structure your shared finances with your spouse/partner

#32
We put money into a shared account for joint expenses, and she and I keep separate finances for ourselves, like whatever else is left over. I also try to put extra into the joint so we can have a joint savings, for emergencies and what not. My wife has her own personal savings as well, that she's always had.

I recommend just opening a shared account and putting a bit above the bare minimum into it. Keep some "you" cash so you can always buy yourself stuff, and you know, if you're ever buying surprise presents, she doesn't need to know. ;) Other people just join it all, and call it a day.

I only join whatever is a dual-expense, otherwise, its either on her, or on me solely.

Re: Ask HN: How do you structure your shared finances with your spouse/partner

#33
We have a hybrid solution: A joint checking & savings pair (+ credit card) into which paychecks are deposited and against which living expenses (mortgage, food, etc), are drawn; and personal checking & savings accts with monthly transfers from the joint accts. The personal accounts are our 'fun money', and don't get much - they mostly exist to offload the actual bookkeeping of the discretionary spending to the bank, since they cost us nothing to administer except an extra card in the wallet.

We set it up this way because I take home more than her, and I was tired of arguing with my wife that she should feel free to spend some of 'my' money, or that 'me' buying her something with 'my money' was not a gift per se, but an acknowledgement of the futility of her trying to maintain 'her half' of our lifestyle on her paycheck alone while also kicking in to the house. Abstracting all that into a shared fund we both draw on brought psychic peace. Money's fungible and all, but at the end of the day it does feel a lot better when it's not "I pay the mortgage, you buy the food, my savings grow, yours don't". Now the money doesn't feel like manna.

If your incomes are homogenous this is probably too much effort, but to be clear that effort was mostly just 3x as long at the bank once, to get the accounts set up.

I should add I only won that argument when we had a baby and our 'shared' expenses skyrocketed. Before that she was fully committed to separate finances and a constant, low-grade sense of shame & indigence.

Re: Ask HN: How do you structure your shared finances with your spouse/partner

#34
It will entirely on you two. In my first marriage, we were both high-earners, everything was joint. We were high enough earners and neither spendthrift, so there weren't any needed discussions on spending/budgeting, and having "private" pockets was just an artifact of us having different banks when we met. Direct deposit to a joint account, retirement maxed out, invested at my direction (because I was more interested). Worked great, but mostly because we had too much to ever need to fight over it.

Second marriage, complete opposite situation, I'm the high-earner, she's a housewife (working on building her business, but let's just say the income disparity is real). Finances are more complicated now since I'm a business owner and the bulk of our pre-marital assets are in my (or my companies) name, but at the end of the day, the card I use to buy things comes out of the same account as her caried rds. I do have more control over the flow from my firm to our joint bank account, but from a "who's money is it" PoV - it's our money, it was all earned since we were together (even though we hadn't married yet); The joint account has enough to cover our next years expenses if something were to happen to me and she needed access to funds before whatever estate settlement happened.

There's no one-size-fits-all approach I can tell you to use. What I can recommend though is that you jointly track all your accounts in some tracking app, and sit down once a quarter to discuss whether you are both on target w/r/t savings, retirement, whatever it is you're earning for. As long as you both are on the same page, then you're fighting together, not with each other. Money becomes tense when people feel entitled to it, or don't understand your situation -- having both of your situations on the same page can help make sure your new toy or their new habit doesn't become grounds for divorce.

Re: Ask HN: How do you structure your shared finances with your spouse/partner

#36
All money in joint accounts.

We are always each other's beneficiary.

I make enough that we don't have to think about small-medium purchases too much.

We are frugal in the big areas (e.g. 16yo Honda Civic).

But we do periodic spending temperature checks and as we have gotten older, we have become more mindful of that. Leisure spending over like a hundred or so we always tell each other about it beforehand and try to sleep on it.

I have a spreadsheet where I track weekly account balances + all activity on the main checking account (we rarely pay directly from it, so it's mostly bulk payments for credit cards or bills. Useful for predicting future balances so we can know how much to safely transfer to savings/investments.) On the activity sheet, I annotate each credit card statement with anything "exceptional" or above $250 or so.

Re: Ask HN: How do you structure your shared finances with your spouse/partner

#37
My wife and I direct deposit the first 90% of our paychecks to a shared savings account. Our family's living expenses are transferred from there to a shared checking account on the first of each month.

The other 10% goes into our personal checking accounts to spend on whatever we want.

Re: Ask HN: How do you structure your shared finances with your spouse/partner

#38
We're in a pretty different circumstance so this probably won't be useful, but in our case, my wife has a bank account and I don't. Our belief as fundamentalist Christians is that I as the man have final authority in the family, including over financial matters. I'm also the sole earner, but that wasn't always the case.

We have very little money but it's my sacred duty to always think of how I can care for the family as best as possible, and we've been very comfortable (even when we had basically no money). I've found that when I surrender to God's power, things always turn out for the best. Even in times where it seemed to be a terrible idea, he always had something planned.

Whereas when I stubbornly insist on myself, everything se fracasa bien feo. So I guess my financial strategy is to dissipate my ego and melt into Christ's mind. God is so cool.

Good luck OP, I hope your country's election goes well for you guys!

Re: Ask HN: How do you structure your shared finances with your spouse/partner

#39
1 separate current account each, which our individual paychecks go into, and 1 shared joint account, which all household expenses, bills, mortgage etc. comes out of.

We both put the same percentage of our individual monthly income into the joint account each month to cover the bills. As we're not paid the same though, this means one of us covers more of the bills than the other.

We have a fixed direct debit set up to transfer this into the joint account at the end of each month.

For non-regular big purchases, holidays etc. we usually split costs the same way, based on the ratio of our incomes. Simple but fair!

Re: Ask HN: How do you structure your shared finances with your spouse/partner

#40
Joint accounts for everything, both names on cars and house.

We figure if divorce was a concern, we should make it awkward to separate assets we've made over past 20 years together.

It helps that neither of us are bad with money or debt, but we probably wouldn't have married someone like that to begin with.

Post reply on HN