Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Legality of a Jan 18 SOPA blackout on Google?

news.ycombinator.com

31–32 of 32 posts

Re: Ask HN: Legality of a Jan 18 SOPA blackout on Google?

#31
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Adjective: Less advanced, esp. mentally, than is usual for one's age. Synonyms: backward - delayed Seems fine to me, especially considering it's no longer socially acceptable to use the word to describe the mentally disabled. Using gay however, is a completely different scenario. Retarded reflects on mental performance, while gay reflects on sexuality. English already has so few words - we might as well use the ones…

> Adjective: Less advanced, esp. mentally, than is usual for one's age. Synonyms: backward - delayed The OP doesn't use it to mean "backwards" , "delayed" or "less advanced". He means "stupid" and should just say so. > it's no longer socially acceptable to use the word to describe the mentally disabled Looking on Wordnik [1], four dictionaries out of five list "retard" as having to do with mental retardation (Wordnet…

> When communicating, there isn't any reason to use a potentially offensive word

Unless you want to offend. You might want to offend to signal the intensity of your rage. Minor range can warrant words like idiotic or stupid, major range calls for words like "fucking retarded git"

> The OP uses the word "retarded" by saying "let's not be retarded". My state of retardation doesn't change from second to second; it's fixed at birth. Insulting what one can't change is the most powerful type of insult. If you call me "stupid", I can always work to be less ignorant. If you call me a "chink" because I'm Chinese, I can't change that, and I feel more insulted.

Unless you really are retarded, he clearly meant that you shouldn't behave like somebody who is mentally disabled, so I don't see the similarity to the word "chink".

Re: Ask HN: Legality of a Jan 18 SOPA blackout on Google?

#32
post #16
post #5

They are obviously not going to willingly violate any SLAs. Also the gov't is never going to shut down Google. Their site being offline would not be an accurate preview of any blackouts to come. SOPA is going to cost google money and headaches because they will have to deal with so many upset users. It is our websites that don't have billions of dollars that are actually under threat of being completely shutdown.

> Also the gov't is never going to shut down Google. Also the CHINESE gov't is never going to shut down Google. Just adding a little perspective...

comparing the American gov't to the chinese gov't is jsut ridiculous in this context. american gov't cares too much about it's economy to do such a stupid thing
Post reply on HN