Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Which is the best book on nutrition?

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 41 posts

Re: Ask HN: Which is the best book on nutrition?

#31
Not a book, but a video course, "Nutrition Made Clear" at TheGreatCourses.com. Unlike a lot of the other books I see recommended here, this is not a dieting advice book, it's a course on nutrition. The professor specializes in sports nutrition, so a lot of the anecdotes are along those lines. It's 36 lectures, about 30 min each, plus the guide book.

https://www.thegreatcourses.com/courses/nutrition-made-clear...

Re: Ask HN: Which is the best book on nutrition?

#32
post #5

I’ve read most of them. There be dragons. There’s an entire landscape of conflicting information backed by conflicting scientific studies. You’ll go mad trying to find an objective answer. But I’d recommend Food Rules by Michael Pollan. Honestly, you can get the summary in the first paragraph below: “Eat [real, unprocessed] food. Not too much. Mostly plants.” https://michaelpollan.com/reviews/how-to-eat/ I’d also rec…

That's the problem. You read something and then a year later someone says the opposite and backed up by some university paper.

Re: Ask HN: Which is the best book on nutrition?

#33

The perfect ten diet - by Dr Michael Aziz I lost about seventeen kilos in ten months following the advice in this book The Leangains method - by Martin Berkhan Science and development of muscle hypertrophy - Brad Schoenfeld

I'm going to second the leangains method just for introducing me to the thermogenic effect of food.

What I got out of that book was to increase the thermogenic effect of food as much as you can, while doing intermittent fasting to control your behavior.

Would love to hear your thoughts.

Re: Ask HN: Which is the best book on nutrition?

#34
post #8

I'd start with a movie, not a book. The movie is "Game Changers", directed by James Cameron, and released last month on Netflix and Amazon Video. If you're skeptical about the science behind the movie, read the critique published in Men's Health magazine along with the rebuttal from one of the MD's interviewed in the film. Next I'd read "The Engine 2 seven-day rescue diet" by Rip Esselstyn. If you a more in-depth tre…

[deleted]

Re: Ask HN: Which is the best book on nutrition?

#37
post #8

I'd start with a movie, not a book. The movie is "Game Changers", directed by James Cameron, and released last month on Netflix and Amazon Video. If you're skeptical about the science behind the movie, read the critique published in Men's Health magazine along with the rebuttal from one of the MD's interviewed in the film. Next I'd read "The Engine 2 seven-day rescue diet" by Rip Esselstyn. If you a more in-depth tre…

Skeptical about the science? You mean the lack thereof?

They do a once off 'experiment' with a sample size of 3 and claim that it's conclusive evidence that eating meat "is bad". Yikes.

Re: Ask HN: Which is the best book on nutrition?

#38

The perfect ten diet - by Dr Michael Aziz I lost about seventeen kilos in ten months following the advice in this book The Leangains method - by Martin Berkhan Science and development of muscle hypertrophy - Brad Schoenfeld

I'm going to second the leangains method just for introducing me to the thermogenic effect of food. What I got out of that book was to increase the thermogenic effect of food as much as you can, while doing intermittent fasting to control your behavior. Would love to hear your thoughts.

I finished re-reading the lean gains method book last week. Like you, I too had the take away of DIT ( Diet Induced Thermogenesis) and of intermittent fasting. I’ve been following these by happy coincidence anyway. In my specific case, though, poor sleep schedules and excessive stress add quickly to my body fat percentage.

Re: Ask HN: Which is the best book on nutrition?

#39

You can see an actual nutritionist/doctor and get blood tests. It's probably impossible to determine what is good nutrition from any book besides 'dont eat processed food' because of individual needs/genes.

I've seen a few. It's sort of like hiring programmers when you are not one. I feel like 80% of nutritionists that are 'on the market' are not competent, but I'm not qualified to judge. It's just that they say things that contradict each other, and instead of falling back to some study, they get defensive.

Re: Ask HN: Which is the best book on nutrition?

#40
post #8

I'd start with a movie, not a book. The movie is "Game Changers", directed by James Cameron, and released last month on Netflix and Amazon Video. If you're skeptical about the science behind the movie, read the critique published in Men's Health magazine along with the rebuttal from one of the MD's interviewed in the film. Next I'd read "The Engine 2 seven-day rescue diet" by Rip Esselstyn. If you a more in-depth tre…

I saw Game Changers too. I liked the message, and as someone who built a business on keto, it was an interesting perspective.

But quick research on Google Scholar points out that it's probably hiding some facts. Like vegans may be healthier but get obese too. It helps with diabetes and insulin resistance, but not completely. Gladiators may have been a little fat, as a form of armor.

What's interesting is a quick search turns out that lacto ovo vegetarians do a little better than vegans. So "animal products" might not be entirely bad.

Post reply on HN