Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Good Aeron knock-off/alternative?

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 47 posts

Re: Ask HN: Good Aeron knock-off/alternative?

#31
I can't recommend the Steelcase Leap enough. Maybe I'm in the minority, but I found the Aeron chairs to be somewhat uncomfortable. The Steelcase Leap, on the otherhand... I've had it for a year and couldn't imagine working without one.

I found mine for $100 on Craiglist, so maybe try there.

Re: Ask HN: Good Aeron knock-off/alternative?

#33
Imho, Aeron chairs are overrated, because they lack good neck and head support.

I use a Vitra Headline. Most comfortable task chair in the world. I can code on it for days without feeling that my head is getting heavy and I need to sleep. It's so much relaxing fun I regularly have to drag myself away from the monitor at 3am to go to bed. Truly a revolution.

Re: Ask HN: Good Aeron knock-off/alternative?

#34
The Quantum Mesh Chair from Office Depot is pretty nice, and about $300 new.

Double-check the seat height, though. I'm 5'11" and at the highest setting it's almost too low. I'm not entirely sure if they come in different sizes or if its one-size-fits-all.

Re: Ask HN: Good Aeron knock-off/alternative?

#35
post #27
post #16

Not exactly what you're asking, but I took a chance on replacing my chair entirely with an inflatable exercise ball, and I'm quite happy with the result. It took a week or so to get used to, but my balance has somewhat improved and my lowe back actually seems a little stronger. I'm also putting the money I saved on a chair into buying an adjustable height desk so I can stand & work when I get tired of bouncing on sai…

What kind of desks are you looking into?

Thinking of getting a GeekDesk. You can buy just the frame, then find your own desk top piece (and a hollow-core door from home depot will work just fine)

Re: Ask HN: Good Aeron knock-off/alternative?

#36
Whatever you do, I wouldn't buy the Realspace Pro/Quantum from Office Depot. They may have since fixed the design, but for my current version:

The design for attaching the seatback to the base is poor - all that is holding it up is two metal plates attached to eachother at (about) a 60 degree angle with 2 screws. There is a "slot" one goes into but it is just plastic. Due to this the screws holding up the back have a tendency to snap in half.

Both of my screws broke after 1 month, causing me to go crashing onto the floor. They had a "recall" and distributed a repair kit with new screws but one new screw has already snapped for me. To really fix this chair they would have to do much more than distribute a new pair of screws. Hopefully they have in newer chairs, but I wouldn't risk $250 on it.

This may have to do with weight and height - I'm 6'4 and 190 lbs, so I would place much more stress on the screws than someone shorter. I still wouldn't risk it though.

See: http://www.quantumchair.com/recall/cpsc.html

Re: Ask HN: Good Aeron knock-off/alternative?

#37
post #35
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What kind of desks are you looking into?

Thinking of getting a GeekDesk. You can buy just the frame, then find your own desk top piece (and a hollow-core door from home depot will work just fine)

I think this winter I'm going to build my own version of the GeekDesk. I'll put it on instructables.com or whatever and document it. I'd start today, but I have too many other house projects to do while it is still warm out.

Re: Ask HN: Good Aeron knock-off/alternative?

#38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How long have you had yours? I have a chair from Ikea that was great for about 1.5 years then deteriorated rather quickly.

I have a love hate relationship with Ikea. The rule I've worked out is "buy nothing with moving parts" which would rule out office chairs.

I'm down to 4 out of 6 of these that haven't broken from regular use within the first year: http://www.ikea.com/us/en/catalog/products/70033870

Luckily, I live in the same town as Herman Miller and find good stuff at garage sales every now and then.

Re: Ask HN: Good Aeron knock-off/alternative?

#39

Previously on HN: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=585693 Ergohuman is the closest I can find to the Aeron, but I haven't tried one yet. They're also pretty close to Aeron in price, around $600: http://ergohuman.com/index.html Realspace Pro 9000 is close too: http://www.officedepot.com/a/products/690690/Realspace-PRO-9... A Slate article looking for the 'best desk chair': http://www.slate.com/id/2131646/ Some othe…

Thanks for these links. Very helpful!

Re: Ask HN: Good Aeron knock-off/alternative?

#40
post #2

low-end Aeron (do they exist?) Some of my coworkers saw an ad on Craigslist for a recording studio that was going out of business. They were selling everything, from mixing boards and microphones to computers and Aeron chairs. They got genuine Aeron chairs for about $250 each. Try looking on Craigslist or in the Pennysaver for going out of business type sales.

Got mine last year on Craigslist for ~$400 cash. It's a 2007 with the posture fit support and is fully adjustable. Sure, it was a strange transaction, but my back doesn't mind.
Post reply on HN