Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How is your standing desk working for you?

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 174 posts

Re: Ask HN: How is your standing desk working for you?

#31
My back is fucked up from hard living, and a minor auto collision. Standing desk definitely helps, I stand exclusively when possible.

I have the opposite experience, if you're a fidget-y ADHD person, standing desks can be great. Sitting in a chair all day is torture.

Also invest in an anti-fatigue mat IMO.

Re: Ask HN: How is your standing desk working for you?

#32
I have tried standing desks, and found that standing for long periods is too distracting. I have to shift my weight often to remain comfortable, focus on not locking my knees, etc.

What does work well for me is a treadmill desk. Once you get used to it (it took me a few days) you don't even notice that you're walking. I do find that I have to pause the treadmill to work on particularly difficult problems (I do both front-end and back-end on LAMP-oriented sites), but most of the time my brain can handle both.

edit to add: I work from home, which makes a big difference, I understand that a treadmill desk isn't viable for everyone.

Re: Ask HN: How is your standing desk working for you?

#33
post #30

Standing hurts my feet within 10-20 minutes, but I found a treadmill/walking desk to be something I could do all day long. It helped a lot with back pain, and as a side-effect it cured post-lunch sleepiness. Coding while walking was never a concentration problem for me, so I can only offer that as an anecdotal data point. It might be me, but maybe walking rather than standing makes it easier to concentrate? There wer…

Were you using a good mat at the standing desk? Without one most people will have foot pain.

Re: Ask HN: How is your standing desk working for you?

#34
post #23

I'm looking to buy or make a standing desk now. What desks are you using and do you have any recommendations?

I have a desk from the Human Solution made with reclaimed wood. It wasn't cheap, but it's solid and it looks great. Friends are always complementing me on it. It's been working well for about two years now.

http://www.thehumansolution.com/stand-up-desk-with-reclaimed...

Re: Ask HN: How is your standing desk working for you?

#35

I have an Autonomous AI desk, got it shipped to UAE paying nearly double the price due to shipping and waiting about 3 months. I consider it money well spent. I find that in long stretches of work I really need to switch between standing and sitting else I become irritated. When I work outside home I'm most productive at a specific cafe that has both standup and sit down tables.

Just because you mentioned the UAE, how can I get in touch with you to ask you some trivial questions, regarding this desk?

Re: Ask HN: How is your standing desk working for you?

#36

Makes my lower back pain worse. I also can't get in the 'zone' as easily. I have a powered standing desk and sit at it 90-95% of the time.

Are you overweight? If so losing weight will likely help your back. If you're just inactive doing core and back exercises will help significantly.

Re: Ask HN: How is your standing desk working for you?

#38
I have a Steelcase Airtouch at home that I love, but honestly I don't stand that frequently. I find standing much better for collaboration (but I code alone at home). The Airtouch along with an adjustable monitor arm is a great combination. I end up wanting my screen slightly higher off the desk when I'm standing. One annoying thing for my setup and almost all desk setups that I see is vibrations translating to the monitor. I find a monitor that vibrates while I type very distracting. I use mechanical keyboards so that might accentuate the vibrations. I'm thinking of mounting my monitor on a separate stand like http://www.tvstandsonly.com/P-24273/TV-Stands-for-Expos-with... to completely isolate it from the typing surface

For cramping legs, I have an officemate who uses this: https://www.roguefitness.com/rogue-fidget-bar.

My final recommendation for office workers is to hit the gym with a qualified personal trainer who understands flexibility and range of motion. If you spend most of your day at a desk I will almost guarantee that you have http://www.physio-pedia.com/Low_Back_Pain_Related_to_Hyperlo... caused by your quads spending most of the day contracted leading them to be tight. Working to extend your hip range of motion and core strength will pay dividends in everything you want to do.

Re: Ask HN: How is your standing desk working for you?

#39
I am a twitchy/boderline-ADHD type of guy. When I don't get (a lot) of exercice because of lack of time or whatever other reason I simply cannot concentrate and spend my day changing position in my chair and losing focus.

My sit/stand desk solved that issue and when I'm standing I feel a lot more focused. Even if in the end I'm not moving that much more than while seated, it feels like a world of difference to just be able to step around and move my legs a bit.

Re: Ask HN: How is your standing desk working for you?

#40
I have an ergotron sit-stand desk, and a high-quality foam pad to stand on.

I started my standing experiment with an ikea hack (just a small lack table with a shelf attached for a keyboard). I liked it enough that i invested in an ergotron (I work from home, so my bought my desk setup). I made the decision to invest when I realized I had switched from "okay let me sit down and get to work" to "okay, time to work, let me stand up and get to it".

I still sit during the day, whenever I get tired or something, and when I am not at home I am unable to stand for as long - I think the foam pad makes a huge difference.

Post reply on HN