Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What keeps you from exercising?

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 242 posts

Re: Ask HN: What keeps you from exercising?

#31

I used to start & stop exercising regularly...meaning I'd start going to the gym for a few weeks and then stop out of laziness / lack of motivation. That changed 1 year ago, when I stopped aimlessly 'exercising' and started goal-oriented 'training'. I discovered powerlifting. Its principles and techniques really resonated with me. I was no longer exercising to be 'fit' but 'training' to beat my numbers (I don't do co…

I had a lot of fun when I was lifting (I followed Starting Strength for about four months), but when my lifting partner stopped, so did I.

I've been doing pushups/plank/jumping lunge squats/plank/pushups for a while now, which is nice, but I'm certainly not getting anything near the amount of exercise I'd like to.

So my reasons for not exercising now are two:

1. I don't want to take the time to lift. By the time I stopped lifting, I was taking at least 90 minutes in the gym; probably two hours including changing and showering.

2. I don't have a partner. This helps both for motivation (Steve is waiting for me; I should get going) and for safety/form checks (keep your knees out at the bottom of the squat).

Re: Ask HN: What keeps you from exercising?

#32
I started exercising again mainly because it helps avoid or delay many of the conditions that come with age. At fifty, I can really hear that clock ticking. It also doesn't hurt that being in better shape allows me to keep up with my daughter (now twelve) as we hike, ski, and engage in other active pursuits. Or that I sleep better. Or that I look better, though frankly that would never have been enough all by itself. Wasn't planning to be a model anyway.

The key, for me, has been to tap into both my inner geek and my competitive nature. There was no way I could do this half way. As inanuthshellus put it, I had to make it part of my identity. I committed not just to running, but to being a runner. Starting out, I did a ton of research on techniques and equipment. I run more often than just about anyone I know. I obsess over form and metrics. I work hard to stay on leaderboards for various "segments" or "courses" that I run around town, each and every month (including winter). I'm loud about my running, to reaffirm my identify as a runner. At this point, quitting or slacking off would mean becoming less of something I have striven hard to become, so I keep going even on days when every other factor would point toward not bothering.

This might not be the healthiest attitude in the long term, as my performance will inevitably start to decline some day and that will be hard, but so far it has worked for me. Fortunately, at least in running, there's still plenty of opportunity to compete within one's age group instead of being thrown in with all those twenty-somethings, so even if I do decline I can still hope to decline less than my rivals and my ego can remain intact.

Re: Ask HN: What keeps you from exercising?

#33
I had been going 3x a week for a couple months, but started working full time, and just stopped. I've also started eating poorly again. No real excuse aside from finding time outside of work.

Normally I work 8-5ish then come then have other things I need to get done after.

Re: Ask HN: What keeps you from exercising?

#34
Conviction... We all "know" the right thing to do but we are not convicted within ourselves to do it. Once you find the conviction you will do it. I think that the conviction is hard because most of the threat and risk from not exercising is so far into the future or maybe won't be realized if you have particularly good genetics in a certain area. We are always optimistic about how healthy we are unless we are actually sick (even then...) .

Re: Ask HN: What keeps you from exercising?

#35

First, I don't like it. Most of the time, it is awkward stuff, and horribly boring, exercising just to exercise. I'd rather do so much other stuff. Second, I don't usually find the gains to be motivating. I have trouble sticking with it after a month or two. Third, I'm not really willing to spend money on equipment or go out of my way to a gym. I'd rather not be seen.

I think if people are honest, these are the biggest reasons (particularly 1 and 2). I exercise daily, and #1 is still true. Though not so much the boring part as the unpleasant and awkward part. If you're bored during a workout, you're not exercising hard enough.

It's hard to overcome #2 because it takes about 2-3 months of regular, vigorous exercise to see results, if you're just out-of-shape. If you're very overweight, it'll take even longer to see much difference.

#3 really isn't much of a barrier, since you don't actually require any equipment to get in quite good shape. You certainly don't have to join a gym.

The way to overcome #1 and #2 is to develop a habit of exercising. You do lots of things in your life that are unpleasant in the short term but give you long term gains. You don't do them because of the gains, but simply because after awhile they become habit. Commuting to work, for instance. You don't consciously think about driving in to work so you can get paid in two weeks; you do it out of habit.

You can build an exercise habit slowly, by creating a set of rituals around it (e.g., putting on your workout clothes first thing in the morning, doing a short warmup, finishing with a short cooldown) and starting off slow to minimize #1. This will also minimize gains initially, but that doesn't matter much---you'll get enough gratification just by building up a string of successful completions. Keep your early sessions to 5-15 minutes. Once you've been able to do that daily for a couple of months, extend a couple of your workouts to 20 or 30 minutes. There are a ton of great, free workouts on YouTube (Yoga with Adrienne, Fitness Blender, Millionaire Hoy, and on and on) of various durations. Once you get to a point where you're working out at least 15 minutes every day, with a few 30-minute workouts a week, you will start to see results. By three months in, you should have a fairly strong habit going, and by six months it will seem like second nature.

Re: Ask HN: What keeps you from exercising?

#37
I have been going to the gym, mainly doing weightlifting, for 4 years now.

Whenever I don't go it's due to a lack of free time and energy. This is because I commute two hours a day to and from work, and I have a very active social life. I hit the gym on an average of 3 times a week, though my goal is 5 times a week. I wish my office had a gym.

Your life improves drastically if you exercise. If you really realize how much it benefits you, you will find yourself impatiently waiting until the next time you go to the gym. Not because you want to go to the gym, but because you want the reward that comes out of it.

Re: Ask HN: What keeps you from exercising?

#38
post #16

Note that these aren't excuses. But they make it more difficult for me to exercise. 1. Kids (2 under 2). If I'm not at work, I'm playing with or taking care of them, cooking, etc. there isn't much "me time" as all of it is spent at work. 2. This may sound weird, but I haven't found a comfortable way to keep my private area in place. Most loose shorts / boxers don't work because things move around in some rather uncom…

Get yourself some compression shorts, I don't work out without them.

Re: Ask HN: What keeps you from exercising?

#39
post #16

Note that these aren't excuses. But they make it more difficult for me to exercise. 1. Kids (2 under 2). If I'm not at work, I'm playing with or taking care of them, cooking, etc. there isn't much "me time" as all of it is spent at work. 2. This may sound weird, but I haven't found a comfortable way to keep my private area in place. Most loose shorts / boxers don't work because things move around in some rather uncom…

[deleted]
Post reply on HN