Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: People who completed a bootcamp 3+ years ago: what are you doing now?

news.ycombinator.com

281–290 of 357 posts

Re: Ask HN: People who completed a bootcamp 3+ years ago: what are you doing now?

#281
As others have noted, this is a bit of the "bomber problem".

If in WW2, you would've noted that all of the planes that came back had tons of bullets headed to the underside, you might be tempted to reinforce that particular part.

But you're actually looking at the planes who survived -- not the ones who crashed.

You can put that to the "reading HN today" and "not reading HN today" crowds.

Re: Ask HN: People who completed a bootcamp 3+ years ago: what are you doing now?

#282

As others have noted, this is a bit of the "bomber problem". If in WW2, you would've noted that all of the planes that came back had tons of bullets headed to the underside, you might be tempted to reinforce that particular part. But you're actually looking at the planes who survived -- not the ones who crashed. You can put that to the "reading HN today" and "not reading HN today" crowds.

Not trying to be snarky at all, the formal name for this is Survivorship bias if anyone wants to do some more reading:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias

Re: Ask HN: People who completed a bootcamp 3+ years ago: what are you doing now?

#283
post #175

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I was running a brick and mortar business. I just wanted the coding skills for more leverage. After finishing a bootcamp, I did take a job at a large tech company and then one at a YC startup but I never had any intention of a "coding career". I just wanted to continue learning and see the industry from the inside and to assess what the level of competition truly was in SF/SV. It's been 4 years since my bootcamp expe…

I just met two vets at a makers faire. One was a cop for 8 years, the other doing sales for his small biz. They both are now enrolled in a local code camp (sorry, spacing name). They LOVE it. They're both deeply chagrinned they had never tried that "math geek" stuff before. Now they're talking about starting code camps targeting other vets, help with transitioning to civilian life, build community, mitigate PTSD, wor…

That's awesome! I'm glad it's working out for them.

Re: Ask HN: People who completed a bootcamp 3+ years ago: what are you doing now?

#284
post #65
post #35

Note some selection bias may exist in the answers. If you did a tech bootcamp three years ago and it went fantastically, you're probably reading HN today and will see and reply to this. The more success you had, the more likely you're a developer today! If it went terribly, you might still be working at Starbucks and don't read HN very often.

You can't work at Starbucks and read HN? Seriously, though, after some early career burnout I did a stint at a restaurant job to pay the bills while I decided what I wanted to do with my life...and that was by far my most productive period of time as far as keeping up on general tech news, personal projects, academic research/reading/conferences, etc... A non-code day job can be a great way to have the mental energy…

There is a YouTuber I like to watch sometimes because he occasionally uploads videos demonstrating really unique and high level programming skills.

His day job? A bus driver.

I saw that in the comment section of YouTube, people always ask him "why don't you go code for a job and make tons of money!". His response is that coding is something loves to do, and he wouldn't want to risk losing that love for it, by making it a job.

I love the idea but sadly in the US, living on a bus driver salary would be very difficult. He was based in Finland I believe, so I assume their bus drivers make more money.

Re: Ask HN: People who completed a bootcamp 3+ years ago: what are you doing now?

#285
post #65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can't work at Starbucks and read HN? Seriously, though, after some early career burnout I did a stint at a restaurant job to pay the bills while I decided what I wanted to do with my life...and that was by far my most productive period of time as far as keeping up on general tech news, personal projects, academic research/reading/conferences, etc... A non-code day job can be a great way to have the mental energy…

There is a YouTuber I like to watch sometimes because he occasionally uploads videos demonstrating really unique and high level programming skills. His day job? A bus driver. I saw that in the comment section of YouTube, people always ask him "why don't you go code for a job and make tons of money!". His response is that coding is something loves to do, and he wouldn't want to risk losing that love for it, by making…

living on a bus driver salary would be very difficult

As is often mentioned, that depends on where you choose to live. Around here, I know someone who was a bus driver and a homeowner. She was quite happy with it.

Re: Ask HN: People who completed a bootcamp 3+ years ago: what are you doing now?

#286
post #35

Note some selection bias may exist in the answers. If you did a tech bootcamp three years ago and it went fantastically, you're probably reading HN today and will see and reply to this. The more success you had, the more likely you're a developer today! If it went terribly, you might still be working at Starbucks and don't read HN very often.

I had a great experience, which I shared in another comment here. I agree, however, that there are plenty of folks I studied with who either washed out because they weren't prepared, or haven't accomplished that much because they frankly aren't that smart or hard-working. Those people probably aren't posting here. Boot camps are no silver bullet. Like any kind of education, more is better, and the quality of the stud…

I'm glad you had a good experience, but I'm uncomfortable with your analysis here.

If plenty of folks enter a boot camp and wash out because they aren't prepared, I don't think that's much about the students. I think that's a huge failure on the part of the boot camp program.

The theory of boot camps is that you turn anybody who qualifies into somebody basically competent. E.g., US military boot camp drop out rates are around 10%. If ill-specified student quality is used to justify higher failure rates, then we end up with something almost tautological: only the quality students succeed, and the way you measure quality is by whether or not they succeeded.

Re: Ask HN: People who completed a bootcamp 3+ years ago: what are you doing now?

#287
post #272

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Keep in mind that "senior" or other title doo-dads don't really have a fixed meaning. Also, depending on the workplace you may be undervaluing domain experience. Yeah, of course, a taxi driver isn't going to ascend at Uber because of Taxi driver skills. But a high-skilled experienced CPA with a knack for software development could do really well against 20-something SWE's at a fintech company.

At my company, and every other large company I have worked for titles absolutely have a fixed meaning. There are standard pay bands that are largely predicated on your title.

_Within_ any one company, sure, "senior" may mean something.

But looking across companies... Nope. A "junior" could easily change jobs/employers and land on a "senior" title or vice-versa.

Re: Ask HN: People who completed a bootcamp 3+ years ago: what are you doing now?

#288
post #35

Note some selection bias may exist in the answers. If you did a tech bootcamp three years ago and it went fantastically, you're probably reading HN today and will see and reply to this. The more success you had, the more likely you're a developer today! If it went terribly, you might still be working at Starbucks and don't read HN very often.

>>"What are you doing now? Do you feel that the bootcamp prepared you for the jobs you got? Do you think most of your cohort are still working as developers?"

I don't think selection bias is a problem for the questions the OP asked.

Re: Ask HN: People who completed a bootcamp 3+ years ago: what are you doing now?

#289

Is anyone surprised by the amount bootcamp folks in this thread who are now in "Senior" roles after only a few years? I'm not trying to diminish their accomplishment; Their accomplishment is astounding. But are bootcamps really that effective? I remember interviewing a ton of bootcamp grads from a couple of schools in Austin, TX and being largely unimpressed. You know that feeling after you interview someone where yo…

As another commenter mentioned - this is probably due to selection bias. My best guess is that bootcamps aren't a bad deal for smart motivated people.

Your intuition is correct.

Bootcamps aren't learning institutions - they're fundamentally recruitment agencies. They connect companies with smart, motivated people who can learn things on the fly.

This is why there's such a massive variance between bootcamps. The best bootcamps have the luxury of screening for the best people.

Re: Ask HN: People who completed a bootcamp 3+ years ago: what are you doing now?

#290

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is a YouTuber I like to watch sometimes because he occasionally uploads videos demonstrating really unique and high level programming skills. His day job? A bus driver. I saw that in the comment section of YouTube, people always ask him "why don't you go code for a job and make tons of money!". His response is that coding is something loves to do, and he wouldn't want to risk losing that love for it, by making…

living on a bus driver salary would be very difficult As is often mentioned, that depends on where you choose to live. Around here, I know someone who was a bus driver and a homeowner. She was quite happy with it.

I suppose that's true, and I should keep that in mind more often. I live in California, and though some rural areas do reach that kind of affordability, they're also so remote and disconnected from society that I don't consider them an option.
Post reply on HN