You're missing that ChatGPT has been immediately, practically, and extensively useful to millions of people. Crypto, after more than a decade, has been useful only to criminals and scammers.
Kinda hillarious how this comment concisely mixes logical, factual and semantic errors.
Ask HN: Is anyone else bearish on OpenAI?
241–250 of 321 posts
Re: Ask HN: Is anyone else bearish on OpenAI?
#242Earlier quoted context omitted.
Are you able to give a specific example of a problem it helped you solve? Especially one that you were at a complete blocking point, it provided some solution, and then you were able to continue to expand upon that solution. I keep reading responses like yours, but I haven't seen any specific examples of problems being solved, so it all sounds very abstract. In my interactions with ChatGPT, it felt like just interact…
I think this speaks to the bubble you're in and how your kind of software development probably represents 0.1% of what's out there. I don't even know what WebGPU, Warren Abstract machine or "whatever is that you're trying to do" is. I've been doing dev for ~20 years now, most of the work out there is essentially plumbing events/databases/REST APIs/regexes/JSON/configs/ web UIs in existing and well established framewo…
Re: Ask HN: Is anyone else bearish on OpenAI?
#243Earlier quoted context omitted.
The parent comment claimed they had the value of 15-20 high priced world class consultants from every field, but this makes it seem like it does only the most basic common tasks.
Agreed. I asked it things I actually need help with, not relatively mundane tasks that are easily accomplished by reading documentation. And the fact that it answers so confidently and yet wrong concerns me.
Re: Ask HN: Is anyone else bearish on OpenAI?
#244Earlier quoted context omitted.
I'm not the OP but I had a similar set of experiences with ChatGPT so I find the discussion useful. Essentially I already know how to find what I need using a search engine, and I know how to use cues from the source material to judge if it's correct. When I try using ChatGPT for technical problems I face, I frequently get hallucinated answers that feel like a waste of time. Then I go on HN and read these paeans from…
> Then I go on HN and read these paeans from other technologists who say ChatGPT has completely changed how they work and is 10x better than using Google. I'd like to have that too! I just don't get it, it doesn't match my experience at all. This is exactly my experience and what I am trying to get at. I start feeling that maybe I'm missing out, so I go give it a try. My direct experience shows that it spits out gibb…
Re: Ask HN: Is anyone else bearish on OpenAI?
#245Earlier quoted context omitted.
no way Canvas and Blackboard will be obsolete in a few years. schools can't maintain all this infra system on own
The infrastructure will not be needed. Why keep a static book or a semi-interactive LMS when AIs act as tutors and mentors?
2. School are slow to adopt new techs
Re: Ask HN: Is anyone else bearish on OpenAI?
#246OpenAI, at least in my day-day workflow for the last 9+ months has so superseded anything that google ever was to me that I'm having a difficult time comparing the two. I've got a monitor dedicated 100% of the time to ChatGPT, and I interact with it non stop during the flow of technical scenarios and troubleshooting situations that flow into me - working in areas that I have the slimmest of backgrounds in, and shutti…
So for an MBA major, 80% accuracy at 5% of the cost may be amazing but for me as an engineer and a person who cares, the inaccuracies are catastrophic.
I’m open to suggestions on how to work with this.
Re: Ask HN: Is anyone else bearish on OpenAI?
#247OpenAI, at least in my day-day workflow for the last 9+ months has so superseded anything that google ever was to me that I'm having a difficult time comparing the two. I've got a monitor dedicated 100% of the time to ChatGPT, and I interact with it non stop during the flow of technical scenarios and troubleshooting situations that flow into me - working in areas that I have the slimmest of backgrounds in, and shutti…
My issue with ChatGPT is that it sounds like an expert consultant but I know it’s likely it’s just making up sentences some of the time. And I’d need a real expert consultant to know when. So for an MBA major, 80% accuracy at 5% of the cost may be amazing but for me as an engineer and a person who cares, the inaccuracies are catastrophic. I’m open to suggestions on how to work with this.
So, just like an expert consultant?
Re: Ask HN: Is anyone else bearish on OpenAI?
#248OpenAI, at least in my day-day workflow for the last 9+ months has so superseded anything that google ever was to me that I'm having a difficult time comparing the two. I've got a monitor dedicated 100% of the time to ChatGPT, and I interact with it non stop during the flow of technical scenarios and troubleshooting situations that flow into me - working in areas that I have the slimmest of backgrounds in, and shutti…
Two interesting things it did for me lately: insisted that 8 + 6 = 11 and also proved that P = NP. I don't know which solutions it may be providing you, but it can't be anything too complex, or at least not too abstract.
edit: typo
Re: Ask HN: Is anyone else bearish on OpenAI?
#249Earlier quoted context omitted.
In all honesty I've only been using InstantClaude so far due to the larger context window being something I'd want down the line. What should I be using in your opinion to get the best results? Examples I can think of where it gave wrong info was: - I asked to compare the size of the MacBook m1 and the 16" framework laptops - I asked how to add the nixpgs-unstable channel in NixOS. - I asked to help write a power she…
It's incredible to me that so many people still don't realize that GPT-4 is a completely different level from other LLMs. It's like if an alien visited and the first place they went was to a convention for Special Needs people and then they decided that humans were too stupid to talk to. Or rather, there was a Mensa convention next door with a $20 entrance fee and they figured it wasn't worth it. Or rather, for $20 e…
Re: Ask HN: Is anyone else bearish on OpenAI?
#250OpenAI, at least in my day-day workflow for the last 9+ months has so superseded anything that google ever was to me that I'm having a difficult time comparing the two. I've got a monitor dedicated 100% of the time to ChatGPT, and I interact with it non stop during the flow of technical scenarios and troubleshooting situations that flow into me - working in areas that I have the slimmest of backgrounds in, and shutti…
Are you able to give a specific example of a problem it helped you solve? Especially one that you were at a complete blocking point, it provided some solution, and then you were able to continue to expand upon that solution. I keep reading responses like yours, but I haven't seen any specific examples of problems being solved, so it all sounds very abstract. In my interactions with ChatGPT, it felt like just interact…