Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What are your favorite books or essays written at least 100 years ago?

news.ycombinator.com

231–240 of 247 posts

Re: Ask HN: What are your favorite books or essays written at least 100 years ago?

#231

Maxwell's book on electromagnetism, it shows his hindsight perspective on interpreting the phenomena. One can look at the papers and works he wrote that led up to it, but they are full of detours and unbalanced attention with small dead ends. When he writes his book he tries to convince the audience of his time in one comprehensive work. What I love especially, is that he is very careful and systematic about his conc…

Which book is this? I believe reading the original masters who came up with the discoveries is the way to understanding. It is said that when the Great Mathematician Gauss was asked as to how he made his discoveries, replied; "By studying the Masters and not their Students". There is something about the process of trial and error, testing various hypothesis', going down dead ends and then doubling back and finally li…

severine is correct: it is in A Treatise on Electricity and Magnetism, which can be had free of charge from the Internet Archive.

vol I

https://archive.org/details/electricandmagne01maxwrich

vol II

https://archive.org/details/electricandmag02maxwrich

The relevant section is in the preliminaries in Vol I : I assume you already know electromagnetism, I suggest jumping to pdf pages 52 "on potentials" and reading till 57. No modern textbook will explicitly introduce such an assumption, instead modern textbooks assume the student has been indoctrinated with cartesian product spaces i.e. R^3 etc. Such students would have seen in prior analysis courses that the line integral of the gradient of a scalar function does not depent on the path [... in R^n!]. So if curricula and students implicitly and a priori exclude spaces other than R^n, then no student will protest that for example the line integral of the electric field between 2 points could depend on the exact path, making all subsequent math and theorems more tractable, at the "small price" of a priori excluding the (arguably) confusing possibilities of handles (if you are a mathematiciann), wormholes (if your a physicist).

Maxwell on the contrary refuses compromise on investigative accuracy to "ease the job of didactics", theres many examples of that throughout the treatise.

Re: Ask HN: What are your favorite books or essays written at least 100 years ago?

#232

Maxwell's book on electromagnetism, it shows his hindsight perspective on interpreting the phenomena. One can look at the papers and works he wrote that led up to it, but they are full of detours and unbalanced attention with small dead ends. When he writes his book he tries to convince the audience of his time in one comprehensive work. What I love especially, is that he is very careful and systematic about his conc…

Do you have a place to get a good copy of this? Amazon seems to be turning up those dodgy PDF rips to print.

I got mine from the Internet Archive, see my reply to someone else above.

Re: Ask HN: What are your favorite books or essays written at least 100 years ago?

#234
post #68

Meditations by Marcus Aurelius has been mentioned 5 times in this thread so far. I endorse it as well. This book is the private diary of the Roman Emperor. He doesn’t say anything about politics or much about other people, just exhorting himself to do better and be better. This man walked the walk.

To follow up your recommendation: he was more than a Roman emperor, he was arguably one of, if not the most powerful people on the planet. Some might argue that any Roman Empror was, but his reign I believe was near the zenith of Rome’s Empire in terms of territory (please correct me if I’m wrong). Therefore you’re reading his diary, realizing his own worries, all the while being this person.

In terms of territory, the Empire reached it's zenith under Trajan.

Re: Ask HN: What are your favorite books or essays written at least 100 years ago?

#236
All the essays of Emerson, GK Chesterton, Hazlitt, Oscar Wilde, RL Stevenson, William James

Every book by Nietzsche (except Zarathustra).

La Bruyere - Characters

Charles Mackay - Memoirs of Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds

Ambrose Bierce - The Devil's Dictionary

Re: Ask HN: What are your favorite books or essays written at least 100 years ago?

#239

The Count of Monte Cristo , hands down. Published 1844 by Alexandre Dumas, one of the greatest writers to have ever lived. I’m an avid reader and I always laughed at the idea of having a “favorite” book.. until I found mine. I loved the book so much, I resolved to learn French (et je l’ai fait!) just so I could someday read it in the original French.

Monte Cristo is also my favorite novel by Alexandre Dumas, but I enjoyed many other books he wrote — he used to have assistants that wrote part of his books, and, IIRC, one of them claimed that he was the main author of some novels. I'd recommend reading "Les 3 mousquetaires", where the Lady is one of the most interesting characters I've ever met. The book was a huge success, and is still famous in France nowadays, l…

Not against you in particular but I really hate these sorts of 'behind the scenes' info about authors. I just recently read that Asimov needed a lot of editorial help. It really takes the magic out of it.
Post reply on HN