Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How do you start a website that requires user contribution?

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 54 posts

Re: Ask HN: How do you start a website that requires user contribution?

#21
Another approach is to make it backward compatible with something else. For example, if you wanted to make a new site/network similar to StackExchange (but presumably with some revolutionary changes; not just a "me too" copy), you could start by adding an interface layer using the StackExchange API and adding some of your new smarts to give your users some of the benefit of your tool, on top of the StackExchange content. Most likely you wouldn't be able to add all the new goodness there though, so you would also do as other comments have suggested to build up your own content. Maybe even incentivize users to add stuff based on StackExchange answers they find (assuming some manual intervention is necessary to make the answers suitable for your site - and also assuming you comply with terms of use and such).

It's hard to give exact examples without knowing what you plan to do of course, but that's the general idea. Make it backwards compatible with whatever the closest thing is out there already, so that even in cases where you don't have any of your own content to return for a user, you at least have something. Then do everything you can to ramp up your own content asap.

Re: Ask HN: How do you start a website that requires user contribution?

#22
I've done this. I started with introducing it to a few friends. We made 11 posts its first night. Then I spent $15 on an ad as a sort-of "pre-launch" to see if it would stand up to a little bit of user testing. I checked back in 10 hours and the site had over 100 posts. It was a good start.

The site eventually made it to the top 200k on Alexa.

Re: Ask HN: How do you start a website that requires user contribution?

#25
Having worked on a growth team for a few years and where I incremental millions more active users above trend, the underlying techniques are surprisingly simple.

- implement many different ways you can display the content you have and try to make it relevant

- don't display empty pages, try to show the most relevant content you have even if it's not great

- if you want people to perform an action (here, adding content), ask them to do it and make it easy :)

- send out email or other notifications, giving social context of other people performing the action you want them to perform and with a clear call to action, once again

Re: Ask HN: How do you start a website that requires user contribution?

#26
post #9

[deleted]

You don't have to start a content business in order to take on investment - running something that aligns with your interests can be rewarding enough on its own. Optimizing for what investors like seems shortsighted.

I am not following. Did you mean to reply to my comment? I made some suggestions about how someone might go about getting started in this instance. Did they make sense?

Re: Ask HN: How do you start a website that requires user contribution?

#27

Another approach is to make it backward compatible with something else. For example, if you wanted to make a new site/network similar to StackExchange (but presumably with some revolutionary changes; not just a "me too" copy), you could start by adding an interface layer using the StackExchange API and adding some of your new smarts to give your users some of the benefit of your tool, on top of the StackExchange cont…

Does that work in most cases? Most communities don't provide APIs. A few will provide RSS feeds - not clear if you can legally reuse them like that?

Re: Ask HN: How do you start a website that requires user contribution?

#28
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You don't have to start a content business in order to take on investment - running something that aligns with your interests can be rewarding enough on its own. Optimizing for what investors like seems shortsighted.

I am not following. Did you mean to reply to my comment? I made some suggestions about how someone might go about getting started in this instance. Did they make sense?

Not quite - I replied to a comment just underneath yours that has been deleted. It was something along the lines of "don't start a content business, investors HATE content businesses".

Re: Ask HN: How do you start a website that requires user contribution?

#29

You have to fake it. Yelp seeds every city they enter with paid copywriters for instance, Reddit was entirely fake accounts initially. Airbnb pays for photography of nicer listings. Either hire professional copywriters or recruit unpaid off-site interns to do it for you. Personally the intern method I think works best because they are dedicated to giving you good content, but really rough around the edges and the con…

Will people really agree to an unpaid internship for some brand-new, unknown company? What's the reasoning there?
Post reply on HN